In Greater Manchester, Keir Starmer says at #pmqs, some cases lost in the spreadsheet date back to Sept 18.

It's been described as 'intergalactic incompetence' he says.

Ha. That was from my story/headline on Mon. The person who said it is about to get an unexpected text
Sorry, PMQs really isn't about me - I just wasn't expecting that.
KS notes that rates have risen tenfold in some places under restrictions; yet the PM says it's 'too early to say' whether they're working.

PM: We're continuing to provide £5bn of support for the NW and NE under restrictions.
[Anyone recognise that number? It doesn't immediately seem familiar.]
KS goes through the rates in eg Bury, Bolton when measures came in, vs now. Will he 'level' with ppl there: what's the problem there?
PM: The problem is the disease continues to spread. We're doing a combo of local/national measures. Sometimes KS seems to support; sometimes not
PM: Does he support rule of 6, yes or no?

KS: Yes. [heckling]. But if he doesn't listen to communities saying rates have risen tenfold under restrictions then that's a problem.
Pretty fractious PMQs this, unsurprisingly.

KS notes that in Kirklees had measures brought in when rates were 22/100k. In others, like Hillingdon, not so much. Why?

PM: We're working on a new framework on this.
KS: What's the basis for the 10pm rule? If there's evidence, why not publish it? Will he do so before the House votes on it on Mon?
PM: You accepted this measure two weeks ago; it was designed to reduce the spread of the virus.
PM is going for Labour as flip floppers.
"That's not new leadership; that's no leadership."

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jennifer Williams

Jennifer Williams Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JenWilliamsMEN

7 Oct
More than half the new cases in Manchester are among students, many in halls. Huge frustration in the system here that this was foreseeable; a feeling that there wasn’t and still isn’t a national plan for student return and that lockdown might end up being the price.
Should add that Manchester, politically, remains fiercely opposed to an economic lockdown, largely for that reason (although I imagine that would have always been the case). Suspect we’ll see a swift move towards the north lobbying with one voice, as per recent letters to govt.
That’s not to say that universities themselves have escaped criticism either and the situation with MMU’s lockdown was frankly a PR disaster. But the problem is, the students are back now, paying 9k a year to sit in a flat watching lectures, many self isolating. It’s a mess.
Read 4 tweets
6 Oct
Starting to understand this a bit better. Pillar one labs talk direct to PHE’s database. Pillar two don’t, hence the ridiculous spreadsheet workaround. But surely the bigger q is: why don’t pillar 2 labs talk to PHE’s database (still)?
news.sky.com/story/coronavi…
And yes I am being a nerd about this, but it matters. That statement yesterday didn’t feel like it gave the full picture. DHSC are the data controllers here; they also commissioned the Lighthouse Labs. Blaming PHE solely provides ministerial distance
It also feels like a function of the same/similar issues that were seen with Pillar 2 data earlier in the pandemic, as I think @EdConwaySky is alluding to. Which explains partly why local officials are *just so mad* about this.
Read 4 tweets
5 Oct
Worth reiterating from my thread yesterday that some of these contact tracing delays don’t sound insignificant. Have heard of one case in Oldham that took almost fortnight to reach local teams; yesterday’s data release apparently included Bolton cases dating back to Sept 19.
Both areas have very high infection rates, obviously.
At the same time there’s this: the mystery of ‘local by default’ contact tracing, announced by govt over the summer. Hasn’t happened. Councils are proactively setting up their own systems, but the national one doesn’t seem to have changed (computer glitch aside).
Read 4 tweets
4 Oct
The concerns I’m getting so far re this massive anomaly/backlog in Covid statistics relates to contact tracing as much as anything else. The ‘computer problem’ the PM referred to this morning appears to have resulted in massive delays in positive cases getting to contact tracers
And particularly local contact tracing teams.

This sounds pretty bad, from the messages I’ve been getting here.
One v well placed local source: ‘Basically it was clear last week the national computer systems weren’t working.’ 😬
Read 9 tweets
4 Oct
Andrew Marr asking the PM why the infection rate in Oldham has doubled while they’ve been under extra restrictions. They’re not working are they?

PM: it’s too early to say
Mcr has been under restrictions since the end of July; infection rates are up 10x. Why isn’t it working?

PM: how do you ensure places fight the virus effectively while keeping the economy moving? The way to do it is hands, face, space/ rule of 6.

We’re not under rule of 6, FYI
PM says ‘one of the things that’s been put to us is that by curtailing hours’ (ie 10pm curfew) this can have an effect.

Put to the government by whom?
Read 6 tweets
1 Oct
New: Sounds like Bolton is being taken out of its extra pub restrictions, after Matt Hancock announced it is being brought it in line with the rest of GM. No extra restrictions for GM atm. This is what GM leaders had wanted
(And Tory MPs in Bolton.)
Extra measures for other NW places though: Liverpool city region and Warrington
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!