It's Brexit revisionism day... 1/ I pushed for Labour to adopt a Norway style deal a) after the Referendum and b) again from July 2018. Leadership said no both times... then in early 2019 came the research showing Labour was losing more Remain votes than Leave votes...
2/ Theresa May's deal was an *attack on the working class*. No Labour MP or trade union leader could have supported it. The options were Norway or Johnson's hard Brexit...
3/ For as long as possible many on Labour left held out for a Norway solution: single market, free movement - and there were signs the SNP would have gone for it...
4/ Once May was gone, the only way forward was to fight for PV+ Remain. That was the fight (because you can't remain without a second referendum)... and 80% of Labour members wanted that...
5/ The problem was not just that Corbyn dithered: as we now see, the "left" included loads of closet Lexiteers (and some principled ones who were open from the start)... all prepared to ditch free movement
6/ The point of left politics is sometimes you have to stand against the stream - like Keir Hardie, shouted down by workers in 1914 for opposing the war... and those who fought Brexit will be very proud once ppl realise how sh*t the outcome is...
7/ We went on the streets to oppose the Prorogation, we fought (behind the scenes) for a coalition govt to take control from Johnson without an election: the SNP/Libdems pulled the plug and handed Johnson a Brexit election
8/ The fact remains: Britain's future is in a comprehensive free trade agreement with Europe, with common standards and oversight... and the "smash the imperialist global system" Lexiters were wrong from the get-go newstatesman.com/politics/brexi…
9/ We will not rejoin the EU this side of 2050 I think. But Labour should fight for the closest possible trade, security and migration links. Don't even think about maintaining the Union without that.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"Lee Cain - a Marxist Analysis" 1/ Vote Leave won, took over the Tory party and govt and then a) Covid b) Biden cancelled their essential project ... plus...
2/ Johnson is not stupid but lazy and has a short attention span ... he can't lead and has no vision so outsources everything to cronies ... but the "thin deal" creates a fork in the road ... meanwhile ...
3/ Everyone in govt knows that when the public reckoning happens over the late lockdown, Johnson and Cummings are toast... but there's a deeper problem of fiscal strategy ...
Boris Johnson's presser was a shameful moment in British governance. Under-prepared, insincere, apologetic - he revealed the NHS is about 6 weeks from collapse, thanks to his refusal to lock down in early October 1/
2/ I've seen a prime minister rattled - Brown and Darling during the second RBS bailout in 2008 - but even they were in control of the timetable. Johnson has lost control of this crisis...
3/ With the entire machinery of government of what is still the 5th most powerful country in the world, Johnson could not stage a coherent briefing to the British people, nor even get the Powerpoint to fit on screen...
The Great Reset is a half-assed but well intentioned idea by the WEF to design a sustainable version of neoliberalism-lite. But the Covid conspiraloons think it's an actual "global elite plan to take over the world" because the graphic looks like a Freemasonic eye 1/
2/ Here's the Mises Institute and a Vatican conspiraloon spreading the same basic idea... it maps perfectly onto QAnon and plays on the ultimate fear of the disoriented neoliberal self: that society exists after all...
3/ It's totally consistent with Arendt's observation that, before they take power the authoritarian right have to conjure up "a lying world of consistency which is more adequate to the needs of the human mind than reality itself" newstatesman.com/world/2020/09/…
If anyone's thinking to spend the weekend fantasising about a left split from Labour, here's an updated summary of why it's crazy ... 1/ Labour is the only route to a left government in Britain. Even Podemos ended up in power as junior partners to PSOE... medium.com/@paulmasonnews…
2/ 56% support for Scottish independence and Labour on 13% in Holyrood polls mean 2024 is the last chance saloon. If Scotland is out of the UK there'll have to be something akin to the US Democrats, or Popular Front in 36 - until the demographics change medium.com/@paulmasonnews…
3/ The culture/values conflict is unavoidable and will be intensified inside any left party. Trans rights, migration, Brexit - all the issues that divide the Labour left would divide anything to the left of it: so then there'd be two left alternatives... medium.com/@paulmasonnews…
The Tory party is giving us an object lesson in "culture war-ification": free school meals are an economic issue - now they're being elided with criminality and fecklessness 1/ it's not random or accidental ...
2/ and now the Tory MPs are claiming cultural victimhood - "poor little public school educated me, being hounded by the plebs"... when their supporters *still* stand outside Parliament harassing left MPs/ journalists...
3/ It shows the futility of the mantra "don't fight the culture war": their attack on BLM, anticapitalism in schools, Critical Race Theory, "activist lawyers" etc an intelligent fightback but can't be ignored...
The Newsnight film on Labour's divisions under Starmer was pretty accurate... but 1/ Look how easily it has provoked more divisions. Len McCluskey's "counting gold" comment about Mandelson was a disgrace and so was Unite's initial defence of it... he is right to apologise...
2/ The allegation of Starmer being "untrustworthy" from Diane Abbot sounded to me like a left that has no intention of fighting for influence in a battle of ideas... I hope the #GrassrootsVoice NEC slate stays well away from this...
3/ There's a growing logic: the disaffiliation of a big union, a provoked confrontation over the EHRC report, a Unite-led "faction" so that tankies can live in a well-funded echo chamber while abdicating the struggle for a Labour government...