#MECFS is often referred to as neglected, under-researched and poorly understood. However this doesn't even scratch the surface when it has been described as one of the biggest medical scandals of this century.
For the last thirty years, an influential group of psychiatrists and researchers have dominated the understanding and treatment of ME.
They redefined it as an ambiguous condition characterised by unexplained fatigue and argued that it was not a disease but rather due to patients being inactive, mistakenly believing they are seriously ill.
They developed CBT and Graded Exercise to address patients' false illness beliefs and deconditioning, but these were recently withdrawn by major health agencies because they were not effective, the research was flawed, and patients reported they were harmful.
This has led to widespread misunderstanding with 80% of doctors mistakenly believing ME is a psychological condition despite it being classified as a neurological disease by the WHO in 1969.
The consequences have been devastating, for example: an Action for ME Survey in 2017 found that 1 in 5 parents of children with #MECFS face child protection proceedings because professionals don't understand or believe in the condition.
The draft 2007 NICE guideline recognised weight loss was a possible feature of ME and recommended a dietitian, nutritional support and tube feeding in extreme cases.
However, Barts ME/CFS clinic (led by Peter White - a proponent of CBT and Graded Exercise and author of the discredited PACE trial) fedback stating "This is alarming and arguably negligent advice, which we strongly condemn."
NICE responded "this recommendation has been removed"
14 years later, the 2021 NICE Guideline now recognises nutritional issues in ME and recommends a dietician and monitoring for weight loss.
To learn more about Severe and Very Severe ME watch this 8 min explainer video.
"I think it may well be a form of depression" Dr Stuttaford talking about ME on the Rantzen Report - M.E. The Secret Epidemic in 1996 - He was booed by the audience and complained about it in an article in the Evening Standard - "I was like Daniel walking into the lions den" twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
The episode recieved a lot of criticism, another article in the Sunday Telegraph stated that The Evening Standard's vision critic sent a copy of the ME episode to the Broadcasting Complaints commission.
Minutes of a program review meeting revealed that BBC executives felt that Dr Stuttaford, had been "set up as an Aunt Sally" and that the show degenerated into a "bearfight".
"I spoke to the GP about it [Long Covid] & he advised me to do this thing called Graded Exercise... when I looked it up loads of people who had ME/CFS or anything like this was saying this is the worst idea, you must not do this"
"The list of symptoms was all too familiar. Forty years apart, Dr Shepherd [Who has ME/CFS] and I had been struck down by almost identical diseases, and - what was worse - been met with very similar responses. Dr Shepherd was a medical mystery. So was I."
"In the four decades between our collapses, almost no progress had been made on uncovering the nature of post-viral disease."
Summary of conversation between @adambeyoncelowe and @davidtuller1 about the new NICE guideline and the new government initiative organised by former Health Secretary Sajid Javid and carried out by the Department of Health and Social Care.
There are 3 ministerial groups: Research, Attitudes and Education and Living with ME. Full details haven't been published yet but It will include implementation of the new NICE guideline and making sure they are adhered to across the NHS.
Adam is on the Attitudes and Education sub group. The health minister has resigned but official information in the public domain is its going ahead and the next Health Minister is committed to it.
Fiona Fox director of the Science Media Centre has a new book out called Beyond The Hype - The Inside Story of Media's Biggest Controversies.
The chapter on ME/CFS "First they came for the communists" is biased, inaccurate and offensive. #BeyondTheHype
🧵Thread
Fox writes glowingly about a group of #MECFS researchers that are being harassed and discredited by a small group of 'activitists' and is concerned that science is under attack. The chapter title appears to liken these 'activists' to Nazis.
Fox claims the 'activists' are in the minority but over 80 charities and over 100 academics don't trust the research and 15,000 people have expresed no confidence in the treatments.
"For 30 years they have been disowned, ignored and lied to by consecutive governments, with no positive answers to their questions about exposure to toxic substances and gases & the affect it had on them"
"Even when I was still in the military, I was getting illness after illness... when I questioned whether it could be anything to do with my service in the Gulf or what we were exposed to, the military line was 'You're talking nonsense, there's no evidence.'"
But new research links the nerve agent Sarin to Gulf War Syndrome in >1000 veterans.
Sarin was released into the air when caches of Iraqi chemical weapons were bombed, it is usually deadly but soldiers were exposed to low doses which is thought to be the cause of GWS.