Broadly, I'm not sure how much value my writing twitter threads provides, relative to the costs.
Ostensibly, more people see my twitter threads than my blog posts (I think), but I suspect the QUALITY of the engagement is much lower for twitter.
For twitter, I think most people are casually scrolling through their feeds, giving momentary attention to things that seem interesting.
And I guess that that kind of engagement is 10 to 1000 times less likely to cause any kind of permanent shift in anyone's understanding of anything, or in their behavior, compared to the way that people typically read blog posts.
(I would be quite curious to hear corroborating or conflicting personal experience, on that point.
Do any of you have specific twitter thread that left a lasting effect on your thought or action?)
Plus, twitter content is typically ephemeral. It gets most of the engagement it is ever going to get in the first few days, and then fades into the fog of the internet.
I do feel that the twitter thread is somehow a different format than the micro-blog post. Since I've been posting here, I've been finding myself having different more twitter-shaped thoughts.
Part of this is that twitter threads are linear and un-plotted, in the way that a blog post is usually more of a structured tree, which makes it easier to write without necessarily knowing where I'm going. It's just one chunk at a time.
I don't have to have a thesis.
But most of my threads them take about as much time to write as a blog post.
So I want to try to convert my twitter-posting thoughts into blog-post format instead, and see what happens.
If here's something you think I should see, or respond to on twitter, feel free to ping me about it. I might not see it otherwise.
Also, I add virtually all my twitter threads to threadreader. In case you, like me, want to read threads more slowly and careful, and not in the mix of twitter, you can find mine here.
(Unfortunately, @threadreaderapp does have random-seeming constraints on what shows up on an author's page (must be a top level thread, longer than 4 tweets).
It will unroll other sorts of threads, but they won't show up on an other's page, for some reason.)
Although, it does still bother me when people blame "capitalism", in particular.
I guess because it is particularly infuriating when one of the very few the incredible, amazing, generators of enormous historical good is blamed for bad things.
I want to compile all of my twitter threads that touch on what I care about in a romantic partnership / spiritual collaboration.
This is largely for my own reference.
However, it occurs to me that a bunch of disparate threads, each of which was alive when I wrote it, and each dealing with a different facet, might in aggregate, be a good way of conveying the ephemeral thing-ness of my experience.
I'm increasingly resistant to try and describe what I want in this domain in any kind of top-down way, because when I try, my descriptions often feel "flat" to me, and more-often-than-not I feel missed or projected on.
In particular his analogy of a calculator (for a computational view of the self) is great.
"The point is to realize that both The Physics Explanation and The Math Explanation are true, and in _fact the entire purpose of the calculator is to make them coincide_."
This points directly at the source of the horror that I've expressed in the other thread.
Being physically implemented, all change has to be physically implemented.
But some change is the result of the system taking inputs, responding to them, reflecting on itself, and changing the way that it operates, often it quite radical ways.
Does anyone else find being an embedded / naturalistic agent disturbing?
Like, I could be injected with a chemical that would cause my cells to make new proteins, which could alter my brain.
It could change the algorithm that this body is running.
Which, from a computational theory of identity, is to say that you could inject me with a chemical that would delete ME, and replace me with someone else.
That's horrifying. It feels like one of the things that "shouldn't be allowed".