Zoe Gardner Profile picture
May 12 9 tweets 4 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
High net immigration figures will be built up into a frenzy in the next weeks. A couple things to remember:

- the rise is driven by people on visas, not asylum seekers, who remain a tiny proportion

- the immigrants are people who bring huge positives to our communities #r4today
- The immigrants being from India & china “instead” of the EU is a neutral.
The only thing that matters is what rights they have on their visas

- More people’s visas now are short-term & highly restrictive, that do not have a pathway to settlement.
That’s not positive #r4today
- Research from @Praxis_Projects has shown how these visa restrictions force many migrants into poverty: in the cost of living crisis, migrants in low income families have ‘no recourse to public funds’ so they can’t access any of the support keeping others going. #r4today
- Research from the GLA & LSE about 18 months ago demonstrated how barring migrants from accessing mainstream social support in this way, not only pushes people into debt & poverty, but ends up costing the taxpayer far more in emergency responses in local authorities #r4today
- My research strongly suggests it is the short-term visas that have proliferated, that are extremely expensive & complicated to extend & renew, that are the key factor forcing people out of the system, living here without authorisation & subject to a hostile environment #r4today
Finally, this insane scaremongering report on US border policy is a deliberate backdrop to our twisted conversation here in the UK

US experts have long warned the extended COVID restrictions on mobility was building up a human catastrophe & draconian response won’t work #r4today
For goodness sake. Of course there’s a record numbers in the border backlog in the US: the government extended an artificial restriction on crossings for 4 years. When you block people at a border point, they build up. This isn’t rocket science but the framing is absurd #r4today
On high net immigration, credible analysts like @jdportes & @M_Sumption @MigObs will be blessing us with worthwhile takes on the ONS migration stats when they come, taking the heat out of the issue by dealing in facts.
Go to them before believing hysterical headlines pls #r4today
Anyway, a lot of you have started following me from refugee stuff in the last year. Hi🥰

I want to emphasise, though, that my interest extends to the rights of *all* migrants, & we'll never have a decent, humane border system till we recognise the humanity of all people who move

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Zoe Gardner

Zoe Gardner Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ZoeJardiniere

May 13
Riddle me this, cos I’m seriously thinking it through.
Starmer is right on a couple of things, namely the Tories are no longer what they used to be, but a far right populist, extremist outfit. And Labour have moved into the ground vacated, & are now a moderate right wing party…
Who is our left or even centre-left option?

Cos it’s fine if Starmer’s Labour is “coming out” as the real Conservatives. You do you.

But neither me, nor my family, nor most young people have ever, nor plan to ever, vote Conservative you see. Not under any name or colour…
So I’m totally unsure what I, or people in progressive big cities are doing come the election to be honest. But if we don’t get a new left party to replace the dominoes shifting to the right, then this country is ridiculous.
You don’t have to point out first past the post to me…
Read 10 tweets
May 10
Today, the government’s “stop the boats” #RefugeeBanBill debated in the Lords

The Bill means when people come to us asking for help, we will no longer assess whether they are refugees or not- We’ll simply lock all of them up, regardless

Only traffickers will welcome it #r4today
People will always try to seek safety in the UK.
We are one of the richest, safest countries on Earth & we colonised a third of it, leaving ties of language & community behind.
We abandoned Afghans, we are abandoning the Sudanese. They won’t give up because of this Bill #r4today
The Bill essentially says the tiny trickle of migrants seeking to rebuild a life by reaching the UK should just go somewhere else

But the international refugee protection system is based on solidarity. If we say “not here” why on Earth would the French not say the same?
#r4today
Read 7 tweets
May 5
It's come to my attention again that few people have any idea what the government's "stop the boats" illegal migration bill does, so:

It ends the right to seek asylum in the UK.

No decsions. No applications will be processed. From Afghans to Albanians. Limbo forever for all.
There are infinitessimally small caveats but this is essentially the truth & the whole story.

In plain & simple terms: No one coming to us for help (or any reason) will have their claim for protection heard anymore, ever.

They'll all be detained, all be left in barges & hotels.
Actually, I shouldnt have used Albania because, exceptionally, while they'll be denied the right to apply for asylum like everyone else, Albanians specifically won't all be in limbo forever, rather illegally deported- meaning any who do need protection will be sent back to danger
Read 6 tweets
Mar 29
I wrote a piece on how to respond to the #RefugeeBanBill and whether safe routes/humanitarian visas are the answer.

Proud of this one, although I don’t know how many friends it will make me..

It’s the principle of territorial asylum we have to defend now opendemocracy.net/en/beyond-traf…
In short, we’re dancing on the head of a pin contorting our demands into the space considered “politically viable” to protect ever shrinking numbers of “good refugees” through safe routes.

No proposal I’ve seen would actually remove the need for some to take irregular journeys..
(And my own proposal I worked on at jcwi is included in that criticism)

So while these visas would be great & help some people, they’re not where our energy should be spent. There’s a bigger principle we’re losing here.

The right to come here however you need to & ask for help.
Read 4 tweets
Mar 28
Not only has the government been housing Afghan refugees in inadequate temporary hotel accommodation for years.

They will also pass the #RefugeeBanBill today that blanket denies protection to ALL Afghans coming & asking for our help & says we’ll send them to Rwanda.
#r4today
I’m not sure how it happened.

How can it be that #r4today has a story on Afghan refugees on THE SAME DAY the government will pass a law through its next stage in parliament that will deny ALL Afghans reaching us protection from now on and not mention it?
How can a Tory MP- WHO VOTED FOR IT be complaining on twitter that:

refusing asylum to Afghans who reach us through desperate means and sending them to Rwanda

Is not what they want? It is EXACTLY what the #RefugeeBanBill does & MPs & the media seem not to have noticed? #r4today
Read 5 tweets
Mar 19
All the client media puff pieces about Braverman’s Rwanda stunt don’t change the fact that it’s morally abhorrent to transport men, women & children and dump them halfway around the world in a country the size of Wales, whose people live under dictatorship & largely in poverty.
The real impact of deportations to Rwanda or of Braverman’s anti-refugee Bill will be to push people back into hiding in trucks, back into the shadows, staying hidden from authorities and at the mercy of criminals & exploitation in our communities. Undocumented numbers will soar.
None of this pagent is really about solving the issue, it’s about laying the ground for the next election, which the government is scared it will lose.
Braverman thinks taking us out of the human rights protections of the ECtHR, like Russia, is the way to save her political skin.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(