1. THREAD on latest UK Covid Numbers:

A reasonably detailed dive into the latest numbers & (some) implications.

TLDR: things going in right direction but don't think unlocking will be easy.
2. Confirmed cases are still falling & we are back at levels last seen in early December. Positivity rates (accounting for changes in numbers of tests) are also falling in all 4 nations (and in all age groups).

ONS infection survey entirely consistent with this picture.
3. Cases and positivity rates also falling across all English regions & LAs. However, E. Mids, Yorks & Humber and N.East falling slowest.

Obviously falls are GOOD, BUT the green diamonds show where we were at the end of Aug last year.

There is a LONG way to go.
4. Hospital occupancy falling steeply in all UK nations which is GOOD but everywhere still has MORE people in hospital with Covid than they did during the April peak.

ICU occupancy falling more slowly (expected) & much higher than a year ago.

The NHS is still struggling.
5. Deaths have peaked. ONS registered deaths now shows that the 4 peak weeks in April match deaths in January - and we have still to come down. Over half of all deaths have been in these two peak periods.

Reported deaths (more recent data) show that we HAVE peaked.
6. With vaccinations and the ongoing discovery of effective treatments (e.g. recoverytrial.net/news/tocilizum…) means we should never see that many people dying again.

The only thing that could lead to it would be catastrophic failure of policy (inc not mitigating risk of new variants).
7. Vaccinations are continuting to go really really well with about 20% of UK population having now received first dose.

We've vaccinate over 90% of over 75's and almost 75% of 70-74 year olds. This is brilliant.
8. Impact of vaccines take time to show up. At least 2 weeks to get immune response from 1st dose (maybe 3 for over 80s). Then another 2-3 weeks before you'd even start to see an impact on hospitalisations and deaths. Plus not everyone vaccinated at once.
9. Also lockdown messes with the signal... No much sign yet in the hospitalisation data but perhaps tentative sign in deaths (many who die, do not go to hospital) from @d_spiegel work.

Can't say for sure this is vaccinations, but it is consistent with a vaccination effect.
10. Enouragingly, outbreaks in care homes now falling sharply. If almost all care home residents have been vaccinated and most care home staff, these should fall further.

If there is an issue with delaying 2nd dose for older people, it will become apparent first in care homes.
11. Israel saw sharp reductions in cases and hospitalisations in people over 60 - 90% of whom are now vaccinated. Israel also doing a 3 week vaccination schedule with Pfizer. Effects really started showing 6-7 weeks in.

We should start to see clear signals by end of February.
12. But 90% of cases are in under 70s - so vaccination won't do much to prevent cases spreading if we open up.

Some thoughts about it. Firstly, there remain outbreaks in nurseries (open) and primary schools (about 20% of pupils attending). As schools open, these will go up.
13. We need to monitor cases carefully and do all we can to make schools as safe as possible for returning students and staff.
independentsage.org/the-return-to-…
14. Lockdown exacerbates inequality - not least in exposure. Younger adults in more deprived communities more likely to get Covid - much harder for them to shelter at home. And many live in overcrowded housing which also increases exposure.
15. This should incentivise govt to do more to make workplaces safer & provide accommodation to those who cannot isolate safely at home (and proper financial support).

It also means that as restrictions ease, more people will become exposed as their leave their homes
16. The best mitigation, especially given our more transmissible strain, is to get and keep cases extremely low and do it with proper find, test, trace & SUPPORTED isolation system. Plus a slow and phased reopening to monitor for increasing transmission.
17. Internationally, the "Kent" strain is spreading to different amount across Europe. Govts are keeping strong restrictions to prevent it dominating, but B117 still becoming slowly dominant. Could lead to big March spikes there.

