Thinking about our Covid-19 situation in BC with the view of what’s happening in Italy.
We have short-term economic interest that we’re weighing against human life. Many lives.
To me it’s a morality question. And to me the obligation we have to each other is to save our lives.
I would not send 100 employees to a job site knowing 20 would get very sick and 2-3 would die. That is not acceptable.
I’m at a loss for why we have a question here. We’re speaking of human life.
Killing people is bad. You could say full-on objectively bad.
Back to my scenario, it’s condemning people to death. It’s a little random. Certainly that doesn’t make it okay.
You stand in defence of human life, the dignity of human life, or you stand with the worst of humanity.
Where do we want to stand?
Arrogant stupidity is normally an irritant. Now it’s a threat to public health and the lives of each and every person on earth.
People aren’t numbers. Lost lives are the lives of fellow humans.
I think we need to fall back to objective morality and call this out for what it is.
We have a right to live. Most fundamental right because we are here, we were born and this time on earth is our time on earth.
The most sacred thing is our lives.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Somehow I missed this story from May.
This fellow was my evidence teacher and he was the pride of the faculty of law. It was no secret that he and I did not like each other.
I knew my stuff. He gave me a shitty grade. I knew it was personal. Whatever.
What surprised me was that the law faculty was so enamoured by him. To me there was something off about him. He seemed contrived. Worse, but it’s hard to pin down.
I’m surprised he didn’t go into property development.
The fact that we did not get along, I knew something was off, is a point of pride and the only good I take from this.
Poor old Bill Morneau.
Here’s my take:
He gets into politics for altruistic reasons. He’s actually a human (not a lizard alien) and he decides he should bring his significant skills to the table in the service of the public. Very honourable.
And he joins a party with real vision, a smart balanced leader and a solid team with a plan. And they do it. They win an election, they cut child poverty, they make taxation much more fair and they advance a progressive agenda. Can’t please everyone but they do a very good job.
Then, pandemic and money needs to go out fast. Craig Kielburger, many forget, has serious cred. All parties want to be involved with his non-partisan activism. I suspect he and We are getting an unfair, undeserved rough ride. But that’s an aside. Good old Bill follows the rules.
I suspect people don’t know what’s coming.
It you look at photos of any city from pre WWI you’ll see all sorts of businesses. You’ll also notice that none of them exist anymore. There are reasons.
Most businesses don’t survive their first owner. They had the heart and motivation.
The courageous entrepreneurs who start businesses do the work of three employees. They often contribute far beyond what they extract from the business. It is their drive that keeps it going. Without them, the business folds or falls in decline. Employees don’t often see it.
Very successful businesses, like Army & Navy, could very well succeed but for the unmotivated inheritors who fail to maintain the drive of the original visionary. Canadian Tire has been very smart in this regard. Franchisees can’t gift or sell their store to a family member.
I’ve learned a lot in the last few weeks that I haven’t shared on Twitter. So much. But yes, here are a few tidbits:
Commercial property owners downtown Vancouver, about 30% of retail and restaurants told them they give up. No plan to every re-open. Walking away.
This was as of the end of March. Almost all other restaurants and retail informed their landlords they simply couldn’t pay. Basically only a handful paid their rent April 1. Landlords are panicked and allowing it to slide to try and keep the tenant. Offices are the next issue.
Most offices also sought a break from the landlord. Landlords have decided to enforce leases and personal guarantees (for now) because they don’t have the same concerns re vacant storefronts. They all concede rents will drop but not for leases.
17 years ago I spent a lot of time at 222 Main Street Vancouver criminal court. I got sick. Pneumonia. It had long-lasting effects.
I just spent 2 days in court and all I could think was the risk to which we are all exposed. I am particularly concerned about the elderly.
Including my elderly colleagues and judges and my family.
In these circumstances it would be reasonable to refuse to go to work. As lawyers if we refuse to go, we face career changing discipline.
What’s more important? Your life, the lives of others or your career as a lawyer?
You can guess where I stand on that.
It’s time for the @BCProvCourt and @Dave_Eby to take action here. If this gets from a lawyer to a prisoner or a witness to a sheriff to a judge...
I don’t want to think about it. I sure as heck don’t want to give my life for a minor trial.
Oaths are important. I took the Barrister’s oath and reflect on it regularly. I have been present when new lawyers take their oath. I have administered it many times. Sometimes we discuss it a bit so it’s clear to everyone the obligations. I have reminded some lawyers of it.
US senators have an oath:
Oath of Office
I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same;
that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter: So help me God.