As bloody as the world wars were, they weren’t particularly bad by historical standards. The 17th century was uniquely bad for 2nd millennium AD, with Little Ice Age & glut of specie leading to state collapses & population decline across Eurasia.
Falls of Rome & Tang in 1st millennium were worse, but at least they were recorded. Records of the even worse Bronze Age Collapse around 1200 BC barely survived for some areas, & for other regions all we have are archaeological indications that they regressed to the stone age.
Further back in the 3rd millennium BC, an even worse series of catastrophes occurred - the Indo-European invasions - ending the Megalith Builder Civilization with their urban settlements & leaving much of Europe depopulated for 600 years.
By the time of their destruction the Megalith Builders themselves had been in a centuries long decline from their Golden Age in late 5th & early 4th millennium. Their great realms had likely disintegrated around 3500 BC into smaller chiefdoms engaging in endemic warfare.
The Megalith Builders themselves were the result of WHG chieftains overthrowing the decadent EEF chiefs like those of the Linear Ceramics around 4400 BC & subjugating an 1800 year old neolithic civilization. Possibly related to spread of copper-working.
The EEFs had settled Europe after the worst catastrophes following the Last Ice Age - the Storegga Slides. A continental shelf collapsed & resulting tsunamis drowned an entire landmass (Doggerland) while floods elsewhere in Europe devastated WHG communities.
While mankind does fall, stagnant, & decline - the trend in the long term is progress. Even our declines & falls are getting less worse with every cycle.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Thread with excerpts from “The Great Cauldron: A History of Southeastern Europe” by Marie-Janine Calic
Translation from original German by Elizabeth Janik. Original title was “Südosteuropa”.
Disputes over the origins of the Romanians & Albanians - did they form in their current areas in ancient or classical times, or are they the result of medieval migrations?
Thread with excerpts from “The Archaeology of the Caucasus: From Earliest Settlements to the Iron Age” by Antonio Sagona
Mountain passes in the Caucasus were glaciated in the last ice age - preventing anyone from crossing.
Swidden (slash & burn) agriculture was common in Georgia & Armenia 4000-3000 BC, reducing tree cover & leaving much charcoal. In 3000 BC the fires abruptly ceased, the forests regrew, & plants associated with the steppe & pastoralism spread in the region.
Great cataclysms characterized the end of the last Ice Age. With glaciers blocking the Ob & Yenisei from draining into the Arctic, melting ice instead flooded to the west - into the Aral Sea, the Caspian, the Black Sea, and eventually the Mediterranean: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altai_flo…
Caspian seals, Arctic ringed seals, & Baikal seals are all descendants of the same seal population that spread during this cataclysm, as the waters from Lake Baikal to the Mediterranean were connected 12000 BC - 9000 BC.
The 19th century was not kind to the Amerindians. Though they started the century outnumbering criollos almost 3 to 1, modern DNA shows they comprise perhaps 40% of the ancestry of modern Mexicans. I think other Spanish-American nationalities are similar.
I’d guess the process that Gregory Clark describes for early modern English applies to Mexicans too - modern Mexicans mostly descendants of middle class, not the peons.
Fehrenbach: population growth, debt, & increasing land concentration led to immiseration in 19th century Mexico. Mortality 3x that of Europe. Food had to imported, & mule labor was more expensive than human. People were poorer in 1910 Revolution than 1808 Independence War.
Thread with excerpts from “The Napoleonic Wars: A Global History” by Alexander Mikaberidze
Europe in 1789
🇪🇸 restrictions on currency exports, 🇬🇧 successes in undercutting 🇫🇷 industry after mutual tariff reductions, & government monopolies struggling with domestic black market all hurt 🇫🇷 finances & stability. Persecution of black marketers caused vast majority of 🇫🇷 tax rebellions.
Thread with excerpts from “The Russian Civil Wars 1916-1926: Ten Years that Shook the World” by Jonathan Smele
10.5 million died in the Russian Civil War, another 2 million fled, & 5 million starved to death in the aftermath.
While the Bolsheviks lost the elections decisively, they won the votes of groups that mattered most - major cities & their military garrisons. The SRs won the peasant masses, but they were too diffuse to generate power to match urban & concentrated Bolsheviks.