First, let's talk dollars. The voucher provides $6,000 per student while Georgia general education public high school students only get $4,365. This voucher acts to prioritize discriminatory private schools over Georgia public schools. #GaPol
Next, we know that vouchers take money away that's desperately needed to maintain and improve public schools. Georgia does not provide any funding to educate students in poverty, no money for wifi or security either. Districts just have to ✨find✨ that money somewhere.
So what's the true cost of this bill? We don't know--the author didn't get a fiscal note. How will schools deal with the rising health care costs for bus drivers/parapros/etc (that the state does not pay) while millions are diverted to private schools?
Next, student safety. Did you know that private schools can refuse services for students with disabilities? Or use discipline practices that put these children in danger? What about the fact that the teachers at the private schools don't even have to have a bachelors degree?
If SB 233 was about parent empowerment why don't we ask for protections for these kids? We could demand that participating schools accept all students regardless of disability, religion, gender identity, sexual orientation and language proficiency. This bill does none of these.
Finally, Georgia's constitution states that "no money shall ever be taken from the public treasury, directly or indirectly, in aid of any church, sect, cult, or religious denomination or of any sectarian institution." That's exactly what this bill does
I know it's trendy to tear it down now but the separation of church and state is actually a good idea and worth protecting for both the church and the state. Public dollars need to remain in public schools, not propping up discriminatory private schools. END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Senate Ed and Youth committee will hear a new voucher bill (SB 233) today. I’ve sat in QUITE A FEW of these hearings over the years. Imma try and guess some of the pro-voucher talking points before the meeting. Chime in if I miss any.
“This bill will empower parents to find the school that is best for their child.” Disregard that this same argument could’ve been made in the 1950s in favor of segregation—this bill does nothing to ensure that parents have accurate information of the quality of a private school
If we wanted to empower parents the voucher would require every private school to publish which services they offer and what students they will, or will not, educate and why. Without this transparency, this is just a private school welfare bill.
The actuary (experts that measure the health of pensions) for Georgia's teacher retirement system just suggested something at the May TRS meeting that would just a few years ago would have caused quite a stir, but now might not register!
Let's take a dive into pensions! THREAD
Ok, so if teachers work 10+ years in Georgia public schools then they're offered a pension upon retirement: a percentage of their highest pay depending on how long they worked in the school. The amount will continue until you pass away, and it increases every year for inflation!
To pay for this, TRS gets a rate from teachers (6% of their paycheck) and the state/districts (~20% of the paycheck). But mostly TRS assumes that they'll get a certain amount back from investing all these dollars. Good assumption right? A bunch of us do this with our 401ks
Our children's public schools have taken a $950 million cut during a worldwide pandemic
$10.2 billion cut over the last 19 years
So of course lawmakers have filed HB 60, a voucher to divert hundreds of millions of dollars more to private schools #GaPol legis.ga.gov/legislation/58…
$543 million. That's what the Department of Audits and Accounts calculated a voucher like this would cost the state once fully implemented.
While kids are going to fast food parking lots to do their homework because they don't have internet at home.
Here's bill analysis I wrote about this in 2019.
"Lower test scores are not the only legacy of school vouchers. In Arizona, the state’s Attorney General audited the state voucher system and found 'persistent' misuse of funds year after year."
Here’s a quick 🧵on the version of the budget that just passed out of Senate Approps #GaPol 1/8
Highlights:
-$1.05 billion cut from public school formula
-$25m taken out to pay for more school counselors
-$15m cut from pupil transportation
-$10.6m transferred from GOSA to GaDOE
First, this budget would put us back into the worst years of austerity. 80-90% of school budgets are for salary/benefits so budget cuts are often furloughs and/or firings. $1 billion will go a long way in some districts in wiping out that teacher pay raise from last year. 2/8
Some of that $1 billion cut will be offset by federal CARES dollars. Districts have been granted $411 million to deal with costs associated with COVID-19. Problem is, a lot of those costs are still on the horizon. 3/8