Michel Estefan Profile picture
Sociologist @UCSanDiego: teaching, pedagogy, social theory. Mexicano. Also on Bluesky as @mestefan.bsky.edu Views my own.

Sep 17, 2022, 8 tweets

If you’re in a DEI position, here’s a quick summary of the findings from the empirical literature focused on prorgrams/initiatives designed to diversify an organization. 🧵#DEI #diversityandinclusion #Sociology #SociologyIsPractical #PublicSociology
#UCSD #UCSDSociology

The first thing to understand is that how the problem is defined already entails a solution. There are three main ways in which the problem has been defined and thus three broad strategies for addressing it:

Approach 1
The problem: mangers in charge of hiring and promotion are biased/racist/sexist/classist.

The Solution: change their beliefs OR their behavior (i.e. make their views or their actions less biased, racist, etc)

Examples: diversity trainings, cultural sensitivity workshops, diversity performance evaluations, anonymous hiring processes.

Do they work: for the most part, nope.

Approach 2
The problem: people from minoritized social groups don’t have access to the resources and networks needed to gain access to an organization and climb the ladder in it.

The solution: Improve their social ties (we call this social capital in sociology).

Examples: networking or affinity groups, mentoring programs.

Do they work? For the most part, yes, especially mentoring programs.

Approach 3
The Problem: no one is held directly accountable for increasing diversity in an organization.

The Solution: hold someone directly accountable.

Examples: creating the position of diversity officer in the C-suite or at least as part of upper-level middle-management. And give them real power.

Do they work? Yes

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling