Talia Jane ❤️‍🔥 Profile picture
May 3 23 tweets 8 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
I’m en route and will be live-reporting the vigil for #JordanNeely.

Apologies in advance for typos, dropped words.
Be further advised that when I’m reporting I’m prone to not see messages/DMs until after I’m away; apologies in advance for delays in responding.
Happening now: I’m on the northbound F train platform, where people are expected to gather for a vigil for #JordanNeely.

It seems someone already visited this platform, leaving an ominous message. ImageImage
Several white shirts have arrived to the platform, seemed flustered, decided “this is fine.”

Soon after, many more showed up, including anti-terrorism. Mood is angry, and the police presence, and their escalatory behavior, is intensifying it.
An alt-right troll attempted (twice) to enter the crowd and was ejected. One cop rolled his eyes at another cop before thanking a vigil attendee for their help blocking him from gaining access to the larger group.
An unknown scuffle leads to people chanting “let them go!” and for a white shirt named McGinn to walk right into me and some others, putting us at risk of falling.

No one detained, or fallen into the tracks.

Crowd began chanting. The police response to this is absurd.
Someone made a custom candle of #JordanNeely for the vigil, which is more like a protest, for him. Image
Noticed a member of the press was stuck on the opposite side of the protest/vigil.

Asked him, across the police line, why he was being denied. He said “safety reasons.” I asked the cop standing in front of him if he could elaborate, then cops tried to forcefully eject me??
NYPD at the middle of the platform are substantially more hostile & aggressive than anywhere else.

They’ve got flex cuffs out, anti-terrorism, and have a full police line they’re enforcing.

Further down the platform (‘behind’ the protest), totally different story. twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Image
Someone remarked that the cops toward the mid of the platform “haven’t seen any action since 2020” and that’s why they’re being more aggressive.

Spoke with an NYPD Legal who’s familiar with protests, agreed that the protestors are responding to the tone NYPD is setting.
Protest has moved off the platform and quickly up to the upper level. On attempting to exit the subway, NYPD used the emergency exit to enter.

“NYPD is blocking the exit — and blocking justice!”
Once SRG entered the station, protestors slammed the emergency exit on them.

“Hope you liked that!”
“I did”
Some trash in the street, as someone yells to passersby “A white vigilante murdered a black homeless man, and the NYPD didn’t do anything.”
I have no idea what was going on, but I noticed NYPD moved toward the side of the protest and were picking up speed. Someone starts telling them to leave people alone, then one — the same who aggressed on me — runs toward a boutique, arrests som one inside.
Massive chaos. SRG ran into the crowd from the back, resulting in pushing, shoving, people getting stuck between layers of cops and shoved some more, pushed down, then grabbed while trying to help each other get up.

3 arrests here. Nothing unlawful.
Following 4 arrests for reasons I can’t figure out from witnessing it nor reviewing, protestors are told to retreat, the only people around the van are photogs.

Crowd chants “Say his name! Jordan Neely!” while moving away.
SRG briefly played a recorded message stating that people could not block pedestrian traffic or be in the roadway. This came *after* making arrests.
At the back of the protest, a bicyclist waited in front of scooter cops that followed the march too closely. This is a common tactic to give breathing room.

This time, I observed a scooter bump into her bike as she stood. Then she got back on her bike, was chased, pulled off.
Worth noting TONS of cops I don’t recognize from SRG, Community Affairs. The ones I didn’t recognize are the ones who kept aggressing.

Again: NYPD was setting the tone. This was supposed to be a vigil. They showed up dense, aggro, blocked egress. Suddenly, vigil becomes chaos.
Following this, the march got far enough away that it was able to disperse safely.

5 people arrested by a sloppy NYPD that repeatedly instigated.

They let a man go who choked someone for 15 minutes but violently arrested people who…got stuck in a mob rush they caused.
Jail support is now at the 7th Precinct, where friends & family bring water, snacks, sometimes buy pizza or coffee carafes to share as they wait for their loved ones to be released.

