Okay, you might be asking, but didn't federal courts shut down or otherwise limit most of Trump's big immigration policies? Isn't this the same thing?
Hey, thanks for asking.
No.
The executive has all of the power over how, when, where, & why it chooses to enforce immigration law. A state can't just demand that feds enforce it the way that the state would prefer, any more than it can demand them to issue a Gary Buse commemorative stamp or invade Australia
This is essentially the same argument that TX made to stop Obama's DAPA program (basically DACA for some parents of USCs/LPRs) and it was just as stupid and racist and attenuated then as it is now
And yes, I've had plenty to say about giving states some power to keep ICE from enforcing immigration law! But unlike racist arguments re: how taxpayers might use taxpayer-funded services if we don't deport them, there's a real state interest in play here
(And this may not be the commemorative stamp we need, but it is the commemorative stamp we deserve)
Anyway other than an abject lack of standing, failure to show anything resembling irreparable injury, pretense that TX was making a legal rather political argument, & disregard for the federal government's exclusive jurisdiction over imm enforcement this decision was totally fine
(Although in the DAPA decision TX was big mad that they were going to have to issue driver's licenses at a loss to a lot of newly-documented ppl, which always seemed like much more of a TX problem than anything else)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
FYI this* is a common white nationalist talking point used to justify massive federal intrusions into state and local affairs and no one who uses this language should be taken seriously or in good faith
I believe I speak for a lot of my colleagues when I say this:
The last 4 yrs have radicalized me. I don't know now how I so blithely accepted borders & cages & administrative violence of all kinds as a regular part of my life and practice, but I never will again.
I'm only sorry that it took the cruelest and worst-run Presidential administration in at least the past century for me to see what this thing was the whole time I've been practicing, and a deep dive in the immigration history & policy I now teach to see what it's always been.
I still have a lot to learn & am feeling out my own understanding after so many years of basically accepting that things like prisons and detention centers and family visas which take 15-20 yrs "need" to exist, but I'm going to try to put the work in & encourage you to try it too
Anyone else thinking about #immigrationcourt dates scheduled for for clients in 3 yrs and wondering if there will be a federal government to hear them by then, or is that just me
Fun times for someone who grew up believing as a matter of fact that the world would end in his lifetime!
I opened today's class on asylum/refugee policy by reminding everyone that there is no reason whatsoever to assume that the phrase "American refugees" is not something that we will come to know in our lifetimes. Any given country is just a couple of bad leaders/yrs away from it
DMs are open for anyone who wants to go in on* one of these and join me for some recreational arson
--
*read: give me several million dollars for
Or maybe we buy one, upgrade the cell blocks into humanly habitable dorms, and team up with the Unitarians to make the thing a year-round "church camp" which does nothing but provide communal sanctuary for people whose appeals have run out