While this is PREFERABLE to a more impulsive young teen, it doesn't obviate the fact that even a relatively mature 13-year-old often holds views that may change (or they may regret) as an adult.
Raise your hand if you were absolutely confident of something at 14 that you now think is totally wrong. Now, what if that something you firmly believed was an irreversible decision (such as permanent infertility)?
🖐️
And yes, puberty blockers by themselves don't cause permanent infertility, but nearly ALL blocked kids proceed to cross sex hormones (as was noted in the court case), and that combination is what sterilizes.
Top gender specialists are well aware of this. Diane Ehrensaft said parents who hesitate to approve such treatments is only balking because they want grandkids (instead of preserving the right of their child to make an informed decision as an adult). dailymotion.com/video/x7kqndq
Some gender doctors even argue you might as well do SRS on minors, since their gonads have been rendered useless. Like this one at Stanford:
"Affirmative" gender treatment has progressed light years beyond what the Tavistock is doing. US doctors agitate for earlier and earlier treatment. Puberty blockers are the tip of the iceberg. To take just one example:
Mastectomies are not at all uncommon for young teens in the United States. If a UK judge ruled that under-16s can't consent to even (technically reversible) puberty blockers, what about breast removal for a 14-year-old?
“These drugs seriously harmed me in more ways than one and they have harmed many more…particularly girls and young women.” 1/n
"I would like to personally call on professionals and clinicians to create better mental health services and models to help those dealing with gender dysphoria to reconcile with their sex. " 2/n #KeiraBell
"And furthermore I call on society to accept those who do not conform to sex stereotypes -- not push them into a life of drugs and concealment from who they truly are. This means stopping the homophobia, the misogyny and the bullying of those that are different.” 3/n #KeiraBell
Amazing news out of the UK today, where the High Court ruled children cannot meaningfully consent to what was deemed experimental puberty blocker treatment. #KeiraBell
Now it's time for the (far more extreme) "affirmative care" industry in the US to face a similar ruling.
"In short, the treatment [puberty blocking] may be supporting the persistence of GD [gender dysphoria] in circumstances in which it is at least possible that without that treatment, the GD would resolve itself."
Judge raises concern about children on the autism spectrum & with other mental health issues. "We found this...apparent lack of investigation of this issue surprising." #KeiraBell
Last night at his townhall hosted by ABC, Joe Biden said an 8-year-old should be able to "decide to be transgender." This isn't new ground for Biden; his Foundation has been partnered with Gender Spectrum for several years.
Some links in our original 2019 thread are broken or have been moved. Here's a live page from Gender Spectrum discussing their alliance with the Biden Foundation. genderspectrum.org/articles/blog-…
Here's Biden last night promoting the idea that an 8-year-old child ought to be able to "decide to be transgender."
Read the very passage Turban screen-capped here to see how disingenuous he is. Turban launches near daily attacks on those who know & work w/detransitioners. Why does Turban do this, while ignoring what detransitioners themselves say, several of whom responded to this tweet?
Ashley is an "amab" activist with a vendetta against anyone who dares to talk or write about detransition & the recent uptick in girls/women who identify as trans. Check out Ashley's most recent paper (linked here) & this thread.
Ashley has been at this for awhile; for instance, launched a campaign last year to prevent the hiring of Sahar Sadjadi at McGill University for the crime of raising questions about medical treatment of dysphoric youth.
"I remember thinking even before Kai was 3, this kid might be gay....& I thought that cannot happen...would not happen. We started praying fervently. Prayers turned into googling conversion therapy, and how can we implement these techniques at home to make Kai not be like this."
"Putting her in timeout for acting like a girl...for stealing girl toys. Spanking her...REALLY spanking her, every time she said mommy you know I'm a girl."
Watch the video, promoted by the ACLU. Yes, she really says this on camera. But what's left out:
In multiple magazine interviews, mom said the spankings and punishment started well before the child [in desperation?] claimed to be a girl. Like in this one for the Huffington Post: archive.is/zWlen
First we had "I am Jazz" on a subscription cable channel that not everyone watched. Now Jazz is a legal adult, and a new star is born on Netflix, the huge digital channel where most of us in the US go for our films and TV binge watching. But unlike in the case of Jazz...
...this child's mother gave interviews discussing how she did everything in her power (including repeated spankings) to dissuade her toddler from playing with toys the family deemed too feminine. Family members wondered if the 2-year-old child was gay. archive.is/zWlen
The family somehow (how? why?) were noticed in 2017 by major media outlets.