1/6

Good article, but worrying. Albert Hirschman argued that once a developing country reaches the maximum level of investment it can absorb productively, which I'd argue China did in the past two decades, it must implement the financial, legal, and...
ft.com/content/582411…
2/6

political reforms that allow its workers and businesses to operate productively at higher investment levels. This, he always said, was the hard part, as it always involved changes in the distribution of wealth and political power away from the incumbents.
3/6

I think Hirschman is right. The main difference between advanced economies and developing economies is the nature of their institutions, not the amount of capital invested (it is the former that should determine the latter).
4/6

I would argue that if Beijing really is determined to exercise greater economic control over the private sector, as this article argues (although the jury is still out), it would represent institutional regression in the ability of the economy to use that...
5/6

investment productively. Of course it would give Beijing greater control over the investment process, but while this control hugely benefitted China in the 1980s and 1990s, the conditions were radically different then from now. In those days China was massively...
6/6

underinvested for its level of institutional development.

Today it is overinvested. There is no point, in other words, of trying to return to the rapid growth strategies of the first three decades of rapid growth because the conditions are completely different.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Michael Pettis

Michael Pettis Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @michaelxpettis

6 Oct
1/6

According to this very interesting article Chinese entities have sharply increased their buying of JGBs this year in order to get a yield pickup over USTs, which means, I guess, that they have swapped the JGBs into USD. The article adds:

asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-…
2/6

“The yuan's level is guided in reference to a basket of currencies that includes the dollar, euro and yen. China's currency faces upward pressure because the country's economy recovered relatively quickly from the coronavirus downturn. Selling yuan to buy...
3/6

yen-denominated JGBs helps China ease that pressure.”

Actually, selling yuan to buy any foreign currency bonds helps China ease appreciation pressure, but for me the important question is whose currency is taking the brunt of yuan selling. If Chinese entities bought...
Read 6 tweets
5 Oct
1/4

Beijing is so packed with Chinese tourists right now that several times I have had trouble getting my phone connected, but despite the promise of substantial "revenge spending" during this year's one-week national holiday, consumer spending in...

scmp.com/economy/china-…
2/4

the first four days was still down a whopping 31% from the same period last year.

Even though Chinese tourists cannot go abroad this year, there are still 20% fewer tourists traveling in China than there were last year, and they spent on average 12% less per person.
3/4

That isn't good. I have been relatively bearish about the revival of consumption, but I still expected the national holiday to be better than this. If Chinese tourists remain so cautious about spending, even with the sense that Covid-19 is truly behind us, it is hard...
Read 4 tweets
4 Oct
1/4
The author says that "since 2015, the central bank has allowed the currency to trade more freely. The PBoC’s shift has enabled the renminbi to undertake the same signalling role that the yen historically played regarding the dollars prospects."

ft.com/content/0534f1…
2/4
I disagree with much of this article, but especially the claim that the RMB began trading freely in 2015. In fact what happened is that the PBoC shifted from targeting USD to targeting a basket of currencies (the CFETS RMB Index). If you continue tracking the RMB against...
3/4
the dollar, it might seem that the RMB has become much more volatile, but most of that is simply USD volatility.

Against the basket, on the other hand, the RMB has been very stable: it is less than 1% higher today, for example, than it was four years ago. What is...
Read 4 tweets
2 Oct
1/10
I agree, Adam, that what happened in Japan is a very important story, but I would add that your graph shows Japanese government debt, which is only half the debt story. In the 1980s, when Japan was still growing quickly, private-sector debt grew more rapidly than...
2/10
Japanese government debt. In the 1990s, however, when Japanese GDP growth had pretty much dropped to zero, private-sector debt began to shrink as a share of GDP, just as government debt began its rapid growth.
tradingeconomics.com/japan/private-…
3/10
I think, in other words, that while there was growth in Japanese debt after 1990-92, there was also a lot of shifting of debt from private-sector to government balance sheets. The reason I think this is important is because of what it might tell us about China.
Read 10 tweets
30 Sep
1/4
I think this is a little deceptive. While the RMB may have appreciated against USD during the past three months by 3.7%, this was partly because the dollar was weak. Against the CFETS basket, which is a better measure of the performance of...

ft.com/content/ace4da…
2/4
the RMB, it still performed well, but it rose by 2.8% during the past three months. For what it's worth it rose by 2.7% against the BIS currency basket and 2.3% against SDR.

The point is that analysts who only look at RMB in USD terms may think the RMB has been far...
3/4
more volatile than it really is, but in fact over the past four years it has risen just 0.6% against the CFETS index, and has never been more than 3-4% above or below its current level.

I expect the RMB will remain stable or a little stronger over the rest of this...
Read 4 tweets
29 Sep
1/5
It's not so much Atlanticism but international relations more generally that will remain in retreat no matter who wins the US election, and although the world tends to be obsessed with the US and with its bilateral relationships, this retreat won't...

ft.com/content/09f95f…
2/5
depend on whoever is the US president. People in most countries believe their countries should turn inwards.

I argued in my 2013 book that we were going through a period in which global trade would inevitably contract, geopolitical conflicts...

amazon.com/Great-Rebalanc…
3/5
intensify, and anti-foreign and anti-immigrant feelings rise, and I think this remains a global issue. Perhaps because of its obsession with the US and with, more recently, the Trump circus, much of the world (and the global press) seems to focus on bilateral problems the...
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!