Craig Scarborough Profile picture
Nov 29 11 tweets 9 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
It's been exactly 3 years since Romain Grosjean's huge accident in Bahrain.
The monocoque was on at the @F1Exhibition in Madrid this summer.
I took some time to look over the tub and noted the damage, which included elements I wasnt aware of...
#F1 #F1Tech
Thread....


Image
Image
Image
Image
Summarising the crash
The car went intact into the barriers at 197kph, at an angle on it's right hand side. This was the biggest deceleration, 67g.
The car jammed in the barrier and flicked around to the left, breaking apart in doing so, the survival cell remaining in the barrier Image
2)With the initial frontal hit to the barriers, the nose box wasnt evident on the car or track in the post crash pics.
But some of the nose is still attached to the right, but little remains on the left.
Most of the length of the nose appears to be used in absorbing the impact.

Image
Image
Image
3) Although the major impact was from the front, it was at such an oblique angle, the right upper side impact structure was crushed and then as the car flicked around both left hand structures were impacted.


Image
Image
Image
Image
4) The tub became lodged between the barriers, but the roll hoop appears undamaged. The shape of the actual structure is evident as the surrounding bodywork was either smashed or burnt away.
Image
Image
5) The effect of the car flicking around after the impact, created such huge forces the drivetrain broke away from the survival cell. But, this ripped a section of rear bulkhead off. This in itself might not have been a major issue, except where the tear in the monocoque went

Image
Image
Image
6) The exposed tank would have been 'safe'. But the section of monocoque that stayed with engine included the fuel filler hole. This ripped of the filler hatch and breached the tank. Allowing the fuel in the full tank to escape, causing the fire.


Image
Image
Image
Image
7) The ensuing fire necessitated Grosjean to escape the car quickly. The Halo jammed open the armco barrier, giving him an escape route. But the initial escape was hindered by a struggle to get the horseshoe headrest pad out of the way.
It's now been left inside the cockpit
Image
Image
8)Unnoticed at the time, was as the car went nose in & flicked around, the chassis cracked almost all the way around!
Thankfully the survival cell remained in one peice
This is a common failure in a nose-in flick-around incident, it needs a @FIA review to prevent future failures.


Image
Image
Image
Image
9) The other issue that delayed Grosjean escaping the fire was his left foot being trapped by the brake pedal, his shoe was left in the car as he escaped.
It looks like it wasn't caused by the pedal itself failing, but by crushing of the footwell, as the car flicked to the left.


Image
Image
Image
Image
Lots of lessons have been learnt and applied to the rules since the accident. Especially the engine bulkhead mounts and fuel filler aperture.
But, IMO it appears there's more to be done in future rules to mitigate against some of the failures seen here.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Craig Scarborough

Craig Scarborough Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ScarbsTech

Jun 17
Williams are another team bringing a big update to their car.
The FW45 has had a thorough aero review, with one set of bodywork readied for #AA22 at the #CanadianGP.
#F1 #F1Tech ImageImage
The floor is the key change. Mostly the underside, but the inlet fences, floor edge and diffuser are more visible changes. The rear brake ducts are reworked accordingly.
#F1 #F1Tech ImageImage
Also the sidepods, feature new inlets and a deeper scallop to the waterslide. Directing more flow to the diffuser.
#F1 #F1Tech ImageImageImageImage
Read 6 tweets
Jun 17
The first big update to the AMR23.
Heavily revised sidepods, floor edge and cooling outlets.
#F1 #F1Tech #CanadaGP ImageImageImageImage
The waterslide is narrowed and starts with a distinct edge. This may be to contain the rotating airflow, which marries up with the revised undercut, to create more load over the diffuser.
#F1 #F1Tech #CanadaGP ImageImage
The undercut feeds into the floor edge further back and with more more load.
The floor edge has been revised, but not in a substantially different way.
The rear tyre temperature sensor is embedded in the floor (red)
#F1 #F1Tech #CanadaGP Image
Read 5 tweets
Apr 1
Corner entry deceleration issues for RBR persist.
#F1 cars 'brake' in several ways. There's the hydraulic brakes, hybrid braking and engine braking. All affect how the car slows & rotates into a turn. From inputs at the pedals, calculated by the ECU.
#F1Tech #AustralianGP
Simply lifting off the throttle gives engine braking. This map can be varied from the steering wheel button (EB or Torque). Altering the throttle/fuelling at that moment.
More EB (up to a point) gives stability/understeer. Less EB gives more rotation.
Confusing things more are the differential settings, that gave a similar balancing effect on corner entry.
Read 5 tweets
Apr 1
Speaking to guests after #AustralianGP Quali, Lawrence Stroll revealed part of the reason for AMR's pace & why LS was a little slower than FA, but much closer today
The bulged sidepods are driven by exhaust vibrations to ease boundary later build up over and the car
#F1 #f1tech
Boundary layer is a phenomena where there's a layer of air stuck to the car. Over long surfaces it builds up & upsets the aero.
AMR tech director Dan Fallows discovered at Red Bull, during the exhaust blown diffuser era, that vibrating the bodywork reduces this. As used on planes
So, the large sidepod flanks are built internally, to be vibrated by the exhausts, not using the exhast gasses, just their movement
The large flanks to the sidepods each house a large internal volume called the 'Resonant Tank'. This shakes the waterslide tunnel and the underfloor
Read 5 tweets
Mar 5
Given the initial success, here's a closer at what probably the most changed car in the grid, the @AstonMartinF1 AMR22.
#F1 #F1Tech
Given the car's pace, the floor edge is very simple so far.
Just a single section, scroll and cut out. No floor edge flap.
There's a lot of development potential in this area.
#F1 #f1tech
Most noticable is the extreme waterslide set up.
Directing flow towards the beam wing/diffuser to added downforce.
The actual size of the gulley is hard to gauge. But, there's a lot of flat level floor exposed around the back of the car.
#F1 #f1tech
Read 7 tweets
Feb 27
During the unveiling of all the new #F1 cars, the terminology of all the shapes and features gets out of hand.
Here's a simple overview of some of the sidepod jargon we use.
Starting with 'coke bottle' this is the way the sidepods slim between the rear wheels
#F1Tech #F12023
This year a new term and popular design feature is 'waterslide', also described as downwash sidepods.
It's where the top surface slopes down the rear.
#F1Tech #F12023 #F1
An old featymure, but one that gets more extreme every year is the 'undercut'.
It's where the front corner of the sidepod tucks in
#F1Tech #F12023 #F1
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(