ChrisO_wiki Profile picture
May 5 29 tweets 7 min read Read on X
1/ THE SINKING OF MOSKVA, PART 5: In this penultimate thread on the sinking of the Russian missile cruiser Moskva on 13-14 April 2022, we'll look at how Moskva was nearly decommissioned because of her poor condition before being reactivated in time for the invasion of Ukraine. ⬇️ Image
2/ For part 1, describing events leading up to the missile strikes, see the thread below.
3/ Part 2 describes how the crew tried to save the ship after two Ukrainian Neptune missiles struck it at 14:20 on 13 April:
4/ Part 3 describes the ship's final hours on 14 April, and the immediate aftermath:
5/ Part 4, evaluating lessons and conclusions from the sinking, is here:
6/ Prior to the war in Ukraine, Moskva had faced an uncertain future. She had been designed as a Cold War carrier-killer, armed with 16 huge Vulkan P-1000 anti-ship missiles, but her secondary role was to provide air defence with her S-300F Fort anti-aircraft missiles. Image
Image
7/ In September 2015, Moskva sailed through the Bosphorus Strait to take up station in the eastern Mediterranean, where she provided air defence cover for the Russian Air Force's Khmeimim air base in Syria until January 2016. Image
8/ On returning to Russia, Moskva was due for a refit and upgrade but due to lack of funds her future became uncertain. She remained at anchor in Sevastopol for most of the following four years with a skeleton crew of 64 men on board (rather than the usual 500+).
9/ According to a dossier compiled by Dmitry Skrebets, the father of a conscript sailor who died in the April 2022 sinking, the ship was used as a floating barracks under the command of a Guard Captain (equivalent to between a NATO lieutenant or major).
10/ As Skhrebets puts it, "Conscripts were housed there, they lived in quarters, marched around the parade ground, learned to stand watch, and did cleaning." It looked likely that the ship, which was already 37 years old at that time and in a poor condition, would be scrapped.
11/ However, Shkrebets says, Moskva was reactivated for political reasons. As the Russian Navy's only ship of the first line in the Black Sea, it was the only ship there that could qualify as a flagship. Without a flagship, the Black Sea Fleet would be downgraded to a flotilla.
12/ By then, Moskva's condition had deteriorated severely. "At that time, the decks on the cruiser Moskva had rotted so much in some places that the dough mixing apparatus (250 liters) fell through the deck onto the generator (this fact was passed on from call to call)."
13/ "And some transformers (approximately 700 kg each) were practically hanging on power cables. They were propped up with improvised means so that when the sea was rough they would not be torn off and injure anyone."
14/ On 5 June 2019, Moskva left the port of Sevastopol in the Black Sea to test her combat systems and main propulsion. A year later, on 9 June 2020, Captain 1st Rank Anton Valerievich Kuprin was appointed as the ship's captain to oversea the ship's restoration. Image
15/ Money had been found to fix the essentials, like the screws, shaft lines, gears and generator, but not to fully repair or upgrade the weapons systems or radars. These remained in a fragile state even as late as February 2022.
16/ Shkrebets writes: "For example: the OSA air defence missile systems on the left and right sides were undergoing modernisation, but the contract for modernisation was not completed in full. They were only partially operational."
17/ "One of the two radar stations had been suspended with cables since 2006 to prevent it from wobbling and [was] welded in place ... On the other – of the two channels, one was semi-working, without gyrostabilisation, with major limitations."
18/ This state of disrepair was very likely a factor in Moskva only detecting the incoming Ukrainian Neptune missiles when they were just 4 km, and a few seconds' flying time, away from the ship.
19/ Moskva was formally reinstated as a ship of the first line on 1 October 2021, by order of the commander of the 11th Anti-Submarine Ship Brigade. The ship was part of this unit, which had been formed on 1 June 1970, consisting of a command, brigade headquarters and six ships.
20/ By this time, preparations for the full-scale invasion of Ukraine were well underway. Russian forces had begun massing in Belarus and on the Russian border from the start of October, so Moskva's hasty reinstatement was almost certainly linked to this effort.
21/ Between 1 December 2021 and 10 February 2022, Moskva was put through K-1 and K-2 exercises intended to develop crew readiness. K-1 exercises are conducted within the naval base, K-2 exercises are performed at sea. However, the K-2 exercises were cut short by the invasion.
22/ Likely to support preparations on other ships, around 100 professional sailors were taken from Moskva's crew (possibly in January 2022 – Shkrebets does not specify) and were replaced with 86 conscript sailors taken from the patrol ships Ladny and Pytlivy.
23/ These men were, of course, untrained in Moskva's systems and emergency drills. The official list of those who died in the April 2022 missile attack indicates that most of the dead were conscripts. Their lack of training likely contributed to their deaths. Image
24/ A final exercise was carried out off Feodosia on 8 February 2022 before being terminated only two days later on 10 February. Shkrebets says they were overseen by the fleet's division commander, who was also the combat group commander at the time.
25/ At the premature end of the exercise, Captain Kuprin wrote a "Reference Report on the Status of the Guided Missile Cruiser 'Moskva'" which concluded that Moskva still had many very serious defects. Despite this, her condition was rated 'satisfactory'.
26/ This was clearly a politically motivated judgement by the Black Sea Fleet command rather than reflecting the alarming contents of Kuprin's report. On 20 February, Moskva set sail on what was to be her first wartime cruise.
27/ TO BE CONTINUED: Moskva goes to war: how Snake Island was captured, and subsequent Black Sea patrols.
@1Truthkeeper Actually on second thoughts, having re-listened to it I wonder if it might be some kind of status code - like the police using "10-4" to mean "message received". "690" could be the Russian Navy code for "we're fucked", perhaps.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ChrisO_wiki

