Abortions rose by ~70,000 in states without bans, but that wasn't enough to make up for the decline. Overall, there were ~24,000 fewer abortions in the U.S. between July '22 and March '23, compared to a pre-Dobbs baseline.
This data is from #WeCount, a project of @SocietyFP, where researchers have been tracking abortion #s for a year. The numbers are estimates and may shift slightly, but it's an extraordinary window into the way Dobbs has already disrupted tens of thousands of Americans' lives.
There is a strong signal in the data that tens of thousands of people are traveling long distances for abortion. Numbers rose massively in areas bordering ban states - esp Florida, Illinois, North Carolina - even as they fell dramatically in ban states like Texas.
And things haven't stabilized yet. We looked at the states that have banned abortion after six weeks and found that abortion in those states tends to drop by 50-60%.
If that happened in FL, where a six-week ban is pending, we could be talking about 4k fewer abortions MONTHLY.
North Carolina is another state that's seen a big surge - and the 72-hour *in-person* waiting period embedded in its new 12-week ban could also be a huge deterrent for people traveling from out of state.
And remember - these are not quick 24-hour trips for many people. I talked to @FundTexasChoice's Anna Rupani, who said that Texans are traveling thousands of miles round-trip. Her fund's average grant was $1k in the past few months, up from $550 in January 2022.
People who get abortions are often socioeconomically vulnerable. They're not people who are used to hopping on planes. Rupani said that many of their callers have never been through an airport security system before.
And then there are the abortions that DIDN'T happen. Some people almost certainly got abortions outside the legal system. But we'll see the full impact of Dobbs in this year's birth numbers.
And thanks to the researchers @SocietyFP who have spent the past year collecting data that gives us almost real-time estimates of how Dobbs is changing America.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
On some key issues for families, Democratic dads look less like D moms and more like...Republicans. This is a big problem for Ds who want more financial supports for families - and bringing your kid to the House floor won't fix it. More @fivethirtyeightfivethirtyeight.com/features/dads-…
Also important to underscore: There simply isn't a consensus about what "parents' issues" even are. Almost half of Democratic dads, for example, think families have it easier today than they did in the 70s. That's a huge divide with Democratic moms.
Issues like (limited) parental leave are more popular with Democratic dads than with Rs, but D dads are less enthusiastic about it than D moms. This is an important reality check for D politicians who seem to assume that these are big priorities for all parents in their base.
The data, collected by researchers at #WeCount, a project led by @SocietyFP, found that abortions did rise in many states in the two months after Dobbs - but that increase wasn't enough to make up for the dramatic decline in the South and Upper Midwest.
Overall, the data suggest that in July/August, over 20,000 women were unable to get an abortion in their home state because of post-Dobbs bans or restrictions. Some of those women appear to have traveled to states like IL and NC. But not everyone could make the trip.
In the wake of the Dobbs decision, I've been thinking about an experience I had last year, when I gave birth to my daughter in southern Indiana. I came into the hospital in labor and they asked me for a urine sample. Turns out, it was for a drug test.
I knew this was a possibility, which is why I asked what the sample was for. I was also drug-tested at various points during my pregnancy - it was hard to pin down staff on when it was happening. But as far as I can tell it was SOP in that practice/hospital.
There's an argument that this is a good thing - pregnant women who are drug-dependent need different kinds of care. But that was not what was happening with me. I told them I didn't want to be tested, and they said they'd treat it as a positive if I refused.
Most Americans don't want the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade. But that tells us less about people's views on abortion than you'd expect. I've spent a lot of time trying to untangle public opinion on abortion and here are the most important takeaways, as I see them:
The vast majority of Americans do not want abortion to be fully illegal. That is, 85-90% think abortion should be available in at least some circumstances, even if they're pretty narrow. Full abortion bans **without exemptions** are extremely unpopular.
After that, the consensus breaks down. About 25-30% of Americans want abortion to be legal in all cases, without any restrictions. And the remaining 55-65% - which is to say, most people - want abortion to be legal in "some or most cases." That tells us very little.
It's wild to come off six months of fully-paid maternity leave and watch the paid family leave proposal dwindle to almost nothing - and possibly get left out altogether. For those who were not recently postpartum, here's what my life was like at various points in my leave:
Week 1: Spent almost entirely in bed. I had complications after my daughter was born and was a wreck when I came home. I literally hadn't slept in days, and was fighting dangerously high blood pressure. I couldn't even make it to my baby's six-day pediatrician appt.
Week 2: Walking up and down stairs was still a project. My husband was back at work, and my daughter was refusing to sleep unless someone was holding her. We were lucky enough to have four grandparents in town, and set up a rotating crew of overnight baby-holders.
I'm seeing takes saying - take a beat, the conservatives questioned the constitutionality of the Texas law, Roe isn't dead.
But if Roe is still good law, then women's constitutional rights are being violated in TX right now. And it's not like you can just postpone an abortion.
This was the tradeoff for the justices. Texas didn't make it easy - it would be unprecedented to enjoin state judges and clerks as a class to keep them from enforcing this law. But the justices made a choice with real, probably lasting consequences for at least some women.
Texas is a big state. It's not easy to go over the border to another state to get an abortion to begin with. And with the exception of NM, Texas is surrounded by states with many abortion restrictions. There have only been more since we published this map. fivethirtyeight.com/features/we-ca…