Racism - specifically the utter unwillingness to believe in Chinese deaths as real, or to listen and learn from East Asian experience - has played a big goddamn role in hundreds of thousands of unnecessary covid-19 deaths.
When I say 'believe in Chinese deaths as real,' I mean to take the suffering and loss of Wuhan as something catastrophic and imminent, as - eventually, partially - we did Italy, rather than as something far away that couldn't happen to us.
And when it comes to the dismissal of East Asian experience, I don't just mean the refusal to learn from masks and centralized isolation and other verifiable on-the-ground successes, but the inanity of 'their culture is different' takes.
The share of blame attributable to the CCP for its initial cover-up - and its threats against other nations not to institute travel bans - is significant. But it's smaller than the *months and months* of failure U.S. leadership has inflicted on its own country.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
it's notable that even in the paragraph where she's like 'it's hard to know if the U.S is better, worse, or the same as China' the examples she cites *are infinitely worse on the Chinese side.*
U.S federal forces held people without charge for like twelve hours in Portland. That's bad! It's a genuine slippery slope! It doesn't compare to the scale of Chinese repression in the slightest.
look, China can't be like Nazi Germany, because I know people in China, whereas I know nobody in 1930s Germany.
there were *lots* of people in 1930s Germany opposed to German government policy, and even more who were generally good people ignorant or indifferent about politics
there's plenty of problems in the comparison, but when a country starts targeting a population for genocide, beating the drums on ethnonationalist revanchism and upholding a leader cult, we shouldn't be surprised or outraged if people compare it to the most famous example of same
you gotta remember that cops are *constantly* targeted by propaganda by their own departments telling them that their lives are in constant danger, that the failure to act could get them killed, that they are warriors, etc, etc.
one effect of this is that cops kill about 25 to 30 dogs a day in the united states, because *any* dog is seen as a potential threat. your home gets invaded, your dog barks, *boom*.
It feels like we have to say this a lot: it is quite likely that China has *manipulated* its coronavirus numbers, and possibly significantly downplayed deaths. But it is almost impossible that they are lying about the overall successful repression of the virus.
We know this for two reasons: even China's highly censored social media can't entirely prevent - as we saw - people putting up images of hospitals, reports of dead, etc. We've seen nothing on that scale.
Secondly, while China is acting with extreme caution about preventing reinfection, the relative degree of reopening and lifting of restrictions would not be done - especially in Beijing - by a government that *in itself* made up of older men highly vulnerable to the virus.
This is dumb, because there’s no alternative term that captures this power\money dynamic. The term exists because patriarchal systems exist: companion or lover are deeply misleading about the nature of these relationships
this Is, in fact, exactly the kind of euphemism that men who keep mistresses like to use to delude themselves or others about the fundamental underpinning of the relationship!
billionaire with a 19 year old model at his side: this is my companion.
bernie followers on twitter: biden is the worst and we hates him, we do
bernie: me and my old pal joe are teaming up to make sure there's no more malarkey in this joint.
remember one of the reasons Bernie didn't go that hard on Biden earlier is because Biden is *a really chummy guy* who has been his friend since he came into the Senate. Because Joe Biden is friends with *everyone*. nytimes.com/2020/03/15/us/…
That's his greatest flaw - because he still thinks of the GOP as fundamentally reasonable guys who can be dealt with, not as hardened ideologues or utterly corrupt sycophants - but it was also his big strength in the primaries.