Yesterday, the news was so relentlessly awful for the government. By half way through the day when the free school meals stuff really picked up I said the words out loud: look out for a tough-on-immigration headline tomorrow. #r4today... right on cue 😑
So what's this "new tough policy announcement"? #r4today is reporting that EU citizens with past prison sentences of one year or more will be "turned away" post-Brexit.
This makes no sense - we have established there will be visa-free travel with the EU, so how would they check?
Seems more likely EU citizens will be brought in line with existing rules for non-EU migrants on criminality, i.e. they'll face automatic deportation if they serve a prison sentence of over 12 months here in the UK.
If so, I cannot stress this enough, this is NOT NEWS. #r4today
If I'm right - & I dont see how I could be far wrong, but do correct me if so! - this is EXACTLY what I said it would be: An old policy re-announced to grab some headlines that the government feels comfortable with in a week where they've so far taken a battering. #r4today
Automatic deportation requirements for offenders are racist and wrong, but they are not news.
No-deal Brexit probably will make it difficult to cooperate & share information on international organised crime, but that's not an immigration issue. It's another govt failure. #r4today
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Yvette Cooper notes top nationalities of people attempting to cross the Channel are Iran, Iraq and Syria. Are they all asylum seekers?
Yes, the vast majority if not all apply for asylum (i.e. do not seek to evade enforcement, are not seeking to live undocumented in the UK)
Abi Tierney, Director General, UK Visas and Immigration, says numbers are manageable, in fact the UK has seen a drop in overall figures of people seeking asylum.
Ooooh there's a lot to unpack here.... And I dont know if I fully have the energy but let's have a go.
Yes, there's an extent to which western foreign military policy plays into global refugee flows. Historically, a very enormous extent. But directly in this way? Only an extent.
This type of argument presupposes that all global conflict lies at the feet of Western intervention which is.. at best a little naval-gazing.
Give global tyrants their due: plenty of them control, repress, torture, ethnically cleanse, bomb & gas their populations just fine alone.
Syrian refugees - the largest group in Europe - are overwhelmingly fleeing Assad's violence and Putin's munitions.
Yes, Western powers chucked a few bombs in for good measure, but the brutal repression of popular insurrection against dictatorship is what refugees are fleeing.
So, we hear on #r4today that a new report (unnamed) criticises the Home Office for not knowing how many undocumented immigrants are in the UK. By definition, nobody knows.
But, a couple of things about that...
Home Office doesn't have its own recent estimate, but there are several credible estimates out there. Mayor of London's research puts the figure at about 675,000. Pew Research Centre puts it at about 800,000 (but includes asylum seekers).
Contrary to what hysteric coverage of Farige, etc. would have you think, vast majority of these people came here entirely legally. They entered UK on legitimate visa and for any number of reasons lost their status.
Our immigration laws systematically force people out of status.
While we're talking Immigration Bill I'd like to clarify *important* points about what it will & will not do.
The most important thing about this Bill is what it DOESN'T contain. That is, it doesn't contain even an outline of a new immigration system, points-based or otherwise.
The Bill contains legislation to end Freedom of Movement for Europeans & their families.
Other than that it contains a very large blank cheque giving the Home Secretary long-term & wide-ranging power to bring in a whole new immigration system through Secondary legislation.
That means she will be able to bring in the new immigration system WITHOUT a new Immigration Bill.
Dont get me wrong, immigration bills are the worst, I'm not looking for more, but they give our Parliament the best opportunity to scrutinise, question & ultimately vote on the law.
Bit of a rant of a thread here, maybe. A few things I've been thinking about for our sector with all these unlikely people coming out and praising migrant's contribution and being told to be happy about it and most of all MAKE SOMETHING of it...
Look, it's great, really brilliant, that a lot of big name right-wing commentators, as well as the PM, are coming out with warm words about migrant doctors and key workers at this time. I think it will continue to help the general trend of people being less anti-immigration...
It's helping our calls for measures to protect vulnerable migrants from coronavirus and there may be wins long into the future tapping into people's greater understanding of the good migration brings us and how we are all protected from harm as a society together, or not at all..
Portuguese government has decreed that ALL asylum seekers and ALL undocumented migrants with pending applications for residence are AUTOMATICALLY granted and may access ALL STATE PROVISION including healthcare and benefits. I'm going to faint. publico.pt/2020/03/28/soc…
20 NGOs that assist migrants & refugees wrote to the government a joint letter saying the Covid-19 outbreak was putting people in the asylum system and without status at risk. The government has said, we see your point & give them equal rights.