The basis of most false argument, whether it be climate change denial, genocide denial etc, is the self-referential, circular argument. In which the speaker will make an assertion, which is at best a half-truth, likely an untruth, then argue out from it, as if it were fact.
1/6
We're all familiar with these false arguments. That there was previous climate change not caused by humans, and the climate is always changing. That the genocide in Gaza, is due to the 7 Oct attack. All these assertions are false, specious, on close examination.
2/6
However, you rarely get chance to deal with the initial false premises of these arguments, because those using these false arguments, have in minutes, asserted a whole myriad of other false assertions, on the initial false premise of their argument.
3/6
A valid argument, is always consistent with all the evidence, and other verifiable facts.
The next basis of false argument, is overreaching. Where a person will state a partial truth, only true in some contexts, then massively over-generalize it, into a universal truth.
4/6
Plus, there's usually a whole bag of logical fallacies and other false assertions. All put in a forceful browbeating way, with some slanderous ad hominems, if you try questioning the validity of what they assert.
5/6
I think I've just described modern populist right wing ideology in a nutshell. However, being even-handed, all ideology is stuffed full of these techniques of sophistry. Whilst all ideology, is full of it, the right have taken it to the next level of BS.
6/6
@threadreaderapp unroll
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I want to create a thread to correct some of the misconceptions, and blatant misrepresentation of @GretaThunberg as she sails on the #FreedomFlotilla towards Gaza. Where people are making false assertions, and arguing out from that as if it were fact.
Firstly, and most importantly, @GretaThunberg has never supported terrorism, she has never supported Hamas, or said anything derogatory about Jewish people, or anything even vaguely anti-Semitic. She said "fuck Israel", because of Netanyahu's genocidal actions.
2/
It's falsely claimed that @GretaThunberg has given up on climate protest. This is an absolute lie, as she's been involved in many climate protests, quite recently. As she points out, the climate crisis and the genocide in Gaza, are all part of the same interconnected problem.
3/
The temporary, moderate success of the political right is very simple. They are liars and conmen. They will promise all sorts of things, they can't deliver.
The world and politics is in a complete mess. The populist right are simply trying to take advantage of this.
1/🧵
They appeal to the gullible, with prejudices. It's the immigrants, coming into your countries, stealing your jobs, and subverting your culture, and old well worn strategy of the fascists from the 1920s on. Appeal to prejudices, make impossible promises.
2/
It's amazing how quickly they get discovered, from Brexit, to Trump's tariff wars. Neither, nor the rest, produce the sorts of results those promoting them claimed. Time to whip up the fear about foreign invasions.
3/
Ironically, even oligarchs rely on the cooperation of other human beings, who wouldn't work for and be exploited by oligarchs, if they were as egocentric, and as selfish as the oligarchs themselves. It's just that they only want people to cooperate, when they work for them.
2/
The fine line, kings, lords, capitalists and oligarchs have walked, when they first took over our civilizations. Is how to exploit the cooperativeness of human beings, facilitated by empathy, whilst stopping the people cooperating to get rid of these exploitative parasites.
3/
I have been outspoken in my criticism of our political leaders, essentially all of them, for the last 33 years, who made big pledges at the 1992 Rio Earth Summit.
I want to briefly explain my hypothesis about this.
Before going on, I want to make it clear that my claim that our political leaders lied, and have made one broken promise after another on climate change, isn't just my opinion. This is what @antonioguterres the UN Secretary General also says.
2/
In simple terms, this was what happened. The public were very concerned about climate change, and other environmental matters in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and politicians feared the public would stop voting for them, and turn to green parties.
"The world is facing a new form of climate denial – not the dismissal of climate science, but a concerted attack on the idea that the economy can be reorganised to fight the crisis"
This is not new, it is the story of the last 33 years.
The reason emissions keep rising and no meaningful action has been taken to address the climate and ecological emergency, since the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, is the absurd refusal to change the economic model.
2/
“There are now no non-radical futures. The choice is between immediate and profound social change or waiting a little longer for chaotic and violent social change. In 2023 the window for this choice is rapidly closing.” @KevinClimate
I completely support @johnmcdonnellMP's call. Keir Starmer is a disaster for the Labour Party and the country. It is not just the nasty, neoliberal policy, he is politically incompetent, and gifting Reform an open goal.
1/🧵
Starmer's absurdly callous, position on benefits, and winter fuel payments, has allowed Nigel Farage to position Reform, as more progressive than Labour, which is of course complete and utter BS.
2/
My No.1 issue with Starmer is his climate, environmental and nature, where he is one of the most retrograde governments on these issues, in modern times. But it is much worse than this. He has been a major apologist for genocide in Gaza.
3/