Sumanth Raman Profile picture
Aug 26, 2019 7 tweets 2 min read Read on X
Imaginary Conversation on J & K:

Me:Is it correct to confine lakhs of people for weeks on end to their homes & cut off all means of communication?

Friend: No it is not

Me: Isn't that what is happening in J&K ? Do you support that?

F:Yes I do.

Me:Why? 1/n

#Kashmir
F: Bcos some of them are terrorists & many of them are anti India.And see what they did to Pandits. Also,70 yrs of violence.Something must be done.

Me:Is Kashmir an integral part of India?

F:Of course it is.

Me: So are Kashmiris Indian citizens?

F:Yes they are but..2/n
F:...many don't see themselves as such.

Me:So it is OK to lock them up?

F:Yes,in the interests of the Nation.

Me: Isn't the nation made up of its people?

F:Of course it is.

Me: Aren't Kashmiris who you just said are Indian citizens part of our people &so the nation? 3/n
F:They are or rather wd fully be if they stop supporting Pakistan or Azadi.

Me:So if you lock them up & cut off communication they will support you?

F:If they are allowed to move freely they will attack our security forces. So they can be confined till situation is calm.4/n
Me:So Indian citizens who are living in an integral part of India that J&K is, cd attack our armed forces but will support India if they are locked up & cut off?

F: Don't be silly. Its also for their own good. Those who aren't separatist sympathizers hv to be protected. 5/n
M:So you agree there are many who are not terrorists or separatist sympathizers in Kashmir?

F: Of course bt a smaller number only.

Me:So is it ok to confine them also up though they are not Terrorists or anti India?

F:What a silly question. How do we identify who is who?6/n
Me:So innocents can be confined for no fault of theirs?

F: In the larger interest of the Nation, Yes.

Me:But they too are the Nation.

F: Get all of them say that first.

Me: How? (Loop continues)

End of Conversation 7/7

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sumanth Raman

Sumanth Raman Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @sumanthraman

Mar 13, 2023
#RRR and #NaatuNaatu winning the Oscars is in many ways a life lesson for us.A catchy tune with a foot tapping dance is how I see the song.Nice but hardly extraordinary. Yet it wins the biggest prize in cinema.Why?Promotion is one big reason. An above average product made to look
extra special by months of promotion.Of course just promotion cannot make any product win but it does make a key difference.If you promote yourself in life you give yourself a better chance at success.There have been many better songs to come out of India but they didn't make it
Maybe there were a dozen reasons why they didn't and promotion may have been just one.But at the end of the day you don't need to be extraordinary to win. People less talented than you are often more successful. Likewise many more talented than you haven't reached where you have
Read 5 tweets
Nov 21, 2022
Time to nail yet another D-stockists story.Charge is that knowledge of Sanskrit was mandatory for learning Medicine in Tamil Nadu and the Justice Party ended this.This is an extract from a Govt. Education report of 1914. Please see the student data.30 Native Christians,2 Muslims
1 Parsi and 56 Non Brahmin Hindus besides the 73 Brahmins in the class. Were all of them proficient in Sanskrit? Were Christians,Muslims &Parsis forced to learn Sanskrit?In fact most Brahmins were also not proficient in Sanskrit. Is there a G.O that said Sanskrit was compulsory?
Is there a G.O issued by Justice Party Govt. later that said Sanskrit was no longer compulsory? Could it have been that Sanskrit knowledge was mandatory for admission to Ayurveda college and this was twisted to Medical College by D-stockists? Sole evidence quoted by stockists
Read 8 tweets
Oct 12, 2022
For those asking what is the problem here it is.
1.Many of the medical terms do not exist in Indian languages and need to be either used in English or hv words created
2.Medical journals are in English and carry the latest updates.Translating every issue would be near impossible
3. Research collaborations are globally mostly in English. How will the Hindi only candidates participate in such research?
4.Creating a database of Hindi Textbooks in Medicine would take years of effort and would need significant resources to keep updated.
5. There will be a demand from regional parties like DMK to have MBBS in regional languages also. This will compound the nightmare manifold.
6. Errors in reading prescriptions and advice already costs 1000s of lives every year. Now translation errors will need to be added
Read 5 tweets
Sep 9, 2022
Conversation with a Whatsapp Uncle yesterday.
Profile: Late sixties,Retired from senior position in a corporate,children in the US. Upper middle class
Thread..
Uncle:So,how is the political scene? Modi will win in 2024,no?
Me:Too early to predict Sir.
U:He has done a great job
Me:On what exactly?
U:Oh,everything.India's stature has grown tremendously
Me:Where? How?
U:I visit my children in US.They say India is regarded highly now
Me:Regarded highly as what,by whom?
U:Our economy is fastest growing in the world.And world leaders seek our PM's opinion
Me:On what?
U:Oh on so many things. BTW have you seen the infrastructure development across India?
Me:What specifically?
U:Roads,bridges,trains,all have improved so much
Me:Has that not been happening for last 25 years steadily?
U:They are happening faster. And no corruption also
Read 12 tweets
Jun 17, 2022
#Queensland amusement park case verdict cd be a classic example of how a prosecution can collude to lose a case. No dispute at all that it is Govt land.Only issue is whether it belongs to HRCE or Revenue Dept.Eviction sought by HRCE quashed bcos they cd not prove it as their land
Why isn't Revenue Dept pressing its case for eviction? Dist. Collector rejected temple claim that the land was theirs. Also judgement says that Queensland offered to provide alternate land and Collector had inspected it. Contrast this with Sastra case where Govt says no
question of accepting alternate land. Two Departments of the same Govt. ostensibly "fight" with each other to allow an encroachment to continue. And shockingly Judgement says Govt is "considering" proposal of Queensland to provide alternate land. Most damning are these sentences
Read 5 tweets
May 30, 2022
On the #Karthikgopinath case the sculptor Padma Shri K V Munuswamy told me that HRCE often does not pay directly for the orders placed.They ask donors to do so on their behalf. For Siruvachur temple idols also he says that an advance was paid by devotees. He says devotees
also paid for the earlier works for the private temple which is nearing completion. He also said that the idols for the HRCE temples at #Siruvachur were being sculpted & work was going on in Villianur near Puducherry.He says he was approached by Karthik Gopinath who had told him
that funding would be through crowd sourcing &that 33 odd lakhs had been collected.Munuswamy says that work is in full swing and in a few months idols would be ready.He told me that HRCE is not directly paying for these idols.Karthik told him funds collected will be used to pay
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(