so a few other POC authors and I have made threads on this recently and I've seen us get accused of promoting "nazi-level racial purity" in books and being ABLEIST for not telling white authors EXACTLY what to do besides this
- Preorder and promote POC-authored books
- Don't act like white authors are the only ones who exist and thus it will be some sort of devastating blow to diversity in books if they take a step back from writing POC stories
1/?
- Understand the difference between writing from a POC perspective and having POC characters in your story
- Understand the frustration of white-authored POC stories getting more favored than #ownvoices ones bc they will inherently appeal more to the white gatekeepers
2/?
- Don't tone-police POC or throw severe accusations bc they are tired of talking over and over and over about this very well-worn topic
- Don't demand that POC educate you for free so you "don't get called out"
- DON'T RESENT POC FOR GETTING SUPPORTED BY THEIR COMMUNITIES
3/?
- Don't ask POC increasingly detailed questions about your own WIP in SOLE HOPE (key here) of getting a Not Racist stamp
- Don't assume a single POC can give you all the answers; we are in fact also concerned about writing harmful rep and not immune to criticism!!!
4/?
- Do NOT, I mean DO NOT make yourself the victim bc you feel like "white people aren't allowed to write anything anymore 😩😩"
- You are not being oppressed by being asked to step back
- POC don't need you to bestow us with representation; we can represent ourselves
5/?
If your knee jerk reaction to this discourse is frustration and anger, ask yourself - why do you wanna tell POC stories so badly when it's not yours to tell?? Why don't you boost existing and upcoming POC stories instead? Why don't you understand systemic power dynamics?
Anyway I am truly tired of talking about this, stop asking POC writers to comfort you about the diversity in your book when none of us are 100% comfortable with our own work. And stop harassing us bc you suddenly feel self-conscious about your Asian-African-inspired epic fantasy.
gonna mute this too because i know people are gonna harass me anyway. i've retweeted plenty of threads about this. look through my TL if you want more POC perspectives.
This is a learning process and it's okay to make mistakes, but don't take your discomfort out on POC.
OH I wanna add something important:
Don't bring up beloved works written from POC perspectives by white people in a WHAT ABOUT kind of way. Those books were published in a different time and no matter their quality, we can thrive to do better about uplifting actual POC authors
*strive, smh. can't lose my author cred over a typo 😤
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
White people - when you ask POC questions, I wish you'd ask less "Is it okay if I do [certain thing]?" and more "What are your thoughts on [certain thing]?"
The first makes me uncomfortable bc you're demanding a clear Yes/No that no single POC has the right to give - 1/?
- it puts the burden on ME to repeat for the countless time that we are not a monolith and others may feel differently before giving my opinion, and even then, I worry that you might take my answer and run bc I'm not sure if you're conceptualizing our internal diversity 2/?
But if you ask "what are YOUR thoughts?" instead, it shows me you're aware that you're getting the opinion of a single person and that you're not expecting me to speak for a whole group of people. Only then do I feel safe giving my thoughts 3/?
what if I wrote one of those culturally-inspired YA fantasies except the culture was Canadian culture
- Syrup-based potions
- Royal guards riding moose
- Queen suspiciously absent
- Protag is daughter of a baker of "timbits" (in italics), gets whisked to the palace when it's found out she wields great magic
- Oppressed Indigenous population
- Magical fur cloaks
- Enchanted hockey sticks as weapons
- The apothecary "shoppersdrugmart" (also in italics)
- The rebellion in the Quebecois province
Okay who's ready for THREAD: CULTURAL INSPIRATIONS AND OTHER TRIVIA & LORE IN AVATAR THE LAST AIRBENDER, BOOK 1
Disclaimer: Unless cited from official sources, all musings about possible inspirations are my personal opinions, and will also skew Chinese bc that's what I am 1/?
So right away in the background writing in the opening sequence, each element is accompanied by a characteristic that generalizes their nation
Water is Kindness, Earth is Strength, Fire is Passion, and Air is Harmony (approximate translations) 2/?
The banner up top says something like "The Many Mighty Powers Divided in Four," while the bottom is "All Under Heaven Are Pacified by One" (probably refers to the Avatar)
The production team hired a master Chinese calligrapher Dr. Siu-Leung Lee, so all the writing is legit 3/?
Hold on, am I missing something or did America really only give some people a one-time stimulus check of 1200 and expected everyone to be able to quit their jobs and stay home
Okay so we talk a lot of shit about Americans not following quarantine guidelines and wanting to keep their businesses open, but honestly, how were they supposed to shut down or stop working with 0 support from the government?!
Like of course I don't condone protesting against quarantine guidelines, but it seems that much of it has spawned more from being asked to do the impossible than plain selfishness over not being able to party or whatever