ChrisO_wiki Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ChrisO_wiki

May 6
1/ THE SINKING OF MOSKVA, PART 6: The Russian missile cruiser Moskva participated in Russia's invasion of Ukraine for only 48 days before being sunk. Her logbook, published here in English for the first time, gives a granular account of her activities. ⬇️ Image
2/ This is the final instalment of a 6-part series of threads. For the first part, describing events leading up to the missile strikes that sunk Moskva on 13 April 2022, see below.
3/ Part 2 describes how the crew tried to save the ship after two Ukrainian Neptune missiles struck it amidships and in the stern, setting it on fire.
Read 58 tweets
May 5
1/ Here's how insane Trump's newly announced movie tariff is. As announced, it would apply to US productions filmed outside the US, as well as purely foreign-made films (which are often made with US involvement).
2/ So let's take the upcoming Mission: Impossible – The Final Reckoning. It's been filmed primarily here in the UK, with United Kingdom, with Malta, South Africa and Norway also used. It cost $400 million to make - one of the most expensive films ever.
3/ Trump's tariff would apply a 100% tax to the production cost. So a $400m production would face an approximately $400m tariff charge, doubling the cost to the studio. Great for the US Treasury, right?
Read 13 tweets
May 4
1/ THE SINKING OF MOSKVA, PART 4: The Russian Black Sea flagship Moskva sank on 14 April 2022 after being hit by two Ukrainian missiles the day before, inflicting the Russian Navy's biggest loss in 80 years. This thread looks at possible lessons learned from the sinking. ⬇️ Image
2/ For part 1, describing events leading up to the missile strikes, see the thread below.
3/ Part 2 describes how the crew tried to save the ship after two Ukrainian Neptune missiles struck it at 14:20 on 13 April:
Read 36 tweets
May 3
1/ THE SINKING OF MOSKVA, PART 3: After being struck by Ukrainian missiles on 13 April, the Russian missile cruiser Moskva was abandoned and left to drift burning overnight. This thread tells the story of the ship's final hours, and what happened next. ⬇️ Image
2/ These threads are based on a newly published dossier compiled by Dmitry Shkrebets, the father of a conscript sailor who died in the attack on Moskva. For part 1, describing events leading up to the missile strikes, see the thread below.
3/ Part 2 describes how the crew tried to save the ship after two Ukrainian Neptune missiles struck it at 14:20 on 13 April.
Read 24 tweets
May 2
1/ THE SINKING OF MOSKVA, PART 2: The sinking of the Russian Black Sea Fleet flagship on 13-14 April 2022 was the greatest loss for the Russian Navy since World War II. The father of one of the dead sailors has published an inside account of how it happened. ⬇️
2/ This thread describes Dmitry Shkrebets' account of how the crew tried to save Moskva after two Ukrainian Neptune missiles struck her starboard side at 14:20 on 13 April.

For part 1, see the thread below.
3/ The chaos and confusion aboard the ship after the missiles struck is captured in audio released by Ukraine in May 2022. A Moskva crewman can be heard radioing for help with emergency sirens blaring. "[This is] Moskva", he says, "two hull breaches below [sic] the waterline."
Read 32 tweets
May 2
1/ A detailed inside account of the sinking of the Russian missile cruiser Moskva has been published. It describes how the ship was overwhelmed with fire and smoke, safety systems failed, interior structures collapsed and crewmen jumped out through portholes to save themselves.⬇️ Image
2/ On the afternoon of 13 April 2022, Moskva was struck and set on fire by two Ukrainian Neptune missiles. A day later, the ship sank. Russian authorities said that 396 crew members had been evacuated, with one sailor killed and 27 missing. Image
3/ Dmitry Shkrebets, the father of one of the missing sailors, has compiled an extremely detailed dossier of the events that led up to the sinking and how the sinking itself took place. It includes survivors' first-hand accounts. The ship was in a very poor condition at the time.
Read 31 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(