As if we don’t have enough going on this week already, we will be getting one or more opinions from the Supreme Court in a few minutes, at 10a. The opinion announcement audio, unlike arguments, will not be livestreamed. #SCOTUS
The first opinion, by Barrett, is in Bartenwerfer v. Buckley, a bankruptcy case. The decision is unanimous, but Sotomayor concurred, joined by Jackson. supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf…
Second decision is in Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. v. Hewitt, a labor case about overtime pay for highly paid employees. The employee wins, in a 6-3 decision by Kagan. supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf…
In Helix Energy, Gorsuch dissents and writes. Kavanaugh dissents and writes, joined by Alito.
The third and final decision is in Cruz v. Arizona. Sotomayor writes the 5-4 decision for the defendant in a capital case about an out-of-control state court decision seeking to prevent the defendant from exercising his rights. Dem appointees are joined by Roberts and Kavanaugh.
Barrett's dissent is not good news for where it shows she is willing to go — with Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch — regarding federal review of criminal cases. (And where she is willing to let state courts go.)
Now, over to Twitter v. Taamneh oral arguments, the aiding and abetting case referenced yesterday, already in progress. supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments…
Waxman: "Justice ..." *stops, pauses, gathers his thoughts*
Gorsuch and Waxman will be doing their Abbott and Costello routine next week at the National Theatre once Gorsuch is feeling better.
PageNet, kids: "The company grew to become the largest wireless messaging company in the world, with more than 10 million pagers in service, and $1 billion in revenues, before the paging industry's rapid decline in the late 1990s." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PageNet
Deputy SG Kneedler is up now, for the government.
Gorsuch is reeeeally making the argument this case should be DIG'ed.
Schnapper is back.
The case is submitted. #SCOTUS is done for the day.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Breaking: #SCOTUS will not stop Florida from carrying out its first execution since the summer of 2019. Tomorrow, Florida is scheduled to kill Donald Dillbeck. There were no noted dissents.
Notably, Dillbeck was sentenced to death after a murder conviction — but only an 8-4 death sentence recommendation. Dillbeck was, in part, asking #SCOTUS to consider and rule on whether a unanimous jury is required in the penalty phase to impose the death sentence.
Only people intentionally seeking to subvert a clear understanding of journalism — and, specifically, the power of The New York Times when it comes to agenda-setting and narrative-changing — would dismiss legitimate questions about coverage by saying they're not activists.
The letter I signed was not asking for the journalists to be activists. It is asking for better, more accurate, more responsible journalism. It is seeking journalism that contextualizes coverage, both within stories and in coverage decisions.
Many unsurprising names, some disappointing names, some disappointing-but-unsurprising names, in a letter that builds off of the dismissive response of Joe Kahn.
#SCOTUS is back today. We’ll be getting orders from last Friday’s conference in 15 minutes at 9:30a ET, followed at 10a ET by oral arguments in the big Section 230 internet algorithm case, Gonzalez v. Google.
"On Friday ... nearly half of the attorneys general across the country made clear that the effort to end medication abortion is the national Republican position." lawdork.com/p/republican-a…
In addition to Mississippi AG Lynn Fitch, here are the other 21 signatories to the brief seeking an end to the FDA's mifepristone approval: lawdork.com/p/republican-a…