Jake Scott, MD Profile picture
Infectious diseases doc, clinical associate professor, @StanfordDeptMed, antibiotic stewardship director @SOMatSHCTV | opinions my own, no conflicts of interest
Cathleen Groenstein 🇺🇸 Profile picture 1 subscribed
Dec 1, 2023 7 tweets 2 min read
“White lung syndrome” is a made-up term. Any pneumonia appears as a white opacity on an x-ray or CT, which is partly how the diagnosis of pneumonia is made. But it’s not specific to pneumonia, and it’s certainly not specific to Mycoplasma pneumoniae, which is not “mysterious”. 🧵 Mycoplasma pneumoniae is a bacterium, not a virus. (It’s one of the smallest free-living organisms.) It can cause pneumonia in kids age 5-17 and can be severe but is very uncommonly fatal. Radiographic findings vary but can look worse than anticipated from the physical signs. 2/3
Sep 27, 2023 5 tweets 1 min read
Urinalyses (UAs) are widely used, yet are often ordered inappropriately, and the results are not as meaningful as one might think.

Pyuria (WBCs in urine) is nonspecific (although the absence of pyuria should call into question a diagnosis of UTI).
🧵
1/5
Leukocyte esterase is a screening test for pyuria (see above).

Hematuria can occur in patients with UTIs, but is also not specific, and generally doesn’t change management. (If there are clinical signs of obstructive pyelo in a patient with sepsis, check a noncontrast CT.)

2/5
Jan 23, 2023 9 tweets 3 min read
I disagree with this statement:

“…protection against severe disease may only last about four to six months.”

I think that the vast majority of people can expect protection against severe COVID-19 to last much longer than 6 months. 🧵
1/

npr.org/sections/healt… As I’ve previously mentioned, accurately determining the duration of vaccine-induced immune protection is challenging, for many reasons:

1. Many who were vaccinated earlier were at highest risk, which could confound results.

2/
Jan 8, 2023 4 tweets 3 min read
Antibodies continue to get all the attention.

This @washingtonpost piece gives them too much credit, and leaves out the critical role of cellular immunity.

1/

washingtonpost.com/health/2023/01… The main reason why most people need not worry about severe illness caused by XBB.1.5 or any other Omicron subvariant is because non-neutralizing antibodies, memory B cells, & CD4+/CD8+ T cells provide longlasting protection against all variants to date.

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/im…
Sep 3, 2022 4 tweets 2 min read
The Argentinian outbreak of pneumonia was found to be due to Legionnaire’s disease (caused by Legionella bacteria)

This was first recognized as the cause of the outbreak at the American Legion convention in Philadelphia in 1976, which affected 221 people and led to 34 deaths The American Legion outbreak went unsolved for months. Ultimately attributed to airborne spread of a bacterium. Exposure was environmental (not person-to-person) and may have occurred in the hotel lobby.

Legionella grow in warm water, cooling towers, plumbing, fountains, etc. 2/
Jan 17, 2022 7 tweets 4 min read
This thread has gotten a lot of attention, but I think there are a few points worth highlighting:

1st: I’m glad Dr. Wachter’s son has recovered

2nd: I’m not surprised, because #VaccinesWork 🧵 3rd: he states that his 28-yo 3x-vaxxed son is “moderately high-risk” because he’s “overweight.”

If he were *unvaccinated*, yes, being obese (especially if his BMI were ≥30, based on data from meta-analyses) increases the risk for severe outcomes.

bit.ly/3rnDFPM

2/
Jan 3, 2022 4 tweets 2 min read
What’s driving the rapid spread of Omicron?

In this Danish study @LyngseF & colleagues found no significant difference between household secondary attack rates of Omicron (29%) vs Delta (28%) among *unvaccinated* individuals (OR 1.17, 0.99-1.38).
1/
bit.ly/3ESwfbY But the secondary attack rate of Omicron vs Delta was 2.6x higher among fully vaccinated & 3.7x higher among booster-vaccinated individuals.

