Martin Whincup Profile picture
Feb 19, 2023 13 tweets 7 min read Read on X
I WAS MONTY’S DOUBLE (1958) gave M E Clifton James the opportunity to re-live his wartime experiences on the big screen. But what if his co-stars had done the same, and who were their movie doubles? A thread...

🧵 1/13
Great War veteran, Clifton James, was serving with the Royal Army Pay Corps when, in 1944, he received a call from David Niven, which led him to Operation Copperhead. The Hollywood star didn't appear in the film. Instead, John Mills was Niven's (almost) double...

🧵 2/13
John Mills (Maj Harvey) had his name in lights for most of the war. Not only did he portray all three services on screen - in many ways, Mills was everyone's double - he also served with RE and RA (Monmouthshire Regt) searchlight units in Britain before being discharged.

🧵 3/13
Barbara Hicks (Miss Hester) served in Britain, too, with the Women's Land Army.

An early depiction of the WLA came in A CANTERBURY TALE (1944) - perhaps Sheila Sim was Hicks' double - though a later one - an episode of FOYLE'S WAR - had a land girl called Barbara Hicks.

🧵 4/13
Like Clifton James, Cecil Parker (Col Logan) was a #WW1 veteran. Enlisting in the Royal Sussex Regiment, he finished that war a Tank Corps officer.

An established actor by 1939, his #WW2 work included SHIPS WITH WINGS (1941), a rare depiction of an RN aircraft carrier.

🧵 5/13
Lt Cdr Michael Hordern (Governor of Gibraltar) was no stranger to war aboard an aircraft carrier, thanks to his service on HMS Illustrious.

The war may have paused his acting career, but his clear diction did see him appointed Fighter Direction Officer.

🧵 6/13
Diction was also important for Marius Goring (Karl Nielson).

In between joining the Queen's Royal Regiment in 1940 and serving as a Colonel at SHAEF in 1945, he supervised BBC broadcasts to Germany.

🧵 7/13
Wartime service did delay Leslie Phillips' (Maj Tennant) career.

While he was declared unfit for service ahead of D-Day, a cut glass accent won him a commission in the RA, then the DLI. Maybe, in the training scenes of THE WAY AHEAD (1944), Niven was Phillips' double.

🧵 8/13
Background was also important for John Le Mesurier (RAPC Adjutant), earning him a commission in the Royal Tank Regiment.

He'd serve in India, but knew the same armoured training shown in THEY WERE NOT DIVIDED (1950). In part, was Underdown Le Mesurier's double?

🧵 9/13
In truth, though, the film is packed with ex servicemen.

One cinema scene gives us both Sam Kydd - who, as a POW in THE CAPTIVE HEART (1946), played on personal experience - and "archetypal British officer", Allan Cuthbertson, late of the Royal Australian Air Force.

🧵 10/13
James Hayter (Sgt Adams) and Alfie Bass (a man on a train) had seen service in the Royal Armoured Corps and Middlesex Regiment, respectively.

Both feature here and would end their careers at Grace Brothers, selling gent's outfits in ARE YOU BEING SERVED?

🧵 11/13
Sid James (YMCA Porter) is another comic who makes an impact on the film.

If not quite his own double, James, a former officer in a South African entertainments unit, could have drawn on his experiences for ENSA tribute comedy, DESERT MICE (1959).

🧵 12/13
Not all war stories are cinematic, and not all of those who served wanted to share theirs.

M E Clifton James did, through a hit memoir and a film treatment which, despite its flaws, remains an intriguing record and a reminder of the universality of wartime service.

🧵 13/13.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Martin Whincup

Martin Whincup Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @whincupm

May 4
"You did have the feeling really of a whole age coming to an end."

For Major Denis Healey, #VEDay was the end of an army career that started on Ilkley Moor, ended in Austria, and encompassed some of the fiercest fighting of the Italian campaign...

🧵 1/9 #VEDay80 #WW2 Image
Image
Though Healey had volunteered for the army the day war broke out, he had time to complete his degree and join the Home Guard "to protect Ilkley Moor from attacks from German paratroopers" before he recieved orders to report for basic training.

🧵 2/9 #VEDay #VEDay80 #WW2 Image
Identified as officer material, he was commissioned into the Royal Engineers.

Healey found life in Movement Control dull, so volunteered for Combined Operations, training as a Military Landings Officer. In this role, he was soon bound for North Africa.

