Thread on the #ArnabGate #WhatsAppLeaks. Alleged Journos are outraging how Arnab knew a retaliatory strike for #PulwamaAttack was imminent days before. Well here’s a list of people who knew beforehand
1. @htTweets because the PM said so on 23rd FEB
2. The @IndianExpress knew because the reported Sambit’s speech TK this effect
3. @IndianExpress had been reporting @ImranKhanPTI saying this a full 6 days before the attack. Did Modi call and inform Khan as well?
4. Also on the 24th IE carried PM’s Mann ki Baat
5. By the 19th (8 days prior to Balakot) Imran was worried enough that he even approached the UN to “defuse the situation”.
6. Notably @thewire_in & @CNNnews18 journalist Karan Thapar in his @htTweets column on the 24th (obviously written & edited by the 23rd) seemed to think a retaliatory strike was imminent
7. Meanwhile - Imran Khan and the Pakistan army were able threatening Afghanistan as far back as the 19th of Feb 2021 - saying the Indian retaliatory strike would derail talks
8. Amit Shah similarly announced retaliation was imminent at a rally on the 21st of Feb.
9. In short at least since the 19th a full 8 days before Balakot happened, the Government made it clear, retaliation was imminent. If alleged journalists didn’t pick up on this, it just shows you what trashy journalists they are. Arnab didn’t say anything not already public.
10. Adding more from crowdsourcing (via @AbhiNationalist) on the 24th US President Trump suggested a strong Indian retaliation seemed imminent & John Bolton strongly supported India’s imminent retaliation.
11. Meanwhile @timesofindia not only knew of a retaliation, but also specifically knew Air Strikes were the preferred option as early as 16th Feb 2019 (2 days after pulwama & 10 days before Balakot)
12. Though staffed with dumb reporters who take years to realise they’ve been conned, even denser than lead @NDTV picked up that strikes were imminent by the 23rd (3 days before the attack)
13. Maybe @the_hindu should explain what exactly they interpreted “full freedom for planning retaliatory action” as reported by them on 17th February (9 days before Balakot) meant. Did they think “retaliation” was candlelight vigils & competitive Bhangra dancing?
14. @IndiaToday was running a programme just 1 day after the pulwama attack, predicting air strikes “as Air Chief Marshal Fali Major had reccomended to PM Manmohan Singh after the 26/11 mumbai attack”. To note INC spokesperson was present in the debate. (Via @prasanna4swaraj)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Abhijit Iyer-Mitra

Abhijit Iyer-Mitra Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Iyervval

16 Dec 20
THREAD
1 @DisinfoEU (EUD) brought out a report on a “web of disinformation” set up by Indian intelligence. This kangaroo court drivel followed no consistent logic & by EUD’s own standards show EUD collusion with Pakistani intelligence & left wing journos in India. Let’s examine
2 first up we need to understand what this latest report is. It adds on a report released by the same group in 2019 claiming to expose the organisation of Madi Sharma. The target this time though is to link @ANI to the Madi Sharma network
3 it claims this is a 15 year operation, IE started by the UPA government under Dr Manmohan Singh. Curiously though in these 15 years it can find only 12 instances of where @ANI this news website called EU chronicle. IE less than once a year.
Read 17 tweets
13 Dec 20
1n Like every poor farmer the #FrugalIndian too was protesting for subsidies. An INC saw me begging & decided to subside my lunch/protest. He offered me a very basic meal as behooves a tiller & toiler such as myself Image
2n To start there was Andalusian cauliflower sautéed in first press mustard extract, titillating spiced with Swedish winter cumin & Bolivian curcuma Image
3n this was followed by knödels in the “malayee caufta” style - made of delicately spiced winter gourds in a light & tangy yoghurt sauce Image
Read 12 tweets
11 Dec 20
Thread
1n I think more than Rahul Gandhi - it is Ram Guhas & Kaushik Basus who’ve reduced the congress & the “Idea of India” to zero. They come from privilege & are extremely articulate but are broken records & their writings subject to the law of Diminishing returns.
2n of course the much vaunted left ecosystem is its own enemy. Once they identify you as a “fellow traveller” they go out of their way to promote every mediocrity (unlike the right which won’t promote even its smartest). This is great for individuals - it offers rapid social
3n social mobility. The problem is it also creates a closed echo chamber where no dissenting thought is allowed. Consequently any new views from the ground up never reach the top & the top becomes more and more elite and disconnected from reality. This also incentivises the
Read 10 tweets
6 Nov 20
THREAD:
1n You know I have no love lost for Modi. However his decision to support Trump was the right one. It is very easy to second guess with the benefit of hindsight. But this was one of Modi’s genuinely courageous gambits. Let’s understand why. First: the institutional
2n nature of USG policies is breaking down. Obama had no issues throwing old and trusted allies like Israel to the wolves when it came to extremely ill considered deal with Iran. (Also Saudi Arabia). He also threw Japan under the truck over the Senkaku dispute with China
3n Obama is single handedly responsible for destroying the European Project, by pursuing regime change in Syria & destroying the reset Putin wanted enact by replacing himself with Medvedev who was lied to and conned in Libya. Trump reversed a lot of this. In short what the last
Read 10 tweets
5 Nov 20
THREAD
1n A porcine faced @BJP4India spokie claimed that BJP’s great virtue is that it never uses power to help supporters. Really? Let’s see what Vajpayee did in 2001 shall we? Remember Karunanidhi then an NDA ally with ministers in the centre being roughed up during arrest?
2 JayaLalitha had come to power in May 2001 in TN & ordered this as revenge. An outraged Vajpayee demanded a report from then TN governor Fathima Beevi. Fathima sent the a report prepared by TN Police, which obviously towed the state government line justifying the brutality.
3 Vajpayee was furious that there was nothing in the report he could use to crack down on JayaLalitha. So the cabinet formally asked the president for Fathima’s sacking, which happened a day later.
thehindu.com/todays-paper/t…
Read 5 tweets
27 Oct 20
The one thing we know from the new gazette on J&K land acquisition rules is: That babus hide everything under extremely complex language, 2 lawyers so far have told me that they’re still trying to understand what it means. Verbosity is a substitute for achievement
1n I’m going to list out the pros and the cons
1) all land sales come under government scrutiny, so no benamis (ergo illegal terror funding revenue or money parking)
2) Full communist model - no demand and supply. Will hurt farmers as they won’t get fair price, GoI list prices
2n
3) the DC will give permission for land sale - problematic, because we know the entire state administration is a conflict economy based on deep rooted corruption. Also we don’t know the communal bias of DCs
4) today the government may sell land to Bihari labourers, tomorrow a
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!