THREAD: For your weekend enjoyment. I’ve been rewatching #epidemic #pandemic movies this week. Here’s what some of them get right and wrong. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Let’s start with “World War Z.” justwatch.com/us/movie/world… There are lots of zombie/vampire movies/shows out there, many based on the premise that people become zombies/vampires when infected with a virus. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Here’s what “World War Z” gets right: People panic. They get in their cars and run. They loot grocery stores. There are shortages of food, fuel, and medicines. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
And most importantly, “World War Z” gets this right: Walls won’t keep out viruses (or zombies). #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Here’s what “World War Z” gets wrong: No virus has a 12 second incubation period. It takes at least a minute for your blood to travel around the body, and it takes longer for your immune system to induce an immune response. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
And most importantly, “World War Z” gets this wrong: You can’t shoot your way out of a viral outbreak. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Next: “Outbreak.” justwatch.com/us/movie/outbr… This one is based on the #Ebola virus. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Here’s what “Outbreak” gets right: The Motaba virus (based on #Ebola) was awakened by men cutting down trees in the African forest. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Deforestation (& climate change, overpopulation, etc) will lead us to come into contact with more zoonotic (i.e. animal) viruses. We’ll see more and more infectious disease outbreaks if these trends continue. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Here’s what “Outbreak” gets wrong: We don’t bomb villages or towns to contain an outbreak. #Ebola doesn’t liquefy the organs of patients. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
The bleeding/bruising makeup is beyond fake. The fixation on tracking down the infected monkey makes no sense. They’d already isolated the virus. They could just have injected the virus into other animals to make antiserum. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
It would have taken months to make that much antiserum. Also, one monkey could not possibly have provided enough antiserum to save everyone. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
We’ve developed monoclonal antibody treatments of Ebola, but they’re no slam dunk, and none would have cured Renee Russo that quickly. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31774950 #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
Finally, we don’t have a biological/germ warfare program. Richard Nixon shut it down in 1969: ndupress.ndu.edu/Portals/68/Doc… #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
And finally, my favorite of this bunch: “Contagion.” justwatch.com/us/movie/conta… It’s no surprise it’s the most accurate. Dr. Ian Lipkin at @Columbia and @Laurie_Garrett consulted on the film. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett Here’s what “Contagion” gets right: Virus genes can recombine. Bird and pig #influenza can recombine & infect humans. It’s how where new pandemic strains of #influenza come from. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett "Contagion" describes how different kinds of vaccines are made: inactivated/killed vaccines, live attenuated vaccines, and recombinant vaccines. The movie also accurately illustrates how contact tracing works. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett Pandemics can lead to societal and government breakdown. Shortages of food and other essential supplies. Runs on banks. And the like. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett Most importantly, “Contagion” gets this right: Parallel to infectious disease outbreaks emerge parallel outbreaks of fear, mistrust, and disinformation. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett In the film, Alan Krumwiede (played by Jude Law) runs the blog TruthSerumNow. (Note how many of the peddlers of misinformation about the #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak have Twitter handles with “truth” in their name. buzzfeednews.com/article/janely…
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett Krumwiede fakes being sick. He takes homeopathic forsythia on camera. And then fakes recovering from an infection he never had. He then tries to make a fortune selling forsythia. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett Krumwiede also criticizes scientists hard at work to develop a vaccine. (Sound like anyone one Twitter?) #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett And in a show of pseudo-objectivity, cable news puts Krumwiede opposite the head of the @cdc, as if they were equivalent experts who should be given equal weight. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett @cdc What did “Contagion” get wrong? The film focused too much on the U.S. Pandemics play out on a world stage, not in one country. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett @cdc We could never develop a vaccine that quickly (144 days in the movie). In reality, it takes a MINIMUM of a year, and that’s if you’re lucky and already have a head start with related candidate vaccines. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett @cdc You wouldn’t test a new #vaccine by injecting yourself and then declaring it safe and effective if you survived. And vaccines don’t take effect immediately. It takes time for the immune system to respond to #immunization. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak
@Columbia @Laurie_Garrett @cdc I’ve left out some other critiques that are a bit more in the weeds. These are the big ones. Key takehome message: Hollywood gets a lot of the science wrong. But it gets human behavior (fear, panic, rumormongering, opportunism) right. #nCoV2019 #coronavirus #coronavirusoutbreak

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Céline Gounder, MD, ScM, FIDSA 🇺🇦

Céline Gounder, MD, ScM, FIDSA 🇺🇦 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @celinegounder

Nov 17, 2024
1/ I explain how RFK Jr's plans could affect Americans' health.

