The good news: “even at this late stage, investment to expand manufacturing capacity would have large benefits.”
The frustrating finding “investing in the amount of capacity recommended by our model (as of August 2020) would have allowed ... the world to complete vaccination by October 2021 rather than June 2022.”
(The benefits would have been $1.14 trillion. Obvs much higher than costs.)
One of the key points to understand in the question of to get the world vaccinated is that the the social value of more vaccines far exceeds the commercial returns to vaccine the manufacturers from installing capacity.
They estimate that “increasing the total supply of vaccine capacity available in January 2021 from 2 billion to 3 billion courses per year generated $1.75 trillion in social value, while additional firm revenue was closer to $30bn.”
That’s a 60-fold difference.
The other fundamental reality of vaccine production is that it is very risky for producers.
Vaccine development often fails and if that’s the case then the producers end up with the losses incurred in the costly but unsuccessful development process.
In this situation - a risky R&D process with a potential revenue that is much, much smaller than the value for society - the authors suggest that it is in the public’s interest to speed up the process by taking on the entrepreneurial risk for the vaccine production.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I agree with the goal of a “people’s vaccine” – we need vaccines for the entire world.
But I don’t see how these proposals would get us there.
It seems to me that our global situation is very much worse than these proposals assume.
1/
The various "people’s vaccine" proposals want to get rid of intellectual property restrictions for the COVID vaccines so that more vaccines can be produced.
2/
In the past there were such horrible situations in which patent restrictions prevented the world from making progress against diseases.
(For example the patent restrictions on ART that meant that HIV-positive people in poor countries could not get the treatment they needed).
3/
Let’s assume that the cost estimates of that study are much too optimistic and the true cost of producing the vaccine will be $200 billion in the end – it would still be less than the economic losses in just *month* last year.
That’s just the loss in production (4.5% decline of global GDP according to the IMF: imf.org/external/datam…).
The full ‘cost’ of the pandemic is of course much larger than that – the pandemic’s impact on our daily lives, people being sick, people dying.
The point is:
estimate of the pandemic’s cost that is much too low >> estimate of the cost to produce vaccines that is much higher than what this study estimates
This study estimates the cost to produce the missing vaccines to protect *the entire world* from COVID. mdpi.com/2076-393X/9/1/…
Facilities to produce 16 billion doses of a Moderna type vaccines would only cost around $4 billion, ~$2 a jab.
Easily the best deal of the decade.
If this is even remotely true it is unbelievably exciting news. 10- or 100-times that price would be cheap.
This important article outlines a plan for how to pull it off (it's based on the paper above). nytimes.com/2021/01/12/opi…
Here is a perspective on the $4 billion price tag.
For the total cost of the entire production operation of this vaccine this is the relevant table – and the Moderna type vaccine is the one on the left.
CapEx = total capital investment cost
OpEx = annual operating cost
It was wrong to believe that 'saving the economy' was an alternative to 'saving people's lives’.
If anything it is the other way around and the two goals go together so that countries that kept the health impact of the pandemic lower suffered smaller economic consequences.
This isn’t a new insight, it’s just more up to date data.
It was obvious early on in the pandemic and has been said by many economists for months.
@jensspahn Für diejenigen die sagen, dass ein kleines Land wie Israel (8,9 Millionen) nicht mit Deutschland vergleichbar ist:
Baden–Württemberg hat eine Bevölkerung von 11 Millionen.
Während Baden–Württemberg 17,000 Menschen geimpft hat, hat Israel 1,000,000 geimpft.