Since Apple seems to be cool with this scam remaining on their App Store, let's look at another app from the *same* developer.

This one has stolen "only" $1M so far...

How?

1/🧵
Enter "Truth or Dare⋆". No, the little asterisk at the end is not a typo, just a shitty ASO dark pattern.

apps.apple.com/US/app/id13976…
Searching for "Truth of Dare", we see their ad at the top. Because the scam is so profitable, they can afford to pay a lot for that. Image
4.5 stars, 16K ratings, glowing featured reviews, how can I say no? Image
Launch the app, you get this: Image
Hmm, there doesn't even seem to be a way to skip this? Well, anyway, 16K ratings can't be wrong. This is gonna be so worth it.

Reader: it wasn't worth it
The app is one of the worst ad-infected scams, but maybe it's just my opinion.

@appfigures shows they have only 203 reviews, out of 16K ratings (!)

The average review rating?

1.9 stars

ONE. POINT. NINE.
Now let's see what people are actually *saying* in these reviews, to get a better understanding of what has been going on here - for YEARS.

Bear with me, I'll show you quite a few.
⭐️ Thieves!
No idea how this has such a great rating. Honestly believe they are fake. Crazy that many could be fake. Charged my account $5 a week for 10 months without me knowing.
⭐️ Criminals
TARGETED MY KIDS, one of whom bought it (my fault). Charges $5 every few days it seems. Already notified AG of my state and have filed a complaint. This app is a total scam.
⭐️ Zero stars SCAM SCAM SCAM
I downloaded this app 7 months ago. NEVER gave it permission to charge me $4.99 a week for the extreme version of whatever. Deleted the 7months ago and have been getting charged every week since.
SCAM SCAM SCAM.
⭐️ SCAM.
Wouldn’t even give them 1 star. Charged money and changed nothing. Still get pop ups, Crashes, questions are the same, nothing good to say. Will not give a refund even though I didn’t get what I paid for
⭐️ Can’t do anything
You literally can’t do anything if you don’t pay the ridiculous amount of money they want you to spend. Those 5 stars were probably from fake accounts that were made by the developers of the game.
⭐️ Disappointed
TWO HUNDRED AND FORTY DOLLARS A YEAR FOR TRUTH OR DARE. Just give me a little x in the top left, top right anywhere. Please. You are under investigation for killing my high, my vibe, and the whole night. You are a bunch of Suckas.
⭐️ Criminal waste of money
Don’t download this app. If you do, make sure you cancel the subscription IMMEDIATELY or else you’ll be bleeding cash out your a**ho** WEEKLY!! I’m all for paid apps, honestly, but these is a blatant money grab with no mercy.
⭐️ cant x out of subscription
i didn’t even get to start when it pops up with the extreme pack that i don’t want obv but there’s no where to click out of it. fix it please!
⭐️ Well something happen
It looked amazing but when I downloaded it, it said “extreme pack” and I didn’t want it but it had no “x” button, and I didn't get to play can you fix it plz and I might give you a 5 star
⭐️ Bad
Because I can’t find the x button for the free trail at the beginning
⭐️ TRASH
THIS GAME IS THE WORST I HAVE SEEN. There is no X button for the subscription so you can’t play the game. Don’t download this game.
⭐️ Trash.
My friends and I were looking for a good party game and I thought WOW! That looks amazing. I downloaded it and i couldn’t exit out of the buy extreme thing.
⭐️ Do NOT download
Sketch AF. There is NO option within the app to unsubscribe and the directions given are not accurate. Just a way to keep you locked in.
⭐️ Pay to Play
There is a paywall after onboarding with no way out of it except quitting the app. Cannot play unless you sign up for the premium free trial.
⭐️ Girl no
This game is horrible. It wouldn’t even let me pay unless I bought exTreMe.
⭐️ So irritating 😤
I am on my iPhone X to play when this subscription pops up I look all over the page but there is no x button so I can’t play so makers of this game pls fix it because I want to play
⭐️ Asked for a review immediately
There is not point in asking my enjoyment level with five seconds of me opening an app for the first time.
Also, there does not appear to be a way to play the free version.
⭐️ F#&k This game
The game is scam. It showed me how to play them Boom! The premium pack comes in and I can’t press on the x because there was no x.
⭐️ WHERE IS THE X
This game is literally FORCING YOU to buy it, when the ad pops up, usually there is an X BUT NO... IT IS NOWHERE. This game is absolutely trash and I would not recommend buying it.
⭐️ Message
How to cancel a subscription?
⭐️ Scam
Forces me to try the free trial for an upgraded game before I can even play the game in general. It says they give you 3 days to cancel, but I’m a pretty sure most people will forget. Looks like a scam to me .
⭐️ Scam
There is no free version, app forces you to accept a short trial period, after which you are ‘conveniently’ charged a weekly fee.
Regular users can see better than Apple how much of a scam this is, but they can't effectively warn anyone else because their rating vote gets drowned in the fake ratings.

