Most of the media coverage on hospitals has been focused on beds. Beds are not the resource limitation, clinicians are. And beds are used as the best proxy for hospital capacity. Typical utilization rates depend on the hospital but vary between 65% and 90%
1/
In April, Vanderbilt created a predictive model to advise the State on what restrictions and NPI’s such as social distancing (notice that masks were not an input into the model) to implement in order to avert certain disaster, without which we would see 50,000 hospitalizations
2/
Take a look at the Vanderbilt projections and then compare them with the actual Hospitalizations in the Visual. Clearly, there was a time when we believed we needed to “flatten the curve” and participate in these measures to save lives.
As time goes on, it becomes clearer that the hospital capacity disaster that was predicted never came to pass, and never will, even with recent increases during the winter respiratory virus season.
4/
No surge facility that we rushed to build-out, including the 1600 beds in the Music City Center were ever used. Considering that clinicians are the finite resource to provide care, what were we ever going to do with those beds?
Furthermore, when hospitals suspended elective procedures in the Spring/Summer- they had to furlough and layoff staff. Observing employment data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics this reduction in staffing has still not fully recovered.
When newspaper articles cite “hospital capacity” issues, they are not citing beds. They cite staffing shortages. Why could this be? When schools are closed for in-person- someone needs to stay home to help and take care of them.
We have seen 865,000 women leave the workforce nationally as of October. What happens when medical professionals leave the workforce to attend to their children for remote school? Staffing shortages.
This is a vicious cycle that our political, education, and healthcare leaders need to find their way out of. It's time they start seeing that they are creating the problem, not solving it.
Per the CDC, Tennessee is on track to see about a 10-12% increase year-over-year in total mortality from all causes
1/
In a recent survey, Americans responded that the mortality burden of Covid was 225 times higher than it actually was. Between 1500 to 1650 Tennesseans pass away every week. While all loss of life is tragic, it is important to keep this in perspective.
Public Health should be focused on minimizing all harms to human life. The response of our politicians and Public Health authorities have exacerbated an opioid crisis and cause undue stress and fear among many.
Firstly, it was wrong to claim that this virus was novel. Secondly, It was even more wrong to claim that the population would not already have some immunity against this virus.
2/
Thirdly, it was the crowning of stupidity to claim that someone could have Covid-19 without any symptoms at all or even to pass the disease along without showing any symptoms whatsoever.
3/
"If a childhood-related infection were protective against a severe course of COVID-19, it would be expected that adults with intensive and regular contact with small children also may have a mild course of COVID-19..
more frequently because these adults are more exposed. to those childhood-related infections. To test this hypothesis, a survey of recovered COVID-19 patients was conducted."
2/
" Of note, intensive care treatment was reported by three of 19 (16%) inpatients in the child group and by 16 of 40 inpatients (40%) in the no child group (p = 0.056, exact Fisher test, one-sided)"
3/
"In testimony before US Congress on March 11, 2020, members of the House Oversight and Reform
Committee were informed that estimated mortality for the novel coronavirus was 10-times higher than
for seasonal influenza."
..Additional evidence, however, suggests the validity of this estimation could benefit
from vetting for biases and miscalculations. The main objective of this article is to critically appraise the
coronavirus mortality estimation presented to Congress..
2/
"Informational texts from the World Health
Organization and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention are compared with coronavirus mortality
calculations in Congressional testimony"
3/
Tennessee Covid Tracking is now Tennessee Stands: Covid Data & Research
Coming Soon: New Covid Dashboard that will track Statewide Hospital capacity, Overall TN Mortality, Age-Stratified Risks, & TN Dept of Health tracking data by County