As we speak, the short video I made for my #CSCW2020 paper with @BriannaDym is playing "at" the conference! "Moving Across Lands: Online Platform Migration in Fandom Communities." Here is a longer version that was targeted at a general audience! #CSCW2020
And if you missed my #CSCW2020 session but want to see the 5-minute talk about online platform migration that is focused specifically on takeaways for CSCW researchers, here is that presentation!
Here are the social computing research-related takeaways from "Moving Across Lands: Online Platform Migration in Fandom
Communities" (link: cmci.colorado.edu/~cafi5706/CSCW…):
(1) common factors that lead to a community leaving one platform and joining another; (2) how these moves impact communities, including common challenges; (3) insights into why some online platforms—or attempts at moving between them—succeed or fail;
(4) common barriers to migration that help explain e.g., why people don't leave when it seems like they should; (5) design implications for how platforms can support community migration, particularly how the "new home" can mitigate consequences like fragmentation & content loss;
(6) a reminder that "online community" /= "platform.
Communities can exist both separate from and across platforms simultaneously. CSCW researchers should always think about what connects an online community beyond the platform where it is embodied. #CSCW2020
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Update on the bonkers omegaverse copyright lawsuit- a bogus DMCA claim for @thelindsayellis's video about bogus DMCA claims. AMAZING EXAMPLE of a complete misunderstanding of fair use. Let's talk about bad faith takedowns & what fair use protects! [Thread]
To briefly summarize the topic of Lindsay's original video:
Author sends DMCA takedowns for another author's books based on a claim of copyright infringement for worldbuilding concepts that originally came out of fanfiction. Gets more bonkers from there.
Following Lindsay's video, she immediately heard from Author's lawyer, with claims of copyright infringement and defamation. re: copyright infringement, the video includes about 400 words of Author's book. (Heavily bleeped since, you know... it's werewolf erotica.)
I'm alarmed by this exact issue, and here's a related one I've thought a lot about:
All datasets that curate "public" data (e.g., photographs or social media posts) create secondary archives of content that otherwise the original content creators would have control over. [Thread]
There are many reasons why you might want to delete content that you originally shared publicly, and why that content still being used by others (even scientists) might be harmful. One example that comes to mind is someone who has been through gender transition.
I also wrote about a speculative example in this design fiction about research ethics--in which there is a curated dataset of "last words" of deceased life-loggers, then used by trolls to harass their surviving loved ones. cmci.colorado.edu/~cafi5706/grou…
Thread about content moderation & privacy trade-offs!
Last week, Playstation users freaked out b/c of an update that included a warning that "by participating in voice chats, you agree to your voice being recorded" - for "safety and moderation purposes." foxbusiness.com/technology/pla…
What's actually happening is that players now have the option, when making harassment reports, to include a short (40-second) voice chat clip with their report.
You can see why this is useful. You can also see why people might not like the idea of chats being recorded.
When @aaroniidx interviewed Discord moderators about how they moderate voice channels, a HUGE issue was "evidence." How can you ban someone from a community based on reports when there's no proof? They really wanted recordings. medium.com/acm-cscw/voice…
Recently some people have asked me how to reach out to potential advisors when applying to PhD programs. So here is a template - remember YMMV based on your discipline so find out about norms!
Dear Dr. __ , I am considering applying to your department's PhD program, one reason
being that I am very interested in the work you are doing on __ (for example, I particularly enjoyed your paper __ and see myself possibly doing that kind of work). My own research interests relate to ___ in these ways, and I have some research experience with ___. I'm wondering
if you will be considering taking on new PhD advisees, or if you have suggestions for other faculty I should reach out to. I'd be interested to hear more about the recent work in your lab, and I'd be happy to answer any questions or to talk if more information would be helpful.
Next up in my "should and how do I PhD" series of videos... tips for PhD applications! feat e.g., knowing the faculty, reaching out to potential advisors, statements of purpose, how to be smart about letters of rec, etc. #phdchat
Going to summarize for folks who don't want to sit through the whole video! Tips for PhD applications: (1) Check requirements early because they will surprise you with how different they can be (2) Know the faculty in the departments you're applying to.
(2a) It is not enough to think "I want to do computer science" so you apply to every CS program. You have to know what KIND of CS you want to do, and that there's someone in the department who does that thing.
"What if racist facial recognition algorithms result in false arrests for people of color?" We've known of this speculative harm for years. But did not take the step to mitigate harm by banning use of this tech by law enforcement. So now it's happened. npr.org/2020/06/24/882…
Very recent steps taken by Amazon, Microsoft, and IBM are great but also too late - law enforcement already has this technology and smaller companies with less scrutiny are continuing to distribute it. I'd like to know what @DataWorksPlus is doing to mitigate harm.
I'm reminded of @robotsmarts' work on overtrust for AI. dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.114… That seems to be happening here - well the computer said it's him and computes don't lie. So why should they waste their time investigating?