Sanjay Profile picture
Feb 22, 2023 20 tweets 6 min read Read on X
THREAD🧵: Loris Karius - A Chance for Redemption 🇩🇪

Yes, I’m making a thread on a player in preparation for what might be the only game he plays for us.

Karius has had an interesting story, and he's now likely to play an integral part for #NUFC on a day of huge importance. Image
Loris Karius is essentially remembered for one game, and one game only. His entire footballing career is unfairly defined by one performance as a 24 year-old, and his career has never really recovered from it.
The first error in that final was just a complete one-off moment, and the second one was a routine bit of handling which went wrong. It happens - especially considering that he was concussed at the time too.

Perhaps the period which settled his fate on Merseyside was actually the pre-season that followed where Karius looked so evidently shot of confidence.

A couple of big errors in friendlies saw him sent out on loan to Besiktas to regain some momentum.

He’s obviously much more than that whole situation though. To be starting in a Champions League final for Liverpool at 24 is clearly indicative of a goalkeeper who had gained the trust of his manager at the very highest level - and getting there requires genuine quality.
Loris Karius was snapped up as a 16 year-old by Man City, played for Germany at youth level, and was seen as one the national team's biggest goalkeeping prospects.

He had played 91 Bundesliga games at the age of 22, when he was given the no. 1 jersey for Liverpool. Image
If you read back through scouting reports from 2016, you’ll see loads of praise for him. “Excellent sweeper”, “brilliant reflexes” and “aerially dominant” were regular phrases to describe him.

That’s the real Loris Karius, and the one that has been forgotten.
Watching back through footage from his Mainz days, his time at Anfield, on loan at Besiktas, and even in the 45 minutes he played for us against Al-Hilal - there’s loads of truth in all of that.
His shot-stopping is satisfactory, and he possesses strong technical and positional fundamentals.

In his last PL season (17/18), Karius had a “goals prevented” (post-shot xG minus goals conceded) of -0.7, which put him 11th out of 27 GKs in the league.

Similarly, his save percentage is usually pretty solid. Obviously the quality of defence affects the quality of shots on target he faces, but the numbers stay consistent even in his Mainz and Besiktas says.

Karius is a solid but unspectacular shot-stopper. Image
I think the area of Karius' shot-stopping to be wary of is his handling - he'll occasionally fumble the ball first time, and pick it up on the rebound if possible.

With Rashford and Fernandes' ability to strike the ball from range with movement, this could be something to watch.
He was earmarked for his aggression from crosses upon signing for Liverpool, although on inspection of footage and numbers, that didn’t seem to always end well.

Pope is arguably the most aerially-dominant GK in the league, and this could be where we miss him the most.
An area where Karius really stands out is his sweeping, amassing the 2nd highest average distance of actions from goal in 17/18.

He’s quick out of his area to mop up behind the defensive line, which is a useful trait to have for any side.

Obviously there’s a risk in this, which increases the chance of errors, but that’s part of the role as Pope showed on Saturday.

Pope’s ability to sweep up is a huge part of our identity, and it’s good that we’ll have a GK who can replicate that.

Karius' ability with his feet is another bonus, and although he won’t be required to do anything fancy with the ball - it’s a useful quality to have.

Liverpool often played short from the back, and that’s reflected in Karius’ numbers.

Karius had the 3rd lowest Avg. Distance per Pass, indicating his ability to play short. Obviously that's part of what's been instructed of him, but it shows that Klopp trusted him to do it.

Also, he's quick to release the ball, which is useful for our counter-attacking threat.
And a final point, as it might come down to it - penalties. Karius has saved 16.7% of penalties in his career (average is around 11%), while de Gea has saved 8.1%.

That could be something that works in our favour if the game goes the distance.

I guess the point of all of this is to show that Loris Karius is more than that memorable sequence of events, and there’s still a player there - and here’s what we can expect of the man between our sticks on Sunday afternoon (unless Howe bins all of this and starts Gillespie 😅).
Karius’ story of promise, heartbreak, difficulties - and hopefully now redemption - is a fascinating one. He’s been through as much as anyone on a football pitch.

Reliving it all has made me appreciate it even more, and I’d love nothing more than for him to shine on Sunday.
The narrative around Loris Karius is as significant as it gets. The biggest game of the century for #NUFC, and we’ll have a keeper with an infamous record in finals making his debut.

