We don't have to let local community businesses fail - there are good options if only the Federal government would take the lead. Our coalition has proposed a common sense national rent abatement strategy. Here's how it would work:
(1/14) #covid19Canada
Landlords would waive the first $10K of rent for business most affected by social distancing (restaurants, day cares, barbershops, etc) for three months. Businesses with less than $5M in revenue, so covering pretty much every local community business. (2/14) #savesmallbusiness
They'd ask their tenant to sign a simple document confirming the regular rent amount, and the fact that they waived it. They'd send the document into the federal government, who would write them a check for 66% of the total. Landlord pays one month, gov't pays 2. (3/14)
A national moratorium on commercial evictions would be declared while the details are being worked out. That will give everyone some breathing room, and force landlords and tenants to work together. (4/14)
At tax time next year landlord revenue would be reviewed to ensure the amount waived was accurate, and that it actually happened. A database of landlords receiving subsidies would be posted online for tenants to validate. Anyone abusing would be penalized. (5/14)
We estimate the program to cost $1-1.5B for three months, using StatsCan data. (6/14)
This program would address the fundamental unfairness of the government's current approach, which asks small businesses to take out a loan to pay rent for space they're not allowed to use. Many just can't take on more debt and will fail without help. (7 /14)
It's also a fair deal for landlords. They only lose one month's rent which, given the circumstances, is a great result. It also gives them cash flow now and avoids the uncertainty of rent deferrals for businesses that may never re-open. We just want fair burden sharing. (8 /14)
This proposal was co-written with the Toronto Association of Business Improvement Areas, and organization representing both tenants AND landlords in local communities. We can't let this be a landlord vs. tenant issue. It's a national public health crisis. (9/14)
Before you say "yeah, but property is Provincial jurisdiction," I will point to Australia. They are structured exactly the same way. And their Federal and Provincial governments all agreed on a national strategy for commercial rent. If they can, we can. No excuses. (10/14)
Also, every other comparable country has either grants or fixed costs reductions in place for small business. The US, Australia, the UK, France, Denmark, Singapore, South Korea, China, etc. Canada stands alone in offering only tax deferrals, wage subsidies and loans. (11/14)
Ours isn't the only viable plan. There are other options. But we haven't done enough yet, and need to catch up to the rest of the world. (12/14) #savesmallbusiness
On April 15, tenants who didn't pay April rent can be locked out. On May 1, our surveys say 70% of small business won't make rent. If we don't act now, we will return to communities without our favourite spots, and to families destroyed by losing their livelihoods. (12/14)
There is no time left. We need our governments to come together on a strategy to tackle fixed costs. Our local small businesses closed in order to protect their communities. Now we need to act to protect them (13/14) #savesmallbusiness#Covid19Canada
For more detail, our proposal is posted here, and was submitted to the Federal government in early April. An earlier version was submitted in late March. drive.google.com/file/d/1VD7G31…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Powerful support for more employee ownership in Canada from a very credible source: @BMO is a top lender to majority employee-owned companies in the US.
Opinion: Canada needs policies that make it easier for business owners to sell to their employees financialpost.com/news/economy/o…
As BMO's Christine Cooper writes here, public policy in the US is highly supportive of employee ownership trusts, where all employees receive shares in their company at no cost. The results are proven and well documented.
As she writes: "Recent data ... show that employee-owners have a whopping 92 per cent more net wealth than their non-employee-owner counterparts. This trend is especially true for young people, single women, visible minorities and parents raising young children."
Everyone should do their part to #StandWithUkraine️. That's why so many current and former @McKinsey and @BCG employees are speaking out as other consultancies leave Russia. In contrast, McK and BCG are *pretending* to leave, without actually leaving. A short thread of shame.
On March 3, both McK and BCG CEOs sent out letters to their former employees about severing ties with Russia. However, both letters said they would complete existing engagements with non-state-owned firms. This is a really important distinction and different from @Accenture et al
Consulting engagements will last from 6 weeks to a year. So, a lot of their current work might last through the end of the war. Presumably, they could start taking on new work at that time, meaning their #standwithukraine commitment might only amount to a few delays.
It's not a fun or happy topic, but Provincial political leaders and small business advocacy organizations should be talking about an easier path to bankruptcy as a way to support small business in Canada. #onpoli#cdnpoli 1/ thestar.com/opinion/contri…
Many political leaders, and organizations like @CFIB, @CdnChamberofCom and @RetailCouncil have done great (and tireless) work over the past 20 months keeping businesses afloat amidst rotating shutdowns to protect public health. But for many no amount will help them survive. 2/
Encouraged by governments, many family-owned small and micro-businesses have taken on massive debts and owe huge back rent trying to keep the doors open. Those debts will come due amidst a much worse operating environment. In some cases paying it back will take decades. 3/
@LongosMarkets is a great family-owned grocer, and their customers love it. So why did the Longo family sell out to one of the big three conglomerates?
Empire (Sobeys), Loblaw and Metro own 75% of the Canadian grocery market.
(2/12) restobiz.ca/longos-ranks-a…
Maybe they got an offer they couldn't refuse!
Or, maybe they had no credible alternative.
That's not the case in the US, where US-ESOPs enabled family-owned @Publix, @WinCoFoods, @BrookshireBros and @HarpsFoodStores (and others) to stay independent by selling to their employees.
#SaveMEC is about more than saving a co-op. It’s about preventing another Canadian icon from suffering the same fate as Tim Horton’s: a slow grinding decline under ownership that doesn’t care. So, let’s look at the unimpressive and troubling potential new management of MEC.
Short version: @MEC to be run by three middle-aged white men: a mediocre-at-best American investor, an out-of-work grocery CEO and a COO who might never have managed a store and runs a guns-and-testosterone shoe brand. This should go well!
Long version: First, the buyer, Kingswood, a PE fund out of LA. Its website claims it was founded in 2013, but it only sort of was. Until 2019 Kingswood seems to have been just one guy: Alex Wolf. His first real fund was raised last year, and MEC will be that fund's first deal.
1/ Today we begin phase 3 in Ontario, or, as I like to call it "killing ourselves to pay the rent."
2/ As has been well documented, we know from other places that opening up bars lead to more cases and more deaths. So, people will die. Why are we killing them? To keep these businesses from going under. And what would drive them under? Rent. This is all about rent.
3/ When a bar (or movie theatre or gym) is closed, they lay off their staff and stop buying things. The things they already bought aren't perishable, so there's no cost to holding them. Most of what's left is rent. Bars could stay closed almost indefinitely with no rent.