Thread with excerpts from “The Archaeology of the Caucasus: From Earliest Settlements to the Iron Age” by Antonio Sagona
Mountain passes in the Caucasus were glaciated in the last ice age - preventing anyone from crossing.
Swidden (slash & burn) agriculture was common in Georgia & Armenia 4000-3000 BC, reducing tree cover & leaving much charcoal. In 3000 BC the fires abruptly ceased, the forests regrew, & plants associated with the steppe & pastoralism spread in the region.
Neolithic arrived in Caucasus 3500 years after Anatolia. They were mostly derived from N Mesopotamia & Zagros. Three distinct cultural divisions - Armenia, Ossetia & N Caucasus, & W Georgia.
Armenia had mesolithic hunter-gatherers from 10000s to 4000s BC who coexisted with later neolithic farmers & had apparent contacts in Mesopotamia. W Georgia had same pattern - hunter-gatherers living in region long after introduction of farming into the 4000s BC.
Dense neolithic settlements with round buildings in eastern Georgia 6700-6500 BC.
S Azerbaijan had neolithic settlements originally like those of E Georgia & Armenia with circular buildings, but by 5600-5400 BC they were replaced by neolithic settlements with rectangular buildings with close links to N Iran & S Caspian.
Concentric ditches around neolithic settlements, in both Caucasus & elsewhere. Possibly animal enclosures, possibly fortifications, possibly a market. Given these sites are on hills & have half-meter thick walls, I guess fortifications.
Caucasus copper working spread from southeast to northwest in late sixth & early fifth millennia. Luxury trade across or around Caspian to C Asia began in this period, as evidenced by turquoise & carnelian finds.
Winemaking was invented in S Caucasus in 6th millennium BC, & spread from there. Wild wine grapes still grow in S Caucasian forests.
Copper Age Caucasus - Maykop in N Caucasus 3800-3000 BC succeeded by Novosvobodnaya 3300-2800 BC, Chaff Faced Ware (aka Amuq F) in N Syria-Mesopotamia to Armenia 4000-3500 BC, & Sioni Horizon in E Anatolia/Armenia 5000-3500 BC.
N Caucasus had Copper Age sites that still relied heavily on stone & bone tools 4500-3600 BC, some overlapping in time with Maykop sites. Some of these sites were forts with 4 m thick stone walks. One site had a sterile (artifact-less) layer followed by a Maykop layer.
The pre-Maykop peoples of N Caucasus traded with the Cucuteni-Trypillians to the west, buying copper luxuries from them. This might have stopped in 4300 BC, causing the pre-Maykop N Caucasians to make their own copper.
Maykop was in the N Caucasus & Kuban regions. Chechnya & Ingushetia were borderlands with S Caucasus Kura-Araxes Culture & Terek River was the border with Pit Grave (Yamnaya in 🇷🇺) people - the Indo-Europeans. The borderlands with both Kura-Araxes & Yamnaya show mixed cultures.
Trade connected N Caucasus to C Asia either directly or indirectly, as evidenced by lapis lazuli, carnelian, & turquoise finds in Maykop sites.
Shared religious customs between Maykop & Mesopotamia identified in seals & buying objects beneath floors. Novosvobodnaya built megaliths like Globular Amphora & Funnelbeakers did in C & N Europe. Also signs of technology sharing between Novosvobodnaya & Funnelbeakers.
Maykop culture began before the Late Uruk Expansion, so any art affinities between Maykop & Mesopotamia would been results of cultural spread from N Caucasus to Mesopotamia.
Maykop & Kura-Araxes copper were chemically similar, possibly mined from same deposits or prepared similarly. Copper may have been from local Caucasus deposits.
Copper Age Chaff Faced Ware Culture of S Caucasus existed ~4500-3500 BC in highlands between Kura & Euphrates rivers. It was a fragmented culture with no centralisation. Most parts were influenced by Mesopotamia’s Ubaid culture.
Chaff Faced Ware site of Berikldeebi in C Georgia was burned between 4000-3600 BC & replaced by a walled Mesopotamian settlement with a temple.
Sioni Tradition was a Copper Age set of groups from 4600-3200 BC in south central Caucasus. They lived off of a mix of hunting, farming, & herding. They built stone towers with 1 m thick walls.
