I mean I don’t even know where to start with this, but if total crisis means they finally hand contact tracing over to town halls then I guess that’s progress
The thing that immediately nags at me about it is that if govt is so immediately able to localise contact tracing as a result of political panic, *why couldn’t they do it months ago on the basis that it was the right thing to do*
Local authorities will be given control over mobile testing
Can we please not allow this to be a story about the government suddenly making a big innovation in contact tracing.
Ofc progress if contact tracing is localised. But it’s relative, against no progress. Anyone writing this story from a political perspective needs to know public health depts have been *pleading for this for months*. This is not a govt innovation
The obvious qs are
- what does localised contact tracing mean in reality
- when
- how much £
- how many ppl
- how much of that comes from the central contract
- when
- oh, and when
There’s no WAY you can get away with briefing that to a Sunday newspaper, it then getting on the front, and thinking some of us won’t shout the house down about it. DETAIL. Now.
Sorry, got furious. But this makes me incredibly cross and I know I’m not the only one. Ppl in local govt and public health have not been making this argument for fun. They don’t go ‘oh I know what would take up six months of my life, I’ll have a soul destroying battle w/ govt’
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Went to the pub. Sat in the freezing cold with wonderful friends. All agreed we’d have to come up with inventive legal ways to meet and drink again in the foreseeable (supermarket trolley park? church?). But all of us needed it, and this winter will be tough here without it
Without getting too philosophical about it, you need things to aim for. Even if it’s just a pint. And the endlessness is partly what’s driving people mad, including me: you don’t know when you’ll know, and when you do know, it might not have an end point
And I really have considered my recollection of the legislation re supermarket trolley parks and churches btw. I’m aware that there’s a ginnel clause (sadly the ginnel is legally still your house) but I still have a vague hope that there’s a houseboat loophole.
After a good sleep (and an even better curry) and in the full knowledge I’m probably going to have to work today, have been thinking about the past couple of days. So, a thread
First thing: the anger here is real - it’s not confected. It comes down to the sense people have that they’re being treated with contempt. They are very, very, very angry.
Second: could understand why eg Hancock might have been frustrated by Mcr in recent weeks. While Liverpool etc have been fairly clear about what they’ve wanted, GM has struggled to get consensus - while still being vocally critical of govt.
GM’s meeting with govt is over and it doesn’t sound like they were told what govt wants to do to us; just various data/analysis that I think those on the call were mostly already aware of. One person present says they were ‘seriously underwhelmed’.
Continuation of conversations tomorrow, potentially.
This is a bizarre situation, it seems to me.
Worth bearing in mind that we have a ~devolved health system here. Local leaders are pretty well briefed on the public health situation. Ministers reading out data to them that they already know (or which they would interpret differently) isn’t necessarily going to go well.
More than half the new cases in Manchester are among students, many in halls. Huge frustration in the system here that this was foreseeable; a feeling that there wasn’t and still isn’t a national plan for student return and that lockdown might end up being the price.
Should add that Manchester, politically, remains fiercely opposed to an economic lockdown, largely for that reason (although I imagine that would have always been the case). Suspect we’ll see a swift move towards the north lobbying with one voice, as per recent letters to govt.
That’s not to say that universities themselves have escaped criticism either and the situation with MMU’s lockdown was frankly a PR disaster. But the problem is, the students are back now, paying 9k a year to sit in a flat watching lectures, many self isolating. It’s a mess.