I don't know who this person is.
But I've noticed her really problematic "hot takes" popping up on my timeline last few weeks thanks to some lovely mutuals

This seems to be her latest one. 🤦🏽‍♂️

A thread
First thing that popped in my head was this was exactly the though I had in my head back when I was much younger and single and more importantly ABSOLUTELY IGNORANT about this issue.

Was only after I had spoken to some survivors/victims of partner abuse I realized the truth
The truth is it is never so black and white. Psychologists can give you so many fancy sounding words like "Stockholm syndrome" or "battered spouse syndrome" etc to explain it.

But just a quick google search of "why do victims stay with their abuser?" Will yield 100s of results
I went through a few a them and collated a few reasons of "why"

It is by no means conclusive nor exhaustive

But it is something to help you think about it

And I hope this could help someone out there who needs this
Abusive relationships are extremely complex situations and it takes a lot of courage to leave. Abuse is about power and control.
When a survivor leaves their abusive relationship, they threaten the power and control their partner has established over the survivor’s agency, which may cause the partner to retaliate in harmful ways.
As a result, leaving is often the most dangerous period of time for survivors of abuse.
Beyond the physical risks of leaving an abusive situation, there are countless other reasons why people stay in their relationships.
No matter the circumstances, survivors deserve to be supported in their decision-making and empowered to reclaim control over their own lives. Common reasons why people stay in abusive relationships include:
1. Fear
A person will likely be afraid of the consequences if they decide to leave their relationship, either out of fear of their partner’s actions or concern over their own ability to be independent
2. Normalized abuse
If someone grew up in an environment where abuse was common, they may not know what healthy relationships look like. As a result, they may not recognize that their partner’s behaviors are unhealthy or abusive.
3.Shame
It can be difficult for someone to admit that they’ve been or are being abused. They may feel that they’ve done something wrong, that they deserve the abuse, or that experiencing abuse is a sign of weakness.
Remember that blame-shifting is a common tactic that their partner may use and can reinforce a sense of responsibility for their partner’s abusive behaviors.
4. Intimidation
A survivor may be intimidated into staying in a relationship by verbal or physical threats, or threats to spread information, including secrets or confidential details (i.e. revenge porn etc).
For LGBTQ+ people who haven’t come out yet, threats to out someone may be an opportunity for abusive partners to exert control.
5. Low self-esteem
After experiencing verbal abuse or blame for physical abuse, it can be easy for survivors to believe those sentiments and believe that they’re at fault for their partner’s abusive behaviors
6. Lack of resources
Survivors may be financially dependent on their abusive partner or have previously been denied opportunities to work, a place to sleep on their own, language assistance, or a network to turn to during moments of crisis. Making it impossible to leave.
7. Disability
If someone depends on others for physical support they may feel that their wellbeing is directly tied to their relationship; lack of visible alternatives for support can heavily influence someone’s decision to stay in an abusive relationship if they have disability
8. Immigration status
People who are undocumented fear that reporting abuse will affect their immigration status. If they have limited English proficiency the concerns can be amplified by a confusing convoluted legal system & an inability to express their circumstances to others
9. Cultural context
Traditional customs or beliefs may influence someone’s decision to stay in an abusive situation, whether held by the survivor or by their family and community.
10. Children
Many survivors may feel guilty or responsible for disrupting their familial unit. Keeping the family together may not only be something that a survivor may value, but may also be used as a tactic by their partner used to guilt a survivor into staying.
11. Love
Experiencing abuse and feeling genuine care for a partner who is causing harm are not mutually exclusive. Survivors often still have strong, intimate feelings for their abusive partner.
They may have children together, want to maintain their family, or the person abusing them may simply be charming (especially at the beginning of a relationship) and the survivor may hope that their partner will return to being that person.
These are just a few of the many reasons

Credits to the National Domestic Violence Hotline website USA

thehotline.org/support-others…

And there are many more resources like this out there
With so much information readily available at our finger tips I think it is our absolute our responsibility to do a little bit of online reading before we make such unnecessary comments online. 🙏

