Starting a long-term thread on questions that need answers. Perhaps when media has free time after covering Kangana Ranaut, they could tackle these:
1. WHY is it that no other Asian economy has cratered like ours? 2. HOW did our neighbours manage a far lower Covid death rate?
3. WHY is it that India's richest have increased their wealth dramatically (35%) during a time of devastation that has seen GDP contracting & hundreds millions thrown into poverty? What does it imply in terms of wealth concentration, monopolies/oligopolies & creation of jobs?
4. WHY is India the only democracy in the world where ruling party politicians have made it a practice to come on to the streets to protect and defend rapist-murderers and to
terrorize the families of their victims - from Kathua to Unnao to Hathras?
5. HOW come we have enough money (Rs 20,000 crore) to spend on the grand vanity project in Lutyens' Delhi called Central Vista, but not enough money to improve our ranking in the Global Hunger Index (94 out of 107) or to patrol and protect our territory from foreign aggressors?
6. HOW come in India, a govt that came to power on an anti-corruption plank legalized unlimited, secret donations to political parties through Electoral Bonds, while elsewhere in the world, reform MEANS transparency? Here, see who funds whom in the US: opensecrets.org/elections-over…
7. WHAT is the relationship between the fact that thousands of crores in secret donations flow into ruling party coffers and the fact that about 100 Opposition legislators in states have resigned their seats without explanation in recent years, to the benefit of the ruling party?
8. When non-farm employment is growing fast, it would make sense to plan for less headcount in the farming sector. But WHY would anyone try and push people off farms precisely when employment in other sectors is falling or stagnant (partly due to emerging monopolies/oligopolies)?
9.WHY can't we name China as the aggressor? What will happen if we did? Should we let internal, political worries of the govt determine our external response? How can we reverse the incursion without calling it what it is?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The main driving force behind the Indian Rightwing movement is upper class resentment over ancient privileges diluted by democracy. Its objective is a hierarchical future similar to what tradition dictates. The hate you see is the necessary force to create the new hierarchy.
Does that mean that is the only force? Of course not. There are other forces too, but they are not formative or creative forces that shape policy in any way. They are mostly for show. For example, the movement gained from the anti-corruption sentiment built up between 2010 & 2014
And think for yourself, what was the result of that ‘sentimental force’?😀The biggest electoral funding scam anywhere in the world that legalised opaque & unlimited funding of politicians by cronies, called ‘Electoral Bonds’!! 🥲
Su Venkatesan, well-known Tamil author and MP from Madurai, speaking in the Lok Sabha on the narrowly-constituted panel to study Indian culture
Partial, approximate translation:
"The committee has not a single member from South India, Northeast India, Minorities, Dalits or Women. All are upper caste Hindu men. It has no linguistic expert from southern classical languages, but has caste organization heads as members!"
"Is there no India below the Vindhyas? Is there no other civilization apart from the Vedic? Are there no ancient languages other than Sanskrit?"
If you are going to comment on matters of Science, read the research papers. It may be a tad difficult, but possible. Don't go by half-baked media reports
If you want to know how this - and other - 'news reports' directly contradict the studies, you can read the studies linked above yourself, or read this article of mine, with direct quotations from the two studies: thehindu.com/society/histor…
When people say they don't care about politics, what they really mean is that they are comfortable with the direction of politics and they think they will end up on the side of the oppressors rather than the oppressed. If they thought otherwise, they will care about it for sure.
It is similar to what people mean when they they don't care about caste. It means they never had to pay a price for the caste they were born into & don't expect to pay a price either. If it were not so, hell, you can take it for granted they would have been screaming about it.
*correction: ...when they say they don't care about caste.
if the economic situation and/or the external situation continues to deteriorate, expect the ruling party to resort to further domestic polarisation to consolidate and keep its support base. That‘s the all-purpose hammer that works for all jobs.
If you want to check out this hypothesis, ask any one who voted for BJP why he continues supporting the party despite the destruction of the economy; the utter mishandling of the Pandemic and the resulting loss of lives and livelihoods; the surrender to the Chinese; etc...
His/her reponse will hinge on a few things each of which is a clear communal dogwhistle - Ayodhya temple, triple talaq, Article 370, CAA-NRC, Gujarat pogrom.... In other words, as long as hate is kept at boiling point, the party will keep its support base whole.
When you look at India in the 2 decades before 2014, what you see are govts that prioritized economic development & consequently, our global standing. The only blip on this steady progress was the Gujarat pogrom. The steady accumulation of global heft has now been mostly used up.
Starting from 2014, we not merely took our eyes off the economy, we proactively damaged it through political decisions like #Demon. Then we made a mess of our society for deliberate political polarisation. On top of that, we made wrong bets and took our eyes off the border too.
The physical, social, cultural & trust-related capital that we built up internally and globally ever since the liberalisation of 1991 has well and truly been squandered for petty domestic political wins. Until we realize this, learn our lessons & course-correct, we can't fix it.