🧵 3/9 #VEDay #VEDay80 Image
Read 9 tweets
May 1
🪖 HARDY - 1st May 1945

One of the foremost cartoonists of the 20th century, Carl Giles' reputation was earned on merit but born in war.

Such was his wartime fame that, #OTD in 1945, he became the star of a series of photographs...

🧵 1/9 #AFPUinNWE #WW2 #VEDay80 #VEDay Image
Giles may have spent the final months of the war in Europe in uniform, but his battledress was a recent addition.

Blind in one eye and deaf in one ear, he had initially been rejected for military service, so he turned to the pen rather than the sword.

🧵 2/9 #AFPUinNWE #WW2 Image
First providing cartoons for Reynold's News, his talents were further employed by the Ministry of Information creating animated shorts and then, from 1943 with the Daily and Sunday Express - an association which would last for over 45 years.

🧵 3/9 #AFPUinNWE #WW2 Image
Read 9 tweets
Feb 15
🪖 MALINDINE - 15th February 1945

They say any landing you can walk away from is a good one.

However, AFPU photographer Captain Ted Malindine would have been forgiven for doubting that when he met Major Dick Harden #OTD 80 years ago...

🧵 1/11 #WW2 #AFPUinNWE Image
Harden (seated, second left) was one of a number of liaison officers employed by Field Marshal Montgomery with the brief to get out, gather information and report back to the Tactical Headquarters of 21st Army Group.

🧵 2/11 #WW2 #AFPUinNWE Image
On Friday 9th February, he and fellow Military Cross recipient Captain Carol Mather climbed into a lightweight Auster bound for Nijmegen to survey the progress of the allied advance.

🧵 3/11 #WW2 #AFPUinNWE Image
Image
Read 11 tweets
Jan 25
#OTD 70 years ago, prisoner of war drama, THE COLDITZ STORY (1955) was released.

Packed with pluck and boys own adventure, it cemented an image of that iconic Oflag that's been repeated ever since, but it's not where that popular image began (or ended)...

🧵 1/9 #WW2 #Film Image
Image
Image
THE COLDITZ STORY draws on the smash hit memoir of the film's technical advisor - escaper turned author Major Pat Reid.

Released in 1952, this classic account remains in print, though Reid himself acknowledged it (and his outlook) owe much to another formative influence.

🧵 2/9 Image
Image
Long before he'd set foot inside Colditz, a young Reid had been thrilled by stories of #WW1 POW escapes by the likes of A J Evans.

The one time test cricketer felt "escaping was the greatest sport in the world", an outlook writ large in Reid's chronicals of Colditz.

🧵 3/9 Image
Image
Read 9 tweets
Dec 21, 2024
For many, watching The Great Escape (1963) over the #Christmas period has become an annual tradition.

But, with real wartime experiences to draw on, for some of those involved in the film, the production inspired more than memories of seasonal cinema...

🧵 1/12 Image
Donald Pleasence (Blythe) knew first hand the lot of a prisoner of war.

A Wireless Operator/Air Gunner in the RAF, he was shot down on a daylight raid over France and, after enduring a long march to the Baltic, found himself in a POW camp alongside American airmen.

🧵 2/12 Image
Richard Attenborough (Bartlett) couldn't draw on the same experience, but he had flown over wartime Europe.

A member of the Royal Air Force Film Production Unit, he flew with Bomber Command and filmed the whirlwind being reaped from the exposed turret of a rear gunner.

🧵 3/12 Image
Read 12 tweets
Sep 21, 2024
"In the end, both my engines weren't fully fine"

#OTD in 1944 Flt Lt Jimmy Edwards climbed into his Dakota on a mission to resupply troops at #Arnhem.

After the war, he became a renowned comedian, but his experiences on 21st Sept were no laughing matter...

🧵 1/12 #Arnhem80
Image
Image
Edwards had joined the RAF from Oxford, eventually flying with 271 Squadron in Transport Command.

He'd go on to deliver airborne forces into #Normandy on #DDay, of which he'd later say, "although I was part of it, I felt more like a spectator than anything else."

🧵 2/12 Image: IWM (CL 2166)
Edwards had a similar role on the first day of #OperationMarketGarden, towing a glider as part of the vast armada of aircraft heading for Holland.

Though beset by engine troubles, his Dakota (KG444) returned safely to Britain.

A few days later, he wasn't so lucky...

🧵 3/12 Image: IWM (EA 37974)
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(