How do we change our mindset to better deter grey zone threats at home and abroad?
1) The Kremlin relies on below-threshold conflict to achieve strategic objectives. We must enhance our capabilities in these domains, and also how we monitor and assess threats in grey spaces. /1
2) The way we engage the Kremlin allows Russia to evade consequences, which encourages them to take greater risks and accelerate disruptive activities in their near abroad and further afield. We must own our role in contributing to this state of affairs, and up-end this cycle. /2
3) Ignoring Russian behavior creates a system that also requires us to ignore things about ourselves. We must evaluate the weaknesses that we have failed to confront, renew our strength at the seams, reconceptualize what resilience & defense are in an era of grey threats. /3
4) If we can build strength where we know we haven’t had it against Russia, this gives us a better position against China + enhances a domestic fabric of resilience to better mobilize our resources and respond to threats and crises (like pandemics, fires, attacks, more) /4
5) We must refocus on shaping outcomes in a state of perpetual change, not achieving an endstate. /5
Admit our failings but remember our strengths.
Develop a new toolkit that enhances options to respond so that attacks & threats below-threshold can be met with an appropriate response.
Better assess where we should act, where we may need sharp capabilities & mobilization. /6
The grey spaces are where we are losing — in the world and at home.
This is where power has shifted across the past decade. This is where we must be to alter the equation. /7
Catch up today on the first sections of our serial on @RenewGreatPower evaluating our weakness at the seams and vulnerability to below-threshold and grey zone threats — and how they provide a template to renew American resilience
I am 100% here for the rawness and quiet fury of @RepRaskin
“I am not going to lose my son at the end of 2020 and lose my country and my republic in 2021 — it’s not going to happen. The vast majority of the American people — republicans, Democrats, and independents — /2
— reject armed insurrection and violence as a new way of doing business in America... This was the most terrible crime EVER by a president of the United States against our country, and I want everybody to feel the gravity and solemnity of those events... /2
...At the same time, of course, all of us are deeply invested in President-elect Biden and Vice President-elect Harris moving the country forward to repair all of the wreckage and damage of last year — on everything from COVID-19 to the economy... /3
At home and abroad, we are challenged along the seams. Right now, the way we organize & mobilize diminishes rather than unleashes formal & informal American capabilities. Transforming our mindset is a necessary first step.
Trump became president at a critical juncture in a war we needed to fight. And he so utterly failed to do what was necessary that he leaves us more fractured, more unmoored, more exposed as a nation.
The introduction lays out the failures in mindset that have allowed ascendant autocrats to exploit the cracks in our democracy
At home and abroad, our blindness in how we evaluate these weaknesses—in how we interpret threats against us—exposes this failed mindset /2
In recent years, we’ve basically been running a giant wargame against ourselves — and every adversary has had a front row to see the failures in mobilization, intelligence, decision-making, command and control, security — and above all, the failures in leadership. /3