REVEALED: Indian Chronicles – how a massive 15-year influence operation successfully targeted the EU & UN with 750+ fake local media and 10+ zombie-NGOs.
Executive Summary & full report: indianchronicles.eu
Here are the facts 👇 (1/n)
Indian Chronicles’ key objective is to undermine Pakistan internationally.
To do so, they resurrected dead NGOs at the UN.
They impersonated the EU.
They laundered content produced by fake media to real media - and reached millions in South-Asia & across the world. (2/n)
Our new investigation began with a shocking discovery: @MartinSchulz, former President of the European Parliament, was said to have left politics.
But instead, it seemed he was now heading Canners International, a NGO dedicated to the promotion of… food in cans 🥫! (3/n)
We soon found the NGO he was supposedly leading officially ceased to exist in 2007 and was now regularly speaking at the UN Human Rights Council (@UN_HRC) to slam Pakistan. (4/n)
The truth is that Martin Schulz’s name has been hijacked by the malicious actors depicted in our investigation.
Canners International is, in fact, only one of the many UN Human Rights Council NGOs resurrected by Indian Chronicles. (5/n)
Resurrecting NGOs wasn’t enough: Indian Chronicles resurrected Louis Sohn, “grandfather of international human rights law”. Deceased in 2006, he is listed as a @UN_HRC participant in 2007, and as an attendee of an event in Washington DC in 2011. (6/n)
Outside the doors of the UN, Indian Chronicles also created and supported several NGOs and think-tanks in charge of lobbying, organising events and demonstrations, all favourable to Indian interests. (7/n)
You may wonder: Indian Chronicles, who are they?
In 2019, we uncovered 265 fake local media across the world - serving Indian interests.
Indian Chronicles = same actors (Srivastava Group) + unidentified actors who have - at least - tolerated this operation for 15 years. (8/n)
Remember the vanished “EP Today” that we exposed in 2019? To target the EU, Indian Chronicles is back with euchronicle.com, a fake media serving as a honeypot for Members of the European Parliament.
Over 14 years, Indian Chronicles attracted dozens of MEPs. (9/n)
But who would have heard of this confidential media with fake journalists only a few days after becoming active in May? Only a famous press agency could: Meet ANI – Asian News International – a leading press agency in India. (10/n)
Once repackaged by ANI News, the content from EU Chronicle is reproduced by other major Indian outlets, then reaching a domestic audience in India. (11/n)
But the amplification didn’t stop there. We found that EU Chronicle’s articles travelled all over the world thanks to 500+ fake local media outlets. Among other sources, these outlets regularly syndicate content from the ANI news agency. (12/n)
Indian Chronicles really love media: they also stole the picture of James Purnell, a former UK Secretary of State and BBC Director to create a Facebook account. (13/n)
Why stop there?
They used letterhead of @Europarl_EN.
They stole the name of a current @UN staff.
They copy-pasted entire sections of @euobs, @TheEconomist and @VOANews (14/n)
A bit lost? Here is a graphic summary of the whole operation 👇 (15/n)
The impact of this operation is hard to measure. Here are examples of what it led to:
• Articles suggesting the EU supports “surgical strikes”
• Diplomatic incidents with other countries.
This impact, the scope and the duration of this operation should not be neglected. (16/n)
This is what we believe should be done about it. 👇 (17/n)
Here is an important disclaimer about this investigation. (18/n)
We almost forgot! The typo in indianchronciles.eu is intentional: a tribute to Indian Chronicles’ editors who visibly had a hard time writing the name of their own media outlet. (19/n)
As EU Chronicle dares to put it: “Learn about the news in a way you never have before. Walk into a world of knowledge, wisdom and truth”.
To get there, please remember that it’s important to support disinformation investigators and journalists. (20/n)
BONUS: There is always more to investigate: feel free to contact us via indianchronciles.eu.
OSINT people: we left a little something for you. The first to find it will gain our eternal recognition. Tip: read our policy recommendations.
Au revoir (we hope)! (21/n)
#IndianChronicles Since yesterday, international media have covered our investigation, including BBC, Politico, Le Monde, EFE.
#IndianChronicles: Since yesterday, international media have covered our investigation, including BBC, Politico, Le Monde, EFE.
Here is what they found: 👇👇👇
In Brussels, @PoliticoEurope focused on the actors behind EU Chronicle – the same as behind EP Today last year: Madi Sharma.
They also reveal that MEPs @tobiszowski 🇵🇱 & @marctarabella 🇧🇪 claim to have been abused by #IndianChronicles.
On @Euractiv, MEP 🇧🇬 @djambazki, who is cited as one of the authors of EU Chronicle content, declared that he never "submitted any text" and is "looking into legal actions to resolve this issue”.
In March 2020, we stumbled across an article from the French website “Observateur Continental” repropagating the false claim from the US law professor Francis Boyle about “COVID-19 being a perfect bioweapon”. (2/n) lemonde.fr/les-decodeurs/…
Created in April 2019, ObservateurContinental.fr presents itself as an “independent and non-profit information portal”. There are no mentions of any editorial leadership nor information about the ownership structure. (3/n)
1) Uncovered: How an anonymous Spanish alternative blog, which spreads disinformation items and polarizing content, has been using the Amazon Associates program to fund its activities.
2) La Verdadera Izquierda (meaning “the True Left” in Spanish) began in 2011 as a Twitter account and blog with the goal of "unmasking the lies of the left and socialism in this great country called Spain”. It attracted around 38K followers before its suspension in April 2020.
3)The blog appeared several times on our radar as a disinformation propagator, mostly because it regularly copy-pasted content from websites spreading disinformation. maldita.es/malditobulo/20…
UNCOVERED: How the so-called French media outlet “France Libre 24” – which uses disinformation to sow polarisation in society – hides the fact that it’s managed by a controversial Polish far-right media network. (1/20)
Several months ago, our attention was caught by a newcomer in the French online media landscape - France Libre 24, which sounds like the French news TV channel France24. (2/20)
FL24.net presents a large majority of its articles as being sourced from French mainstream media (@AFPfr, @LeMondeFr, @LePoint, etc.) - a practice that gives FL24.net an aura of legitimacy. (3/20)
BREAKING: We uncovered 2 Facebook pages managed from Ukraine that support Marine Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon – leaders of 2 major French political parties (far-right and far-left).
They contain a substantial amount of disinformation.
Thread ⬇️ (1/16)
Our investigation began when we stumbled across linfonational.net – a website with some content that had already been fact-checked by AFP and Libération CheckNews. (2/16)
We noticed that the Facebook page “Marine Le Pen 2022” (30k followers) had very actively shared content from this obscure media outlet registered in Ukraine, and that the page itself is managed from Ukraine. (3/16)
BREAKING: We uncovered a worldwide network of 265 fake media outlets in 65 countries, targeting the US, Canada, Brussels, Geneva and many more, which all serve Indian lobbying interests. (1/9)
Have you heard of New York Journal American? It was a daily newspaper until 1966. Recently, it was resurrected online by the network we uncovered. (2/9)
We’re sure you know @MSNBC… but do you know MSNBC.UK? (3/9)