What happened at the Capitol on January 6 was not like what happened last summer. Nor was it like what happened in Charlottesville. It was a different kind of violence, designed to obstruct the Constitutional process of counting Electoral votes. And it was egged on by Trump.
The bad faith comparisons do nothing to absolve either Trump or the mobbers. The Capitol incident was worse than Portland/Kenosha, etc. or Charlottesville, not because of the intensity or length of the violence, but because of what was attacked. It was treasonous.
This is why Trump's culpability begins well before his speech on January 6. It began when he primed his most intense supporters to believe that he had actually won a landslide victory, but that some bizarre conspiracy involving voting machines and God knows who else "stole" it.
Trump wasn't complaining about "unfair" outside treatment either. He wasn't complaining about a foreign actor or biased media or whatever. No, he was claiming that actual vote tallies were shifted on a grand scale. That is a massive accusation that cannot be leveled casually.
Trump had every right to pursue recourse in the state and Federal courts if his campaign thought there were election irregularities. And those challenges were denied. But not only did Trump ignore the dozens of decisions against him, he doubled down with ever-wilder accusations.
Trump behaved this way because he has no respect for the Constitution he swore an Oath to protect and defend. He even turned on his most loyal ally - Mike Pence - who had the audacity to follow the Constitution. The result of his repeated rejection of the process was violence.
That was his mob that attacked the Capitol. They made it clear that they were "fighting for Trump." Not until hours later did Trump bother to "call off" his seditious mob from ransacking the Capitol. The mobbers should go to prison for a long time. And so should Trump.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aaron Astor

Aaron Astor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AstorAaron

10 Feb
We're at a point where people are setting up bizarre straw expectations and batting them down - and others in the Administration are setting up absurdly low expectations easy to surpass. Here's a thought: Vaccines work. Get them out fast and SARS-Cov-2 will be a minor nuisance.
There will be the need for boosters for years, I'm sure. We'll need to vaccinate kids soon. But the continued existence of SARS-Cov-2 does not mean it is still a "pandemic" as long as serious complications/symptoms go away. And so far all the vaccines prevent serious symptoms.
Speed of production, distribution and administration of vaccines is the most critical component right now. The only thing I really worry about is B.1.1.7's wide circulation among children (as is happening in Israel). Hopefully children's vax will be approved soon.
Read 5 tweets
30 Jan
Pretty important when reporting on Israel's vaccination program that people mention the two-dose regimen. Saying "50% of Israelis are vaccinated!" isn't true. 32.3% got a first dose and 18.4% got a second dose. This is still hugely impressive but it should be reported accurately.
What's really impressive is that 80% of those over 70 years old have received BOTH doses already. And that ~50% of those ages 40-49 have gotten their first dose. As result, new infections among older people have almost disappeared.
As Israel vaccinates more and more people under 40, the number of overall infections will start to decline rapidly. And that should be in the next few weeks. Israel has a fairly young population.
Read 7 tweets
30 Jan
I'm starting to view 2020 as a GOP version of what 1968 was for Dems. The Capitol insurrection mob resembles the Chicago DNC, where an extremist base revolts against its own leaders for selling out. Lots of differences obviously - Cap police didn't beat protestors like in '68.
And Vietnam is not Trumpism. But the political revolt against its own putative leaders and resultant horror at the chaos began self-marginalization of the Democratic Party at the national level that took a long time to reverse.
A few cautionary notes if this parallel holds true. First, the Dems moved further toward the fringe in 1972 before swinging back in 1976. Also, Dems didn't exactly disappear after 1968. Old, local habits persisted for a LONG time. So if there is a shift it will take time.
Read 4 tweets
30 Jan
This map is a thing of beauty. It's amazing how many counties were created in the South in the late 19th c. but then nothing more.
OK so what's the story with the yellow column of counties in West Texas? Did they auction off a couple dozen counties at once?? @tjking @IPAzRGR8
You can see the vaguely triangular counties in Tennessee formed in the 1870s (Loudon, Moore, Hamblen, Chester) and the wedge-shaped ones (Pickett, Clay), basically the spaces between the old 8 miles-to-the-courthouse-radius counties.
Read 4 tweets
18 Jan
Does the "100 million vaccinations in 100 days" mean 100 million people are fully vaccinated? Or does it take into account the two doses (i.e. 50M vaccinated). Or some combination? Because 100M fully (two doses) vaccinated by April 30 would be impressive. 50M, not so much.
@youyanggu defines "immunity from vaccination" as three weeks after the first dose. He estimates 100 million Americans will be fully vaccinated by June 3. That would mean 100M "first dose" administered by May 13 - which is 113 days after inauguration.
So if that's the standard - 100M in 100 days is definitely achievable. We're at over 632k "first doses" per day now; with 2nd doses included we're at 800k per day. But should that be the goal? Or should it be higher?
Read 6 tweets
9 Jan
When a kayfabe POTUS stokes the wildest fantasies of cosplay insurrectionists, and mind-melds his own sense of entitlement with the nihilist drivel of extremely online faux-constitutionalists, you get that shitshow we witnessed at the Capitol.
These guys cultivated a whole industry of survivalist porn - long before Trump or Obama. For most of us it was just a joke. And for some of them it was a joke too. But Trump activated in them a belief that they had a kindred soul in the White House whose power could never fail.
When Trump actually lost an election - and then proclaimed one idiotic "fraud" theory after another - they felt an even closer bond to him. So they thought they were "defending" the "real" Constitution at the Capitol, inspired by whatever fake Founder quote they had in mind.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!