First of all it worries me because it seems likely to hurt progressives electorally. If they're anti-America and average voters are pro-America, even if only symbolically or rhetorically, it means progressives are going to be fighting an uphill battle...
Second, it worries me because if progressive activists don't believe in America, what entity do they think is going to solve all these problems we're facing? If they're placing their hopes on replacing America with some other entity or entities, they're not on a road to success.
Most people like their country. You can harness dissatisfaction with that country to push for reform, or even revolution. But if you base your pitch in static, permanent opposition to your country, you just aren't going to get far, I think.
(end)
And I say this as someone who is absolutely disgusted with my country right now and intends to move out for a while.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/For me, as for a lot of people in Asia, the key moment was the Hong Kong protests.
They were absolutely enormous. Almost 2 million Hong Kongers, out of a total population of 7.5 million, turned out in the streets to demand universal suffrage.
3/The protests failed. China simply implemented a draconian new security law, threw prominent activists in jail, and accelerated the process of subjugating Hong Kong.
--> Thus, while it is important for the U.S. to decarbonize, our biggest impact will come from making green energy cheap enough so everyone else decarbonizes on their own, at low or no cost.
Soon this kind of thing won't even be newsworthy anymore, it'll just be what every country is doing, everywhere.
2/In recent years, China's economic model has seemed to go from strength to strength. Many now wonder if Chinese state-capitalism is superior to other systems.
My guess: After 2012 the big fear was that Hispanics would be a permanent Dem constituency. That fear should have put Rubio in charge of the GOP; instead it lead to the Trumpian backlash. Now, Trump's gains with Hispanics have reassured them...
This type of partisan fear -- that immigration represents vote-importing by the other party, and will lead to permanent demographic drowning at the ballot box -- is a very old phenomenon in American society.
You might say that this is one of the constants of American politics. Immigrants and their kids tend to vote more for one party than the other. This raises fears of demographic drowning among the other party, which then seeks to restrict immigration...
Basically, Trump really screwed the pooch on this one, but we still need to do something about the fact that our supply chains are highly dependent on China.
2/Joe Biden has also vowed to reshore our supply chains. For stuff we need in an emergency, that makes sense. But for a lot of stuff, it doesn't. We're not going back to the days when countries made most things in-house.
3/The U.S. is still going to be good at the things it's good at. Capital-intensive businesses with lots of innovation (plus farming). We're not going back to an economy based on low-skilled assembly work -- nor should we.
2/There are a lot of big policy ideas floating around this country. All of them on the political left, I should note.
Universal basic income, a federal $15 minimum wage, a job guarantee, child benefits, free college...
So why did I pick these three?
3/Let's start with national health insurance.
Our health care system is just a total mess. It's a source of terror, of catastrophe, of massive expense. It's hideously inefficient. It lags behind all the other rich countries.