Samantha Rose Mandeles Profile picture
Nov 19, 2019 10 tweets 7 min read Read on X
I write: @VassarSJP @NationalSJP hate @HenMazzig bc their whole schtick is yelling that Zionists = uniquely, uniformly evil. But Hen is a good person--a Zionist AND a total mensch, & doesn't fit SJP's 'evil Zionist' mold. He proves SJP wrong just by being.
legalinsurrection.com/2019/11/vassar…
THREAD: 2/ It's the same reason @NationalSJP @VassarSJP scream "#pinkwashing." Anything good Israel does contradicts SJP's idea that Israel as a Jewish nation is uniquely, uniformly evil. And since SJP has no substantive argument against the reality of Israel's good works...
THREAD: 3/ ...@VassarSJP @NationalSJP must invent malice where there's none, in order to justify their own bigoted behavior--behavior which, in the end, is much more about making themselves feel important than it is about implementing measurable improvements in Palestinian lives.
THREAD 4/: Similarly, @VassarSJP @NationalSJP can't handle the fact that Jews like @HenMazzig's fam were often victims of Arab & Muslim brutality & exile (which ofc, only *contributed* to the formation & strength of Israel by forcing Jews to flee there) bc...
THREAD 5/: ...if @HenMazzig/ Zionists are bad, but also victimized by the very ppl @VassarSJP wants to cast as victims, SJP's simplistic paradigm & insistence on viewing 🌍 only in terms of *bad white Jewish oppressor vs good brown Muslim/ Palestinian oppressed* falls apart.
THREAD 6/: So if @HenMazzig speaks on that persecution, the facts of which support the idea that 🇮🇱 protects a chronically persecuted ppl (thus ensuring its survival is a moral imperative) @VassarSJP @NationalSJP's entire self-image as *noble defenders of justice* is threatened.
THREAD 7/: Plus, narratives showing that 🇮🇱 is largely *good* for Jews of color is especially hard for @VassarSJP @NationalSJP to deal w/ bc 'intersectional' SJP considers *itself* (not evil Israel) a defender of ALL PoC. So, instead of engaging w these glaring contradictions...
THREAD 8:/...or worse, risk losing the hearts & minds of less gullible students by allowing those students to consider those contradictions (and, you know, *learn*) @VassarSJP @NationalSJP tries to keep @HenMazzig from speaking at all, & others at @Vassar from hearing him.
THREAD 9/: Then, @VassarSJP @NationalSJP justify their obviously illiberal, totalitarian-inspired behavior by claiming moral high ground. It's Orwellian, & shows that SJP thinks that ppl agreeing w you (regardless of ppl's reasons) --rather than evidence--is what makes you right.
THREAD 10/: & why do @VassarSJP @narionalsjp think that? Bc SJP arguments & evidence are weak. Bc SJP's not confident in its own claims. Secure w ur data/ analysis? U'll be ready to listen/ invite ppl to listen to u. Insecure w urself & ur claims? U'll whine/ forbid conversation.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Samantha Rose Mandeles

Samantha Rose Mandeles Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SRMandeles

Mar 6, 2021
Researching @ADL @JGreenblattADL. Found some troubling trends: less focus on Jews/ fighting Judeophobia & more focus on general "anti-bias". Even whitewashing some who've *contributed* to anti-Israel coffers. Why? Do we really need yet another generic social justice org?
Ofc we Jews should do what's right & oppose *all* "ism"s, but we also need to 'put on our own oxygen masks before helping others'. Is @ADL more focused on gaining social justice street cred than confronting *all* anti-Semitism? CC: @LegInsurrection @DrCharlesJacobs

Examples:
Fawning @ADL lesson re @Malala ignores that she gave $50k to "rebuild a UN school" in Gaza (she essentially gave $ to Hamas) destroyed bc Hamas used it as weapon storage!
Plenty of brave women ADL could teach instead who *haven't* (inadvertently or no) helped enable Jew-killers.
Read 10 tweets
Oct 4, 2020
So @AOC won't meet w mainstream Jewish community, incl @ZionessMovement, but will meet w/ anti-Jewish conspiracy theorists from @AMPalestine & Neturei Karta (you know, just those "rabbis" who attend Iran's Holocaust denial conference). WTF. jewishinsider.com/2020/10/new-yo…
This is grotesque. Here she is meeting w/ NK in 2019.
Image
The pic @HenMazzig tweeted features @AOC w NK's Yisroel Dovid Weiss (on the right), who spoke at Iran's Holocaust denial con, met repeatedly w homophobe & anti-Semite Ahmadinejad, & was a guest of Hezbollah murderers in Beirut in 2018.