He is known for falsely claiming that vaccines cause autism & other health issues.

cbsnews.com/video/doctor-e…
2/ RFK Jr: "The problem with the measles vaccine is that it's a leaky vaccine. It doesn't provide sterilizing immunity."

It's true that the measles vaccine doesn't prevent ALL infections.

It's ~97% effective after 2 doses.
3/ In rare cases, vaccinated people may get infected & transmit the virus to others.

This is all the more reason for vaccinating everyone in a community, not just those who feel like it.
Read 13 tweets
Nov 16, 2024
1/ RFK Jr. to lead @HHSGov US Dept of Health & Human Services

with @AdrianaDiaz & @tonydokoupil on @CBSMornings
2/ Kennedy has criticized multiple public health agencies he could now lead.

He's said the @US_FDA's "war on public health is about to end," claiming the agency suppresses anything that "advances human health & can't be patented" by pharmaceutical companies.
3/ But Kennedy's statement demonstrates a common misunderstanding about public health authorities in te US.

We are the United States of America — public health powers reside at the state level.
Read 23 tweets
Sep 19, 2024
1/ A new report from the American Association for Cancer Research @AACR finds that excessive alcohol use is a risk factor for at least 6 cancers.

with @GayleKing @vladduthiersCBS @tonydokoupil
2/ Heavy drinking is associated with an increased risk of:
🔹head & neck cancer
🔹esophageal cancer
🔹stomach cancer
🔹liver cancer
🔹colorectal cancer
🔹breast cancer Image
3/ Drinking during pregnancy can also increase the risk of leukemia later in childhood.

At least 5% of cancers are attributable to alcohol.
Read 19 tweets
Aug 15, 2024
1/ Yesterday, the @WHO declared mpox a public health emergency of international concern (PHEIC).

This is the 2nd time in 2 years that the WHO has declared a PHEIC for mpox.

with @vladduthiersCBS on @CBSMornings
2/ There have already been more than 17K cases in Africa so far this year – more than the total for all of last year.
3/ @WHO announces a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) when there is a significant risk to global health & it requires an internationally coordinated response.

A PHEIC:
🔹helps marshal funding for a public health response
🔹pressures governments to act
Read 22 tweets
Jul 27, 2024
1/ COVID study shows mask and vaccine mandates saved lives

with @CBSNews' @LanaZak cbsnews.com/video/covid-st…
Image
2/ A new study published in the JAMA Health Forum yesterday found that:
🔹mask requirements & vaccine mandates were associated with ⬇️ deaths
🔹prohibitions on vaccine or mask mandates were associated with ⬆️death rates

jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-…
3/ Activity limitations (e.g. closing schools, restaurants, bars; stay-at-home orders; restrictions on leisure time activities & public gatherings) likely provided minimal benefit while imposing substantial cost.
Read 6 tweets
Jul 26, 2024
1/ New Hope Against Dementia: study says singles vaccine also appears to delay onset of dementia
with @CBSMornings' @tonydokoupil @AdrianaDiaz @nateburleson
2/ A study published yesterday in Nature Medicine found that the new Shingrix vaccine was more protective than the old Zostavax vaccine in delaying dementia.

The Zostavax shingles vaccine was discontinued after the Shingrix vaccine was approved.

nature.com/articles/s4159…Image
3/ The Shingrix vaccine is also more protective than Zostavax in preventing shingles.

Shingles is caused by the varicella-zoster virus (VZV), a herpes virus that also causes chickenpox.
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(