2/ The AZ Oxford COVID-19 interim efficacy results are 70% overall. That is substantially less than the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, over short time periods.
3/ There was a small AZ Oxford substudy with a half-dose 1st immunization and an interim efficacy of 90%. That study is much smaller than other studies, and details were not provided (cases etc.), so I don’t make much of that number for now.
4/ Of note, the AZ Oxford vaccine (high dose) appeared less effective in an animal model (macaques) than the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, indicating the animal model is a good one, consistent with the conclusions of many scientists.
5/ The improved outcome with the half-dose 1st immunization will need to hold up (more cases and data), before it can be fully scrutinized. But, simplest explanation is vector immunity is a bigger problem with the higher dose, blunting effectiveness of the booster immunization.
6/ Vector immunity = immune responses against the adenovector. Such responses are usually the majority of the response to a viral vector vaccine.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/ We assessed immune memory of all three branches of adaptive immunity (CD4+ T cell, CD8+ T cell, and humoral immunity—both antibodies and memory B cells) in a mixed cross-sectional and longitudinal study of 185 recovered COVID-19 cases, including 41 cases > 6 months post-COVID.
3/ Sources of protective immunity against SARS-CoV-2 may be multifaceted. Therefore, understanding immune memory in a coordinated manner is needed to see the potential complexities and gain insights into the likelihood of durability of protective immunity.
1/ The second COVID-19 vaccine trial results have been released. 94.5% estimated efficacy! Outstanding news. These are Moderna vaccine results, independent of the Pfizer results a week ago. So there are now two independent successes!
It is the same general type of vaccine as the Pfizer vaccine. Both are RNA.
There were 90 cases of COVID-19 in the placebo group, and only 5 in the vaccinated group. That gives an ~95% efficacy calculation.
3/ There were 11 severe cases of COVID-19. Severe cases are defined as hospitalized cases that require oxygen, and frequently are ICU patients. All 11 severe cases were in the placebo group, indicated the Moderna vaccine works very well at preventing severe COVID-19.
1/ This is a truly excellent and important outcome. Greater than 90% efficacy at preventing disease, with 94 COVID-19 cases to evaluate, is an excellent outcome! It would be good to see more of the data, but those are very convincing numbers.
2/ It is also encouraging that the 90% efficacy is for all cases, not just a subset of cases. Finally, I find it very encouraging for the other COVID-19 candidate vaccines also!
3/ Multiple candidate vaccines had similar immunogenicity profiles in humans, and multiple candidate vaccines had efficacy in pre-clinical models, so there is not specific reason not to expect multiple other candidate vaccines to do well in humans nows.
2/ Given the amount of discussion in scientific, public, and political spheres, it is useful to undertake a thought experiment examining crossreactive T cell effects on COVID-19 disease severity and herd immunity, should crossreactive memory T cells confer some form of protection
3/ We consider immunological and epidemiological aspects and implications of pre-existing crossreactive immune memory to SARS-CoV-2, largely originating from previous exposure to circulating common cold coronaviruses.
2) There is no direct evidence that pre-existing T cell immunity affects COVID-19 infections. LJI researchers and other have proven that such T cells exist, but neither we nor anyone else have shown that the pre-existing T cells make COVID-19 better, worse, or no difference.
3) To say it another way, There is no direct evidence that crossreactive memory T cells to common cold viruses affects COVID-19.
Crotty lab member of the week is Carolyn Rydyznski Moderbacher, PhD! 1. Carolyn is the lead author of our new COVID-19 immunology paper studying T cell and antibody responses in acute COVID-19 cases. cell.com/cell/fulltext/… @ljiresearch
2. Carolyn wasn’t planning on working on COVID-19, but she had developed excellent multi parameter flow cytometry panels for other human T cell studies, and AIM assays, and I needed her to take the lead on COVID-19 T cell work,
3. so she dropped her other project and has worked full time on COVID-19 for the past 6 months, trying to understand immunity to COVID-19. Culminating in the new paper.