And what is Apple doing here?

NOTHING.

Total BS.
If you're wondering how these scammers are getting fake ratings, just google "buy App Store ratings".

It will be an eye-opener.
Oh, and when was the app last updated?

2019.

The scammers are just collecting the money now, no work required.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Kosta Eleftheriou

Kosta Eleftheriou Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @keleftheriou

12 Feb
What Apple doesn’t want you to know about the App Store👇

“The apps you love, from a place you can trust” they tell you. But the reality is far from it.

A 4.5-star app? Might as well be a multi-million dollar scam.

How, you ask?

1/🧵
The average star rating of an app can be *trivially* manipulated by any developer.

Really. Just take a look at this eye-opener of a Quora page:

quora.com/What-are-the-b…
But Kosta, I hear you say. Apple would just take down any app that did that!

Well, no. That might be true in some cases, but scams can go undetected for *years*:

Read 37 tweets
11 Feb
So Apple finally publicly responded to my complaints.

Let's take apart this embarrassingly generic boilerplate statement the gave to The Verge: In a statement given to The...
"investigate and take action on each report"

The most I got out of their official channels when reporting a competitor using "FlickType Keyboard" as the *name* of their subscription IAP?

Competitor changed it to "Type: Flick my keyboard".

Apple considered this "resolved". 🤦
"The App Store is designed to be a safe and trusted place"

Notice how they say "is designed to be" - because they can't say "is".

With so many rampant scams plaguing the store for years unnoticed, how could they say "is"?
Read 11 tweets
10 Feb
Solving the fake ratings issue would solve all of the various problems @_inside and @johnsundell mention here, other than the *really* good counterfeits.

If the ratings are 4.6 stars but all reviews together are 1.6 stars, you don't need any advanced AI to detect.
Also, a huge discrepancy between star rating and refund volume should raise a huge flag.

This scam has been up for years, and is *still* up after all this exposure.

Is Apple even listening?

Nobody would ever be downloading a 1.6 star app.

True ratings would deprive all these scams from their oxygen, and would allow people to come together and protect themselves without relying on a potentially biased decision from any single Apple reviewer.
Read 4 tweets
9 Feb
The App Store has a *massive* fake ratings problem👇

You: an honest developer, working hard for a 4.5 star rating.
Your competitor: a $12M App Store scam, undetected for years.

1/🧵
This app was released early 2016.

With a 4.5 rating from over 150k users, and a price of free, it definitely seems worth downloading: Live Wallpaper Maker - Live4K
Upon first launch, we’re presented with what amounts to a $260/year auto-renewing subscription. I didn’t notice the X button located all the way up there, so I’m gonna assume there’s only one way to proceed here - all those users can’t be wrong, and it’s a free trial after all!
Read 21 tweets
9 Feb
Scammers often make the "Cancel" button of their purchase prompt a "Where's Waldo" of sorts.

Other times it only appears after a few seconds.

Here, there just isn't a way to skip it at all.
You download the app, and it just doesn't work.

Unless you sign up for a $260/year subscription that is, which is what most people will do here.

And here's them pumping their deteriorating rating to 4.4 stars 2 days ago - classic.

The reviews?

1.8 stars
Read 4 tweets
6 Feb
If you ever wondered what scammers can do, my Reddit post exposing them hit the r/Apple frontpage with 100 votes but just got mass-downvoted into oblivion.

And I mean, down to ZERO votes.

The truth won't be hidden for too long, but the scammers surely want to keep it that way. Image
🤦

That's not what happened, @reddit, the downvote bot brigade just got activated. Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!