Based on what I saw, can’t imagine charges other than vapid misdemeanors like “discon” or “oga.”
Ending live coverage on the note that I haven’t witnessed NYPD be so inexplicably, preemptively aggressive and hostile in a few years.

Even Nikas, who showed up late, was confused by the chaos, the choices they made, the unfamiliar faces.

They could’ve let this just be a vigil.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Talia Jane ❤️‍🔥

Talia Jane ❤️‍🔥 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @taliaotg

May 5
Please be conscientious about which protests for #JordanNeely you attend. It’s a sick, terrible thing but high profile stories of injustice tend to get co-opted by grifts that exploit tragedy to brand build.

I will do my best to vouch and verify before sharing.
In general, some good parameters:
- Is the organizer directly active in the topic at hand?
- If no to the first, is the organizer flying solo or joined in collaboration with multiple groups that focus on the same topic?
Ex: the vigil for Neely yesterday was initiated by a homeless rights activist. Another upcoming protest is organized by multiple housing rights groups.

On-topic organizing groups typically have speakers with firsthand experience, expert knowledge. Off-topic groups speak broadly.
Read 6 tweets
May 5
Daniel Penny, 24, a Queens resident from West Islip, NY, choked Jordan Neely, 30, on a northbound F train on Monday afternoon.

Neely was reportedly yelling about being hungry and threw his jacket on the ground. Penny jumped up and grabbed him from behind, choking him. 1/
It was reported by NYDailyNews that Penny “separated from service” in 2021. It is unclear what the circumstances of his separation are.

I spoke with a former Marine about their training. He reviewed the footage and provided some speculative insights:
Penny is being represented by Thomas Kenniff, referred to by the NYP as “DA Bragg’s rival.”

Kenniff ran for DA as a Republican. He represented Ed Mullins who pleaded guilty to stealing from the SBA, which donated to Kenniff’s election fund.
Read 8 tweets
May 5
Was in the middle of a friend telling me she couldn’t shake how familiar this guy looked when she found and sent me this thread.

Says she met him once in 2017 at a party her ex, who he played lacrosse with, was throwing. Said he was “kinda intense and quiet in a weird way.”
“I’m not surprised he’s from the south shore of Long Island, honestly. The segregation there is insane,” she says.

“I’m glad at least people who went to high school with him were okay with exposing him, that’s at least a crumb of hope.”
Read 4 tweets
May 4
I ride the subways a lot too and I don’t think people having an episode or who get on the train asking for food & funds “terrorize the entire car.” I just mind my damn business.
Recently was on the train and a guy got on in the midst of an episode, having a heated argument with no one. Passengers freaked out & fled. One sat near me. I pointed out that he was in his own mind, didn’t even know we were there. Suddenly he seemed much less scary to her.
After that moment, she noticeably relaxed into her seat, like her hackles went down, and we chatted casually for a bit about the divestment from mental health resources and the demonization of unhoused people.
Read 15 tweets
May 4
The gassing of a people with apparent religious beliefs in 1930s Germany set off powerful reactions, with some calling the gassing a Holocaust and others defending the Third Reich’s actions as a defense against disorder.

To me, an unbiased outlet, these are two equal positions.
I love to do Unbiased Journalism that definitely does not fall for the same tropes that have shown to legitimize and platform the irrational hate of a small few.
Since we’re doing journalism that platforms hatemongery as simply having a relevant opinion, let’s add to this discussion the debate over whether the MTA should provide passengers with their own nooses or simply set up stocks on the platforms anyone can use.
Read 5 tweets
May 4
NYC isn’t “bracing for riots.” No riots happened, except from cops.

Yesterday’s vigil was met with heavy police response, antagonism. NYPD Legal even agreed the cops were setting the wrong tone.
A lot of people who were there yesterday haven’t been to a protest, or haven’t been out since 2020 when NYPD was being exceptionally aggressive.

Yesterday was very chaotic but carried some very notable examples of how police set that tone and put people into a terror mindset.
On the platform, for some reason NYPD created a police line on one side. On that line was anti-terrorism cops with flex cuffs, threatening arrest to people trying to access the protest. This was not a coherent police line unless the intent was a kettle, and it freaked people out.
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(