Bill Kirkup presents on the independent investigation into East Kent Maternity Services at #Anaesthesia2023#OBAnes
Battled with how to put “In their own words…” together. 4 slides at a time doesn’t cut it. It was a very emotive experience. So I hope this works (Twitter Blue perk) #Anaesthesia2023#OBAnes (prelude to #OAA23ASM)
In their own words: FAMILIES.
Midwives, not nurses. They cut me open (@HofkampMichael@emilysharpe@ruthi_landau). He’s singing, then he died. We don’t talk about cesareans. Physician: I’m the doctor. Midwife: we won’t be doing that.
Big egos, cliquey behaviour (OB, midwives). Made to look stupid. Dread going to work. A successful day: getting to car without tears. OB: hearsay & uncorroborated (until there are how many witnesses? How many errors?). Consultants refuse to come in.… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
In their own words: AFTERMATH.
That first slide. I didn’t do my job, but I was handing over remember? That’s a PATIENT being asked if she could have done better. Discipline vs reflect. Cover ups. What caused suffering or extended suffering = lies. Grammar >>> #patientsafety. Why… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
What happened:
Underlying failures - teaming (@AmyCEdmondson keynote from #SOAPAM2023 elsewhere on timeline); respectful workplaces; compassion and listening missing - replicated and repeated cycle of harm. (@SusannaStanford paraphrased in that quote)
MISSED OPPORTUNITIES - EIGHT separate clear opportunities to change course, learn, improve between 2010 & 2018. However, reports met with 3 F’s (disbelief, denial and deflection). Arrogance. Any review met with hostility. All is well, good enough. #Anaesthesia2023#OBAnes… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Action now: a different approach required, after an endless cycle of failures. Can’t assume restricted to East Kent (@DOckendenLtd has demonstrated that, hopefully not worse in Nottingham). No detailed operational recommendations- FOUR areas for action: none easy, all… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Area 1: Maternity Signalling System. Plenty of data, no outcomes. Analyze poorly. Need 4 things. Accept natural variation, trends and outliers.
Area 2: Standards of Behaviour. Staff under strain ≠ excuse bad behaviour. Role models, not teaching. Can’t change vs won’t change?… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Physiological changes in pregnancy. Normal LFT/ laboratory changes. #OBAnes#OAA23ASM
Causes of liver derangement in pregnancy: flare of pre-existing liver disease (known or unknown). Incidence of pregnancy in people with chronic liver disease at King’s College Hospital. Historically, cirrhotic patients have been infertile d/t anovulation. Population based data… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Definition of acute SMM: severe, life threatening event during pregnancy & within 6 weeks of delivery. @NPEU_UKOSS provides UK wide high quality obstetric surveillance. Deaths, while uncommon, investigated in depth.
Prof Donald Peebles on Embedding Maternal Medicine Networks at #OAA23ASM. Knowing who to call is half the solution to any problem? (Touched on by @elsmere_g during #OBAnes session at #Anaesthesia2023)
Direct maternal mortality rate per 100,000 maternities had been decreasing over the last 2 decades, but should a remarkable upswing since 2018, not all accounted for by #COVID19. @mbrrace outlined a case for change: most parts of UK have MDT, but make up variable most without… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
The Maternal Medicine Network (MMN) mandate: ensure timely access to specialist advice and care at all stages of pregnancy. Development of Maternal Medicine specialist centres as regional hub & spoke model = urgent national priority (@DOckendenLtd report)
Why is teamwork important in OB/ #OBAnes? @mbrrace suggests some lessons to be learned. Prompt action is arguably reliant on good communication, within & between teams. Involving consultant/ specialist care early has been a theme for over a decade. #OAA23ASM
@DOckendenLtd’ final report highlighted “conflicting agendas and poor teamwork” contribute to adverse maternal & neonatal outcomes? So how do we create good teams?
The history of @NAPs_RCoA projects and key findings for #OBAnes over the years (failed intubation NAP4 1:390, recent US data 1:808 - gotten better or different methodology?) #OAA23ASM