I've heard people endlessly complain about cebrity culture, the worthlesness of being on social media, etc.
Along comes one bluecheck with some decent positions and everyone's like "he's the biggest asset we've ever had, you don't understand His plan."
The demands seem to be:
1) be grateful that a famous person echoed some of your work 2) be content with any partial understanding 3) be tolerant of repeated trashing of book clubs (which is how the research got done in the first place)
I disagree on all counts, of course.
I've always been diplomatic when disagreeing with Q/Andray, and this is how he lashed out last time I called out his unprompted mocking of book clubs.
Didn't see anyone demand he calm down or anything.
Why the double standard?
Is this drama? Am I annoyed? Yes, of course.
I'm gonna let it go, naturally, but I wanted to be clear on *why* it bothers me.
When I start hearing communists sound like Jordan Peterson fans ("you don't understand!", "out of context!"), it seems like celebrity culture to me.
Someone showed me some "Anarchist Ugyhur Genocide Debunk Debunk" video.
I don't want anything to do with these people.
Anarchism is an ideology that says its members should *not* be holding each other accountable, and it results in this.
Down with "lefty unity."
me: Up to my neck in research explaining every major action by the USSR, China, Cuba, the BPP, etc.
them: Proudhon and Bakunin's antisemitism irrelevant, Bey's pedophilia irrelevant, CHAZ murders irrelevant. Anarchism cannot be held accountable for any one anarchist's actions.
These people dismiss @moghilemear13's absolutely brilliant research work as "just a medium blog" only to turn around and shovel Adrian Zenz's medium blog in their source list.
And for all the "No Gods No Masters" preaching, they sure do have a lot of respect for AP and the NYT!
A lot of this Marxism vs. Religion discussion seems to be approached by people trying to show off how inclusive and open-minded they are, rather than breaking down the problem into constituent elements and explaining how to tackle them.
The problem with unchecked religious organizing is real and concrete.
The case of coup-era Bolivia is a very clear example of radicalized cops on the streets chanting prayers, before they charge in to slaughter indigenous people.
Tsk tsk, seeing some Canadians out there not buying into the Canadian propaganda blitz that baselessly projects our own crimes and atrocities onto China to feel better about ourselves.