2/ Right in the abstract here under "implications for public health practice", CDC says:
"To reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission in fitness facilities, attendees should wear a mask, including during high-intensity activities when ≥6 ft apart."
So the 6 foot rule has limits...why?
3/ Because of smaller particles- aerosols- that spread farther than six feet, & hang around for more than 15 minutes.
And CDC acknowledges that; but is still hesitant to send people #BetterMasks (announced today they are sending cloth masks)? C'mon man. What is going on?
3.5/ "Although the timing of cases suggests a point-source exposure, none was identified. Most interviewees attended several exercise classes.
Some published evidence supports aerosolized transmission of SARS-CoV-2, which could have been a contributing factor in this outbreak"
4/ "Although the facility’s ventilation system was not assessed, inadequate air circulation might have exacerbated transmission in the building, which was not originally designed for exercise classes" #covid19
Better ventilation. #betterMasks. We need these in the community.
4.5/ "In addition, facilities should provide engineering & admin controls incl 1) improving ventilation; 2) enforcing consistent + correct mask use & physical distancing (maintaining ≥6 ft of distance b/w all persons & limiting physical contact, class size, & crowded spaces)"
5/ "All classes were held at ≤25% capacity (i.e., 10–15 persons). Mask use, temperature checks, and symptom screenings were required on entry; however, patrons were allowed to remove masks during exercise."
**Why would they focus on temp checks but not require masks?**
6/ Big take-aways/reminders:
-#covid19 spread happens within AND beyond 6 ft; 15 mins
-#Bettermasks and better ventilation = better protection
-Rigorous exercise--> more emission of droplets & aerosols
🧵 1/ So I read this @BostonGlobe story today about what is going to be reopening in Massachusetts on Monday - restaurants will have *no capacity limit* and can host *musical performances*(??)
Hmm interesting.
So I decided to check again what % we have vaccinated #covid19 ...
2/ So we are at 6.2% in terms of people who have received two doses; 16% for those who have received one dose
So...we aren’t even close to where we need to be for vaccinations, we got lucky to see a rapid decline in cases, but now we are rapid reopening
🧵1/ So CDC published a couple of outbreak investigations from gyms yesterday— heavy breathing, incomplete mask use, aerosols 🗣 —> superspreading #covid19
But we knew this was risky from a May 2020 outbreak in exercise classes in South Korea already...
2/ This was published in May 2020 in the @CDC_EIDjournal - they found that rigorous exercise was associated w/ transmission whereas low intensity (Pilates, yoga) was not.
🧵1/ Sometimes when you push for an idea for long enough (#BetterMasks) & when the logic makes sense to you- but you are continuously told by other “experts” (CDC leadership) that it’s not needed; you begin to wonder if you yourself are missing something. #covid19
2/ But- the other factors at play- the political ones- make me think otherwise.
If CDC said “yes better masks are better; yes they protect you more”, they are now on the hook for getting these to people.
But- if they don’t have the bandwidth or political backing to do it...
3/ Then they can’t acknowledge it.
But- because we (many of us) pushed for #BetterMasks incessantly, they probably had to do something.
So they did a study with two masks, which worked better than one mask; two masks is easy bc it’s still on the public to figure it out.
Another @CDCgov report today on #covid19 from unmasked exercise classes
The secondary attack rate of infection from instructors to class participants for classes taught within 1 day of symptom onset was 95% (20 of 21)!
And again here, we have CDC 🗣 about aerosol transmission
2/ Transmission despite 6 feet apart w/ instructors yelling during stationary cycling class #covid19
3/ One of the instructors was teaching kickboxing & personal training - two of the infected participants wore masks and were *still infected* #covid19 #BetterMasks
1/ Last night had a conversation w/ a close friend about #covid19 & life— one of the points we kept coming back to—> risk aversion is a *privilege*
The risk you are willing to take at the end of the day depends on how badly you need to get food on the table. Period.
2/ When we think about #covid19 & we look at who was getting sick, we saw two main groups emerging early on— vulnerable nursing home residents and essential frontline workers w/o the privilege of ‘staying home’
Folks w/ either high health risk or high exposure risk
3/ From that latter group, many who ended up being my direct patients— life wasn’t about how do I avoid #covid19 as much as it was about how do I keep the lights on; how do I continue to feed my kids; how do I find another job if this one is shut down etc
2/ I have treated people who have suffered from #covid19 but said that actually losing their job, relapsing to substance abuse, being afflicted by depression/suicidality was even worse.
For some, it was not even a life worth living at all.
3/ I have also seen a ton of shaming around social activities on Twitter.
“Can’t believe this person did that” etc
We don’t know what other people are going through.
That doesn’t mean condoning all social activities- but it also doesn’t mean stigmatizing all of them either.