But looking away from that, he’s an experienced and skilled goalkeeper. We can depend on him. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sanjay

Sanjay Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @nufcsanjay

Jun 11, 2024
THREAD🧵: Lloyd Kelly - Newcastle United's New Versatile Defender 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

#NUFC are on the verge signing of Lloyd Kelly on a free transfer following his contract expiry at Bournemouth. Eddie Howe has now signed him for the 2nd time in his career - why does he rate Kelly so highly?Image
Kelly came through the academy of Bristol City, where one season as a regular for them in the Championship aged 19 was enough to convince Eddie Howe and Bournemouth’s scouting team to bring him to the Premier League for £13m. Image
A large part of Kelly’s value is derived from his positional flexibility.

He’s had experience as a left-back, as a centre-back in a back four, and on the left of a back three. For a player to be equally comfortable in both roles is valuable to any squad. Image
Read 22 tweets
Dec 29, 2023
THREAD🧵: Newcastle United’s Crucial January Window 🔎

The January transfer window opens in a matter of days, and it's an opportunity for Eddie Howe to strengthen his side. I've taken a look at my preferred options in key areas for #NUFC.Image
It’s difficult to say exactly what positions we should prioritise this window, and what resources we have to sign those players, but what’s for sure is that we need to add more quality to this squad. That’s how we bridge the gap between us and the big six.
RIGHT WINGER:

The priority position has to be a forward of some kind. For me, that needs to be a left-footer who plays predominantly off the right - and ideally (but not mandatory) someone who can play centrally as well.
Read 28 tweets
Aug 18, 2023
THREAD🧵: Lewis Hall - Newcastle United’s Versatile New Talent 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

Eddie Howe has further strengthened his #NUFC squad with the signing of Lewis Hall from Chelsea, on an initial loan with an obligation to buy. With only 9 Premier League appearances, why is Hall rated at £28m? Image
Lewis Hall has only had a brief career in senior football so far, but has deservedly attracted a lot of positive attention.

Having come through the Chelsea academy from the age of 8, Lewis Hall burst onto the first-team scene last season in some style. Image
While Chelsea’s star-studded but misfiring team were struggling in the league, Graham Potter handed a debut to Hall in the EFL Cup at the Etihad, before a Premier League debut at St James. Park.
Read 21 tweets
Jun 23, 2023
THREAD🧵: Sandro Tonali - Newcastle United’s New Midfield Maestro 🇮🇹

#NUFC have gone big in the transfer market again, this time with Italian midfielder Sandro Tonali for £60m. Why is he so highly rated, and why have we moved for him?
Firstly, this is another real statement signing. Much like Bruno Guimarães, and then Alexander Isak, this is a transfer which sends out a signal.

A signal that we’re willing and able to go out and sign some of the top players on the planet.
Sandro Tonali has been a hotly-tipped name in Italian football for many years already - he became a regular in Serie B for Brescia at 17, and hit the ground running at that level. He helped get them promoted the next season, before his first taste of top-flight football at 19.
Read 29 tweets
Jun 13, 2023
THREAD🧵: Yankuba Minteh - Newcastle United’s New Youngster 🇬🇲

The 18 year-old Gambian has become #NUFC’s first incoming of the 23/24 season, having signed for around €7m. Why have the club chosen Minteh, and why is the Feyenoord loan move such a good one for him? Image
Minteh was signed by Odense Boldklub on a 2-year contract last summer after two trials with the club. He was signed for the U19 side, but within the space of two games for them, the coaching staff felt he was already first-team ready.
After scoring the winner against eventual champions FC Copehagen on debut, he went to to become a regular for OB, playing 17 times this season, and starting in 15 of them.

He racked up an impressive 4 goals and 6 assists across these league games.

Read 20 tweets
Jun 8, 2023
THREAD🧵: Newcastle United's 2023/24 Summer Transfer Window 🔎

With transfer season well and truly kicking off, and with #NUFC set to make some important moves, I thought I'd have a closer look at what we need, and who could be most suitable. Image
Having secured Champions League football in the first full season of the new ownership, there’s no doubt that this summer will be one where the hierarchy looks to push #NUFC into a position where that becomes a regularity.
In order to do this, we still need to operate as efficiently as we have so far.

It means finding value in the market - picking up players who not only have quality, but players who can fit seamlessly into Howe’s brand of football, and at prices that don’t see us get ripped off.
Read 27 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(