A few practical observations from lived experience & prompted by this piece:
1) If you feel like family life & work life are squeezing you in impossible ways, you're not crazy or weak or lazy. In our society, they generally are.
2) B/c of this, the answers to your present stress isn't to simply work harder or hustle more. The game is rigged in a 100 different ways.
3) Systemic forces are real & they affect your ability to flourish as a family. The sooner you realize & accept this, the sooner you can deal w/ practicalities of your life.
4) Still, there is hope. Systemic forces explain your reality but they don't have to determine it. You still have agency, creativity, & options.
5) But you'll have to be willing to rethink everything. You'll have to Q the status quo & accepted definitions of success. You'll have to take stock of resources you have & don't have. You'll have to remember that consumption =/= flourishing.
6) For our family, the realities of marketplace & shape of western society have meant several things over the years:
>getting help from social safety
>fewer children than we might have had
>delayed property ownership
>both parents working once kids were past toddler years
7) But we've also tried really hard to push back against the system in the ways available to us to make sure our family has ability to pursue our values
8) A few things that make sense for us (your circumstances will be different):
>I have great deal of control over my work & work from home
>We've learned to accept help, not as charity, but investment in family's future
>We're constantly clarifying our values & ultimate goals
9) But the biggest thing is that we know our family life will not look like most people's. Our values will lead us to different decisions a put work, rest, money, & time use. Our kids will grow up at odds w/ culture that would groom them as workers for the marketplace.
10) But then our goal is not a middle-class family. Our goal is to cultivate a home where members can flourish as image bearers they were created to be.
11) This will include good work & providing for needs. It will include partnership w/ larger community. But at the end of the day, our family does not exist to serve the marketplace.
12) All that to say, if you're struggling as a family, there's a reason for it & it likely has nothing to do w/ your hard work or competency. Feel free to Q & push back & demand more. Reevaluate your goals & seek healthy partnership that are mutually beneficial.
13) Don't be afraid of the social support network. Don't be ashamed to ask for what you need. Your family is worth the investment.
14) And be encouraged that the work of family is worth every sacrifice you make.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Per previous thread about how marketplace is as odds w/ family:
To be clear, women have been asked to bear the weight of this problem alone for far too long.
There's a true tension btwn the home & marketplace, but simply expecting women to give full attention to the home (vs. other callings) doesn't challenge the problem in any meaningful way. It is a stopgap measure.
Not only does it fail to adequately honor the public gifts & capacities of female members of community, it also divides the members of the home from each other, making it easier to conquer.
On Wednesday, I made #allthepies--apple, pecan, pumpkin.
Or so I thought...
A thread.
If you know anything about me, you know I love pie & love making pies. You also know that my husband @n_d_anderson & I garden & can. You also know that I love hanging out on Twitter.
So Wednesday was a fun day for me: making the pies, hanging out on Twitter, talking about life in Appalachia. I made my pecan first & then went downstairs to grab pumpkin off the shelf.
Okay! Two pies in oven & here's first take on #HillbillyElegy:
1) It's worth remembering that the director, Ron Howard spent his childhood on a Hollywood soundstage portraying rural NC. Exterior shots were filmed in Culver City, CA. Mayberry was a work of fiction.
2) Is Hillbilly Elegy just Dark Mayberry? This might explain the limited characterization, reliance on tropes, & "American Dream" framing.
3) Mayberry is idealized version of places America left behind. Middletown is same only in photonegative. But neither tells the full or faithful story, reducing inhabitants to stock characters to perform *our* preferred narrative.
Observation: Those w/ political & social power are far more confident in the robustness & resilance of a system than those outside it.
I've noticed this over last few years in politics as norms have erroded. But I've also noticed it in churches when scandals break.
Obviously, there's a sense in which systems work precisely for those who succeed in them. But it's more than this. There's this clear difference in *experience* of the disruption.