NB Spain had a big post Xmas surge
18. Countries where the "Kent" strain (B117) is already dominant saw massive surges as B117 took hold pre lockdowns. Harsh restrictions in all countries got it under control but - as I already said - coming safely out will be a big challenge.
19. Next week, @IndependentSage will lay out in more detail how we think we can exit lockdown safely - and, more to the point - make sure we *never* go back into one. END
Ps thanks so much to Bob Hawkins, @cfinnecy and @lukemshepherd for help in preparing charts, organising and discussing data!!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Christina Pagel

Christina Pagel Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @chrischirp

9 Feb
MINI THREAD: One way in which the Kent (B117) variant might help us vs SA variant... Both are more transmissible that older variants & so quickly become dominant.

BUT SA not more transmissible than Kent (we think) - so Kent, already dominant in UK, should stay dominant. 1/2
This is good because all vaccines work well against Kent (B117) & it doesn't seem to be re-infecting people who've already had covid.

But SA can re-infect people & evade (somewhat) AZ vax. Unknown is how that might help SA over time as it has more people it can spread to. 2/2
Read 4 tweets
6 Feb
THREAD ON FLU:
Just an attempt to start a conversation about annual flu.

I'm not an expert on this at all and welcome people's thoughts and insights...

Basic question is: how many annual flu deaths are acceptable? 1/7
In a "normal" year there might be c. 10,000 deaths from flu in England & Wales, mostly in people over 65.(greenwichccg.nhs.uk/News-Publicati…),

Timing & number varies depending on flu strain, how good that year's vaccine is & vaccine uptake.

Flu is also LESS infectious than Covid. 2/7
And the measures that work against Covid, work against Flu -> so this year we've seen HARDLY ANY flu.

The chart below compares English hospital flu admissions - but same picture for GP swabs, 111 calls etc.

Same across Europe (flunewseurope.org) 3/7
Read 7 tweets
29 Jan
SHORT THREAD ON SCHOOLS:
When schools go back is a tricky issue. I'm not going to get into it here BUT wanted to highlight a couple of data points from PHE surveillance & ONS infection survey this week. 1/5
Firstly, since early Jan, there have been a number of outbreaks at nurseries (open) & special need schools (30% attendance) (and yes - Covid).

A few at primary schools (20% attendance) and v few at 2nd-ary schools (5% attendance). 2/5
Added to that among young school age kids, case rates going down for primary school ages but UP in pre-school and nursery age children.

Secondary school age going down (not shown). 3/5
Read 5 tweets
29 Jan
MINI THREAD ON HOSPITALISATIONS:

The number of people in hospital with Covid is either flat or coming down in all 4 nations - excellent and a sign that infections really are going down (at least in older groups).

BUT they are still higher than April peak everywhere 1/4
In England, hospital admissions are now coming steadily down from 12th Jan peak and are now below the April peak too... good! 2/4
This is true for all regions of England (good!). You can see that they started going down in previous tier 4 regions (London, SE, EoE) about 7-10 days earlier than other regions. 3/4
Read 4 tweets
26 Jan
Giving some examples on @BBCOne @BBCNews just now about why we we could have - and should have - avoided more than100,000 people dying from Covid.
Other missed opportunities: not making workplaces safer (e.g. DVLA, Sainsbury outbreak, high care worker deaths), not making schools safer, not anticipating uni surges in autumn, etc...
But I did say, and do believe, that the vaccination programme is going very well. So let's acknowledge that at least.
Read 4 tweets
20 Jan
THREAD: we need start planning for the recovery of NHS staff right now.

NHS staff are working beyond their limits – have been for weeks and will continue to for weeks. They've been at the limit for a year. What will be the consequences? What can be done?

Please do read. 1/12
NHS workers are already at higher risk of mental health problems & suicide than general population. Studies pre- pandemic showed that UK nurses & docs were 2-5 times more likely to take their own lives than the general pop.
metro.co.uk/2018/09/03/sui…
independentnurse.co.uk/professional-a… 2/12
The British Medical Association did a survey after the 1st covid wave. 45% of ICU staff showed signs of mental ill-health, 40% with signs of PTSD, more than 2x recent combat veterans. 1 in 5 nurses & 1 in 7 docs had thoughts of self-harm or suicide.
bmj.com/content/372/bm… 3/12
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!