1. Lots of talk about Miami's innovation economy. Here's a little analysis we did several years back. Lots more of this at our old site for the Miami Urban Future Initiative. creativeclass.com/_wp/wp-content…
2. First and foremost, Miami is a near completely different animal than Austin. Austin is a talent/ creative class leader, and Miami is a laggard (though it has some strengths which I'll get to in a minute.
3. Austin's creative class share is 34.% 8th among large metros. San Jose is first by the way with 46.4%. Miami is 47th (out of 53 large metros) with 26%.
4. But like I said Miami does have strengths. With @iamstevenpedigo we can Location Quotients for specific innovative/creative/knowledge/ professional occupations.
5. Key strengths are in financial/HQ & healthcare space: legal occupations LQ 1.75; business & finance 1.06; healthcare 1.08. Much less strength in management .72, computer & mathematics .7; engineering & architecture .59; sciences .5
6. Our assessment is that Miami has key strengths as a HQ location, also with 200plus % growth over the past several decades, as well-established HQ center for Latin America. Also significant strengths in real estate. As well as Media, also as center for Spanish language media.
7. Miami's LQ for arts, entertainment & media occupations also reasonable at .92 But core strengths in broadcast news (1.54), producers and directors (1.18), radio & TV announcers (1.27), camera operators (1.74) and photographers (1.35)
8. Here is our related study on Miami's innovation/entrepreneurial economy. Also some strengths to build from here. carta.fiu.edu/mufi/wp-conten…
9. Data is a bit old now and can use updating but we have Miami ranking:
8th in VC investment
10th in VC investment per capita
9th in high-tech business
4th in knowledge economy businesses
BUT ...
23rd in higher ed R&D dollars, and
43rd in higher ed R&D dollars per capita
10. Region lacks anything like an MIT. Stanford, Carnegie Mellon, University of Texas at Austin, University of Michigan, University of Toronto.
Needs something like NYC's Cornell Tech initiative ...
11. A big strength of Miami is its positioning at the center of the So-Flo Mega-region that encompasses Tampa and Orlando. Brings real strength in technology with Disney, the Space Coast, Tampa Innovation District & Jeff Vinik's efforts around urban tech.floridatrend.com/article/6976/t…
12. So in sum, Miami's natural strengths are in finance, real estate, media & entertainment, & global trade & logistics as well as travel & hospitality with port & airport. Tech ecosystem is now among top 10. But missing a key element in 1st tier engineering research university
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1. Race to the Bottom - That is another possible take/implication of what is happening with the rise of remote work & the geographic shifts being accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic ... One we are not hearing enough about ...
2. I've already written about how the 1% is taking advantage of the pandemic & remote work to shift their residence to avoid state & local taxes ... But maybe there is more to it.
3. What also appears to be happening is that elements of the business elite - the capitalist class - in finance, real estate & tech - are shifting their residence & parts of their operations from higher cost, higher tax to lower cost, lower tax locations.
2. As a baseline, let me post some key stats from my report with Ian on global startup cities which uses data from the pre-pandemic period, mid-2010s. startupsusa.org/global-startup…
3. The San Francisco Bay Area is far & away the global leader. Taking San Fran & San Jose (Silicon Valley) together adds up to more than a fifth of all VC backed high tech startups. Next in line is Beijing with 16.6% & of US hubs then NY with 6.6%
1. 100%. And not just these places. Becoming a tech hub is at least a generational process. Think of Boston's transformation. It began right WW2 with MIT and ARD. @margaretomara lays out the process for Silicon Valley...
2. Pittsburgh. It's efforts began way before I moved there in 1987 ... And now 40 years later we see "the effect."
3. The Research Triangle, Seattle ... I could go on. And you can't just wish and hope to become a tech hub. You need massive investment & massive freedom at a major research university or universities ...
1. Austin is hot. I know it because @iamstevenpedigo moved there and he's barometer. But Austin is anything but a new emerging tech hub. It has been a leading tech hub since I started doing research on tech hubs & innovation clusters in the late 1980s. Some data points.
2. When I started writing what became Rise of the Creative Class in the late 1990s. Get what place was a top destination for @CarnegieMellon comp sci & engineering grads - Austin. I features prominently in that book published in 2002, nearly two decades ago.
3. Check out these data from the book, as published in an excerpt in @monthly. Austin is up there with San Francisco on virtually every tech hub, innovation & creative class metric (wish I could find a better version of that article & its tables): thefreelibrary.com/The+rise+of+th…