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jonathan👨‍⚕️⚕️

Jonathan👨‍⚕️⚕️ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @just1doctorwala

25 Nov
Speaking of Ayurvedic doctors & modern Surgery

Both doctors have degrees in Ayurvedic Medicine. While charging them for culpable homicide prosecution also argued that the 2 doctors did not have requisite education & training to perform these procedures indianexpress.com/article/cities…
Both doctors have degrees in Ayurvedic Medicine. While Shimpi has a BAMS degree, Deshpande has a BAMS degree with a MS in Ayurveda Shalyatantra
In its judgment, the court observed that the main dispute was whether the two accused possess the requisite educational qualification for performing gynaecological surgery, including the cesarean operation and tubectomy, as per government norms,
Read 4 tweets
2 Nov
I tweeted this earlier today before my shift just after
I had read the thread. A mutual had DMed it to me. I was debating how best to respond to it. The problem with such a "fact check" if we can call it that is how to avoid attacking the messenger instead of the message itself.
But the more I thought about it the more I realized the messenger needs to be talked about as well.

Because...

Credibility

That's what it all comes down to

In the age of misinformation, the credibility of certain people is higher than others and with that comes responsibility
When someone with a famous name, or 10s of thousands of followers on social media, or someone with a "Dr." in their name posts something there is an inherent in built credibility to that message

I too enjoy that privilege I won't deny that.
Read 43 tweets
8 Aug
Extremely irresponsible reporting.
If I can even call this reporting.
Seems more like a hit job.
Especially now in time of pandemic
All this kind of reporting does is fester panic and mistrust to the modern medical profession.
The cost figures mentioned make absolutely no sense.
Of you would bear with me I would like to go point by point and ask a few questions about her "figures"
These are some of the TOP most expensive more luxurious private hospitals.
Notice the second hospital? That's right! that's where Amitabh Bachchan and family were admitted.
Private hospitals are profit making no denying but just like hotels you get regular hospitals to 5* level.
Read 23 tweets
16 Jul
For those of you who don't understand why so many of us medicos are questioning the drug Itolizumab the company Biocon and Ms. Kiran Shaw let me explain.

#ThreadAlert
Issue 1. This drug is approved for psoriasis in India.
It is STILL NOT approved in USA for the same.

Ironically she happily quotes USFDA protocols for restricted emergency approval when her drug has not been approved for the original use there 🤷‍♂️

Shouldn't that make you wonder
Issue 2. They claim this drug showed "encouraging results in covid19 patients"
The "test" involved 30 patients. The drug helped with some symptoms but no change in mortality (death due to disease) was seen in the calculations
Also too small sample

Shouldn't that make you wonder?
Read 7 tweets
28 Jun
Any comments on this X Ray?
#MedTwitter
#FOAMed #FOAMrad
thank you everyone for your responses

the objective of me sharing this xray was perfectly illustrated by the responses

notice how we got responses as "perfectly normal x ray" all the way to "covid 19"?

This was a patient i saw yesterday and the experience left a bitter taste
hence i thought i would talk about this

something which is affect us all in one way or another

This is the perfect time to talk about MEDICAL JOUSTING
#LongThreadAlert
Read 33 tweets
9 Apr
I've seen a lot of people asking this question. It is a valid question & shouldn't be dismissed outright. However the answer to this is a little nuanced than straight forward. If you have a few minutes allow me to explain. I hope I don't step on any toes

Let me start with the obvious
Ask yourself,
Honestly

Do you trust government institutions...
REGARDLESS of who the government of the day is?

If you are sick and can afford it, would you go to a Government Hospital or a Private hospital?

So it all boils down to TRUST DEFICIT
When you already have a trust deficit, add to the mix political, social, religious and cultural agendas...

What are you left with?

Let us put aside all that for now
Let us accept a few things
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!