More evidence that immune evasion is likely driving the rapid spread of Omicron rather than an inherent increase in transmissibility.
2/
Dec 20, 2021 6 tweets 1 min read
I still don’t think people understand how well the vaccines *really* work. So let me try to explain.

I spend most of my time treating patients admitted to the hospital with various infections. My colleagues & I are called to see nearly every hospitalized covid patient.🧵 Last time this year, before vaccines were available, I cared for dozens of covid patients a week. Many of them were older, often from nursing homes, and many of them died. My colleagues & I lost over a hundred patients last year. 2/
Dec 19, 2021 10 tweets 5 min read
How well does vaccine-induced immunity hold up against Omicron?

TL;DR it’s still too soon to know

(it took months to get enough real-world VE data for Delta, FWIW) 🧵 I hear estimates of vaccine effectiveness being quoted as if they’re definitive, but they’re based on small numbers or predictions from modeling, which can’t be relied upon for precision, especially when it comes to determining VE vs severe disease. 2/
bbc.in/3q7o5XH
Sep 26, 2021 7 tweets 2 min read
“Covid-19 vaccine breakthrough infections in Veterans Health Administration” (pre-print)

Retrospective cohort study of ~3 million fully vaccinated people (median age 70) from 1/1/21-8/31/21

Post-vax infection in only 0.37%

Hospitalization in 0.07%

1/5
medrxiv.org/content/10.110… Younger age was associated w/ more post-vax events, attributed to differences in behavior. (aHR 0.65; 95% CI 0.63-0.66; p<0.001)

Differences by type of vaccine: more events in J&J recipients > Pfizer > Moderna

(50% had received Moderna, 43% Pfizer, 7% J&J)

2/5
Sep 16, 2021 8 tweets 5 min read
🧵When I look at the bottom right of this figure from @PHE_uk, I can’t help but wonder why so many people are calling *right now* for Pfizer boosters for people >60 w/o comorbidities.

Effectiveness against hospitalization sustained >=95% x >5 months.
1/
bit.ly/3lvGdZa And then there’s this huge Kaiser matched cohort study. 350k vaxxed matched to 350k unvaxxed.

Median age 65

Moderna vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization out to 5 months (thru June): 95.8%

2/
bit.ly/3Es0qaG
Oct 19, 2020 8 tweets 4 min read
My 2-year-old loves swings. His favorite playground finally opened, but all the swings have been removed.
SF reopened indoor dining before playgrounds.
And indoor dining is limited to 2 hours, while playing at a playground is limited to 30 minutes. bit.ly/2IEDWeg 🧵 When considering the differential in risk of transmission, this is backwards.
As a parent of 2 toddlers who went through their snotty-nosed years, I get it. Kids in general-and playgrounds in particular-are often associated w/ germs. But #SARSCoV2 is different. (2)
Oct 11, 2020 11 tweets 3 min read
As an ID doc who regularly sees #COVID19 patients & is responsible for starting & discontinuing isolation, a few comments:

I understand why there’s distrust but Trump may actually no longer be infectious at this point.

Thread (The fact that he wasn’t properly isolating before this evening is a different story.)

(2/n)
Oct 9, 2020 4 tweets 1 min read
Short 🧵
#COVID19 & post-acute/long-term care facilities:
-Facilities are often unfairly blamed for outbreaks
-As long as the virus continues to spread in communities it will likely make its way into these vulnerable populations, & once it gets in it’s very hard to control (1/4) -There are specific things facilities can do to help keep infection out, like frequent testing, but resources are limited & they need much more support than they’re getting.
(2/4)
Jun 13, 2020 10 tweets 3 min read
I wrote a letter to @nytimes, like many of you, after reading this problematic article, but I never heard back, so I figured I'd include it here. With thanks to: @eliowa @GermHunterMD @dan_diekema @mike_edmond nytimes.com/2020/06/01/hea… As infectious diseases physicians, the specialists primarily responsible for controlling infection within hospitals, we strongly dispute the author’s interpretation of data referenced in the June 1st article, “Medical Workers Should Use Respirator Masks, Not Surgical Masks.”