Author’s discussion of the similarities of the Copper Age Caucasians with contemporary Mesopotamians as either a pre-Uruk expansion or a legacy of a trade network driven by metal trade.
Kura-Araxes Culture was a multiethnic collection of peoples in E 🇹🇷, 🇱🇧, 🇮🇱, 🇦🇲, W 🇮🇷, Dagestan, & E 🇬🇪 from mid-3000s to mid-2000s BC. They were characterised by homes with hearths & benches, distinctive pottery, ceramic animals, & certain metal items.
Kura-Araxes rapidly spread from their Caucasus homeland to W Iran & E Turkey. They mostly settled in river valleys & foothills with 400-600mm of rainfall/yr for agriculture, though some were semi-nomadic herders.
Western Georgia never fell to the Kura-Araxes - it maintained its own distinctive proto-Colchian culture. Climate there was subtropical unlike the Kura-Araxes lands, & the soil was fertile enough to keep the proto-Colchians numerous.
Huge Kura-Araxes fortresses with 2.5-4m thick walls made from basalt or mud-brick & enclosing up to 150,000 m^2.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Great cataclysms characterized the end of the last Ice Age. With glaciers blocking the Ob & Yenisei from draining into the Arctic, melting ice instead flooded to the west - into the Aral Sea, the Caspian, the Black Sea, and eventually the Mediterranean: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altai_flo…
Caspian seals, Arctic ringed seals, & Baikal seals are all descendants of the same seal population that spread during this cataclysm, as the waters from Lake Baikal to the Mediterranean were connected 12000 BC - 9000 BC.
The 19th century was not kind to the Amerindians. Though they started the century outnumbering criollos almost 3 to 1, modern DNA shows they comprise perhaps 40% of the ancestry of modern Mexicans. I think other Spanish-American nationalities are similar.
I’d guess the process that Gregory Clark describes for early modern English applies to Mexicans too - modern Mexicans mostly descendants of middle class, not the peons.
Fehrenbach: population growth, debt, & increasing land concentration led to immiseration in 19th century Mexico. Mortality 3x that of Europe. Food had to imported, & mule labor was more expensive than human. People were poorer in 1910 Revolution than 1808 Independence War.
Thread with excerpts from “The Napoleonic Wars: A Global History” by Alexander Mikaberidze
Europe in 1789
🇪🇸 restrictions on currency exports, 🇬🇧 successes in undercutting 🇫🇷 industry after mutual tariff reductions, & government monopolies struggling with domestic black market all hurt 🇫🇷 finances & stability. Persecution of black marketers caused vast majority of 🇫🇷 tax rebellions.
Thread with excerpts from “The Russian Civil Wars 1916-1926: Ten Years that Shook the World” by Jonathan Smele
10.5 million died in the Russian Civil War, another 2 million fled, & 5 million starved to death in the aftermath.
While the Bolsheviks lost the elections decisively, they won the votes of groups that mattered most - major cities & their military garrisons. The SRs won the peasant masses, but they were too diffuse to generate power to match urban & concentrated Bolsheviks.
Tudeh Party formed as a pro-Soviet socialist party after the Anglo-Soviet invasion of Iran in 1941. Tudeh was strongest among teachers, oil workers, bureaucrats, & people of Rasht & Tabriz.
Azeri Crisis of 1945-6: Soviets didn’t leave their occupation zone at planned time as British did. Alienated by Persocentrism of Iranian government, Kurd & Azeri separatists declared autonomy & advanced socialist policies. Soviet Azeris played a role in the separatist movement.
Prime Minister Qavam flew to Moscow & negotiated a Soviet withdrawal from Iran in March 1946. In return, members of Tudeh were brought into government & oil concessions were granted to USSR. Azeri separatists were recognized as a local but not autonomous government.
Lands of the Numics (other than the Comanche who had their own realm far to the east)
Three theories of Numic origins: 1) the expanded east out of the southern San Joaquin Valley 2) they were indigenous to the Great Basin 3) they swept out of the Nevada desert & conquered or destroyed their neighbors in the last 1500 years.
Most Numic tribes do not have myths sharing elements with those of the Amerindians of California - the three Numic tribes that do live in California