AOC will meet w him, but not @JCRCNY. ImageImageImage
Read 7 tweets
Sep 1, 2020
Researching @Dreamdefenders trips to "Palestine". @NGOmonitor @JerusalemCenter & others correctly noted how 2016 #DDPalestine trips met PFLP terrorists.

But the 1st trip, in 2015 (w @OsopePatrisse @msladyjustice1 @marclamonthill) did too:

Ali Jiddah, 1968 PFLP bomber. 1/ ImageImageImageImage
Following the 2015 trip, #BLM co-founder @OsopePatrisse took this pic in Northern Ireland & posted on her website, in which she wears a Yasser Arafat keffiyeh. Pic was there as recently as May 2020. It's now gone, as is any mention of #DDPalestine. 2/ ImageImageImageImage
When ppl wonder how @Blklivesmatter platforms & protesters (supposedly for "justice") show overt Jew-hate, bigotry, or violence towards Jews, it's partially this^

Co-founders & prominent activists of BLM approve of Pal terrorism/ blame Jews & Israel for U.S. racism. 3/ ImageImageImageImage
Read 7 tweets
Jul 16, 2020
.@Rav_Mike @jdforward criticizes @simonwiesenthal for condemning "Black leaders/clergy" silence on "Black anti-semitism"; claims we don't similarly ask for White leaders/clergy to condemn "White anti-Semitism." But imho, this misses some crucial points. 1/
forward.com/opinion/450951…
1. Blacks & Jews = both minorities in the USA, both face discrimination (often from the same ppl). So, it can be doubly hurtful to either community if one feels the other has turned on it.

2. The "connection" is that they repeated same Farrakhanist tropes, distinctive to...2/ Image
...Black Separatist movements, whereas "White anti-Semitism" is often rooted in more 'universal'/'broad' anti-Jewish tropes (horns, Holocaust denial, $$$) in which almost all anti-Semites indulge.

3. Many Jews played a big part in the fight for Black civil rights... 3/
Read 10 tweets
Jul 9, 2020
Under guise of "#humanrights", protesters scream "Allahu akbar" & "the Jews are our dogs" at anti-Israel rally. Apparently, "no one is free when others are oppressed" applies to all but Jews--"dogs" to be subjugated. But y'all #notantisemitic tho, right? 🙄 ImageImage
Here's the video, in case you can't see it in my previous tweet (possible if on desktop):

A pic at the rally. Protesters screamed "Jews are our dogs" while appropriating #BlackLivesMatter & #ICantBreath slogan to justify overt anti-Semitism. Will @OsopePatrisse @opalayo @aliciagarza condemn the use of #BLM mvmt to legitimize literal declarations of Jews' inferiority? Image
Read 4 tweets
Jun 30, 2020
Thread: In today's episode of Academics Say the Darndest Things, (former?) @UTAustin prof @spwells says that he "despise[s]" the "Apartheid oppressor" Israelis, who thus all "deserve to die."

What a paragon of moral fortitude & human rights advocacy!

H/t UTA law's @JordanCope12 ImageImage
Meanwhile @UTAustin's response to this grotesque display of hate = almost non-existent; its @Twitter statement is a dismissive, weak-kneed, boilerplate claim that @spwells' contract ended at the end of spring semester.

Yet Wells' @LinkedIn lists his 5-yr job there as 'present'. ImageImage
I looked all over @UTAustin's website & other social media. Not a single statement addressing @spwells' literal call for a second genocide of Jews.

I also looked thru his @Twitter account. He seems to have deleted those tweets & removed his UTA position from his Twitter bio. ImageImage
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(