Surely it's time for @UKStatsAuth to get involved here?
Whatever you think of lockdown, the lack of transparency and dubious presentation of official analysis and the data driving policy has been a disgrace, & not just from Government but @CMO_England and @uksciencechief...
....Isn't it @UKStatsAuth 's responsibility to say something about all this?
If not I'd very much like to hear the reason.
Pro-lockdown people should be just as concerned about this as anti-lockdown people because the lack of transparency and perception of data cherry picking is damaging public confidence in the scientific work that underpins the policy they support
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🚨I'm told Ed Humpherson, Director General for Regulation at Office for Statistics Regulation (UK's statistics watchdog), spoke privately yesterday to @uksciencechief and @CMO_England to voice concerns about their presentation of modelling data at last Saturday's press conference
🚨Independent UK statistics watchdog criticises UK government for lack of transparency over publication of coronavirus modelling data, following complaints over charts shown by @CMO_England and @uksciencechief
🚨BREAK: UK Statistics watchdog criticises UK Government for lack of transparency over publication of coronavirus cases data, following complaints over charts shown by @CMO_England and @uksciencechief
Bear in mind that a Treasury representative sits in on the Bank's Monetary Policy Committee meetings - so they certainly know what decisions are coming
Asked about the Sun story at the press conference Governor Andrew Bailey says: "We will look into it"
This is very true from Declan - "Beveridge" has become a shorthand for progressive reform in contemporary debate - it's important to look at what he actually proposed in that report and why - and what wasn't actually implemented...
Crucially in the post-war UK system the rate of National Insurance jobless benefit was never set high enough to prevent poverty (despite what Beveridge wanted) which meant that the separate means tested system often kicked in and never withered away (as Beveridge expected)....