Another witness Finaldi hoped would bolster his case based on tabloid tales, but fell flat. She believes MJ was innocent.
Finaldi tossed in Quindoy's tabloid tale that he warned staffers "never leave MJ alone with a kid!" (Quindoys spoke positively of MJ until pay-day after Chandlers, this never happened.)
Gayle confirmed no staff told her any such thing. "That's something I would have remembered."
In another part of Finaldi's reoccurring questioning, he attempts to paint Gayle like all the other staff as "untrained" to know about sexual abuse or report it.
Gayle explains to him that her own son *was* abused by a coach and his demeanor had changed dramatically after.
Continuing his obsession over falsely portraying everything in MJ's room as "all boys" Finaldi asked about his "male closet...where he had the boy's pictures and everything."
Gayle: "He had all kinds of everything. He had memorabilia in both closets."
The "secret closet" that guilters love to ramble on about, which was part of the original architect's design years before MJ purchased the house...was also an openly accessible area including to staff & where maintenance crew would enter to fix bathroom piping and utilities.
When Finaldi keeps circling back to how "weird" it was that MJ had pictures of children hanging in his mansion's bedroom closet, Gayle responded:
"They were friends of his. He had pictures of Muhammad Ali in there. There was other pictures in there."
When asked why MJ would let kids stay in his room, Gayle explained how "he didn't know how to say no."
Gayle described how MJ would give out alarm codes to anyone that asked, even if he didn't want kids in.
She also shuts down Finaldi's attempt of spinning that sinister.
On the claim of only ever having boys sleep in his room, Gayle explained (in 93 & in her depo) how "It's not necessarily for male or female...it was like a big slumber party, a big free-for-all..."
This included seeing June, Lily & Jordie on bed watching TV & girls on MJ's lap.
Gayle recalled Jordan, Jason and Gavin all acting like brats.
She did not believe the allegations and noted that MJ never directly talked to her about the Chandler case or heard MJ telling anyone else about it.
(Wade/James claim he called them & coached them to lie for him.)
Gayle again comments on how she had seen Jordie with his MOTHER and SISTER on the bed with MJ.
Finaldi continuously implies boys being "in" MJ's bed means something nefarious, so she clarifies that too.
"Lying on the bed watching TV...innocently watching TV...sleeping..."
Regarding Safechuck, Gayle recalled his parents being around and even after he grew up they'd be guests at the ranch, together. Few times alone.
She called James a "nice kid" but spoiled - he was "just like his parents...snap his fingers and 'I want this' and 'I want that."
Finaldi fixates on Gayle's duties of taking dirty laundry to the wash. His obsession is about "underwear." An innocuous story morphed by McManus & Blanca.
Gayle explained she'd find dirty clothes of all kinds from everyone and load it up for the wash.
Nothing sinister about it.
Gayle recalls both beds in disarray when she'd go to clean MJ's bedroom—Finaldi insists Wade always slept on lower bed and upper one was always made (this contracts Wade & James in multiple ways).
She said often MJ would sleep on bathroom sofa & w/ sleeping bags for groups.
Gayle concludes her deposition by explaining "it is not fair that he was being sued and he was not here to defend himself."
In summary...
Gayle believes MJ was innocent, never saw anything abnormal in any of the years she worked there & disputed tabloid gossip.
A Finaldi Flop.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is a lovely excerpt that emphasizes how desperate Finaldi's entire basis is.
Much like Sneddon, rather than relying on the merits of his own cases he keeps insisting on the Chandler case despite completely unrelated.
The judge saw right through this and his mistreatment.
Everything Finaldi attempts ends up backfiring.
The judge blasted Finaldi for his unprofessionalism and "gender incivility" against MJ's attorney as part of reviewing the records, based on Finaldi's own attempt to demand sanctions and protective order against the estate. 😂
THREAD: Estate's Renewed Demurrer Motion in Safechuck's Case
This week, MJ's team has filed the anticipated demurrer motion in Safechuck's case, refreshing claims that the prior judge & appellate never ruled on.
A tentative in-person hearing on this demurer will be Oct 16 2020.
The estate argues JS' claims are fatally defective—"No amendment can cure these defects."
1. Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress 2. Negligence 3. Negligent Supervision 4. Negligent Retention/Hiring 5. Negligent Failure to Train, Warn, Educate 6. Breach of Fiduciary Duty
The estate summarizes how James never bothered appealing the original dismissal against the estate.
Instead, James (like Wade) shifted their financially motivated claims by "artfully attempting to recharacterize the alleged misconduct as 'negligence' of the two corporations."
AUG: Well that failed. Sorry-not-sorry to all who padded my wallet on this scheme since Nov. just gonna throw it on YT now....to double-digit viewership.😂
Wade felt the waves of LN would make him "relevant & relatable" enough to generate a mass community of people paying his way to continue work-free mooching.
Instead he found that only the smallest sliver of die-hard guilters & blinded CSA advocates w/ ulterior motives joined in.
Once again Wade is unable to admit failure.
No different than his film directing—rather than admit it was too complex for his abilities, he blamed his son, his mom, then MJ.
This venture failed, so all he can do is put on YT in hopes of finding enough viewership for ad revenue.
THREAD: Don Starks is another witness Finaldi solicited to try & bolster case, based on the 1990s tabloid innuendo of Hayvenhurst 5 when they sought cash grabs.
Starks was a part-time security guard from Aug. 18, 1987 to Feb. 1, 1993. His real job has always been at post office.
But nothing Starks offers, even when deposed by Finaldi, is helpful to the case.
Starks claims that over the 5-6 YEARS of employment w/ Jacksons, there were "maybe 3 times" he remembered MJ arriving w/ a boy in the evening. He admits not knowing their arrangements inside at all.
The boys Starks remembered seeing back when he was interviewed in 1993 included:
- Emmanuel Lewis (Starks thought Lewis was 11-12 years old, he was 16-21) - always defends MJ.
- Yoshi (Jolie Levine's son) - always defends MJ and he & his mom strongly lashed out against Finaldi.
I do find the new judge's allowance of Dan to film the court (including full audio) to be unfortunate.
TMZ had made similar media requests in 2013-2015 with the prior judge and he always flatly denied it.
This judge allowed it right out of the gate on the first request by Dan.
While filming the judge, personnel and witnesses are prohibited within the court, there is nothing in the permit that prevents audio recording of the entire proceeding.
Dan and his editor rely mostly on voice-overs in LN in which any excerpts can be seamlessly spliced together.
This tactic allows them to alter reality by omitting large parts of the estate's responses or manipulating witness responses to present more compelling guilt arguments.
Like when Schaffel released tiny spliced-together fragments of MJ's voice messages to media while suing him.